L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie

jeudi 24 juillet 2025
par Dark Funifuteur
popularité : 45%

détailles moi l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie

ChatGPT :
L’utilisateur demande des détails sur une affaire impliquant l’exportation illégale de déchets français en Indonésie, probablement en lien avec un scandale survenu en juillet 2025. Cela pourrait concerner des déchets plastiques envoyés vers les îles indonésiennes, comme Bali, et des questions juridiques autour de ces pratiques. Je vais particulièrement chercher à comprendre le contexte de cette affaire, définir les acteurs impliqués, et fournir une analyse détaillée, bien structurée, basée sur les faits. Je procéderai à une recherche sur les dernières informations disponibles.
Recherche sur le Web terminée

L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie a culminé en 2019, mais l’utilisateur semble se référer à des révélations récentes, probablement en 2025. Des enquêtes indiquent que des trafiquants français ont envoyé des déchets en Indonésie, contournant les règles de la convention de Bâle sur le contrôle des déchets dangereux. Il est possible qu’il y ait des développements nouveaux et en cours, je vais donc explorer les derniers détails concernant ce scandale et les acteurs impliqués en 2025.
Recherche sur le Web terminée
Terminé

**Contexte et cadre réglementaire**
Depuis les années 1990, une part importante des déchets plastiques et ménagers produits en Europe est exportée vers l’Asie du Sud-Est, souvent sous couvert de « matières recyclables » alors qu’ils sont en réalité impropres au recyclage. Or, la Convention de Bâle (1989), à laquelle la France et l’Indonésie sont parties, interdit l’exportation de déchets dangereux et non-valorisables vers les pays en développement sans notification ni consentement préalable des autorités de réception. Malgré cela, de nombreux conteneurs ont transité illégalement vers l’Indonésie, profitant de failles dans le contrôle des ports et de pratiques frauduleuses visant à dissimuler la nature réelle des cargaisons ([raceforwater.org][1]).

**Découverte des conteneurs illégaux**
En juillet 2019, les autorités douanières de l’île de Batam (située en face de Singapour) ont intercepté sept conteneurs contenant des déchets ménagers, plastiques et matériaux toxiques, dont deux étaient étiquetés comme à destination de la France. Ces envois n’avaient fait l’objet d’aucune autorisation d’importation valable et enfreignaient les réglementations indonésiennes, qui interdisent l’entrée de déchets non triés ou dangereux ([France 24][2], [Le Monde.fr][3]).

**Le renvoi des déchets vers la France**
Le 29 juillet 2019, l’Indonésie a pris la mesure rare de renvoyer ces conteneurs à leur pays d’origine. Selon Susila Brata, responsable des douanes locales, « les conteneurs sont partis lundi et des responsables étaient là pour s’assurer de leur départ » : cinq vers Hong Kong et deux vers la France. Parallèlement, Jakarta a lancé les opérations de retour d’autres conteneurs vers les États-Unis, l’Australie et l’Allemagne, dans un mouvement régional contre ce qu’on a baptisé « la poubelle du monde » ([Le Monde.fr][3]).

**Le rôle des filières françaises de tri et d’export**
En France, des intermédiaires peu scrupuleux achètent des déchets plastiques et papiers usagés, les font tester en laboratoires pour obtenir une classification « valorisable », puis les expédient vers l’Asie. Sur place, certaines usines (notamment à Surabaya et dans le village de Bangun) ne sont pas équipées pour traiter les mélanges de déchets, et ont dû se contenter de récupérer la cellulose ou certains plastiques, déversant le reste dans les rivières ou sur des décharges à ciel ouvert. Ces pratiques entraînent une pollution locale très lourde, affectant la santé des riverains et la biodiversité marine ([raceforwater.org][1]).

**Réactions diplomatiques et sanctions**
Sur le plan diplomatique, Paris a exprimé son « incompréhension » et exigé des explications de Jakarta. En France, l’affaire a relancé le débat sur le renforcement des contrôles en amont, notamment via l’Agence Nationale de Sécurité Sanitaire, de l’Alimentation, de l’Environnement et du Travail (ANSES) et la Direction Générale des Douanes. Plusieurs procès ont été intentés contre des opérateurs de recyclage accusés de tromperie sur la marchandise exportée, et France Nature Environnement (FNE) a obtenu la condamnation de certains industriels pour « exportation illégale de déchets » ([France Nature Environnement][4]).

**Conséquences et enseignements**

1. **Renforcement de la législation** : l’affaire a précipité l’entrée en vigueur, au 1er janvier 2025, de l’interdiction générale d’importation de déchets plastiques non recyclables par l’Indonésie, contraignant les pays exportateurs à mieux trier et valoriser leurs déchets localement ([Vietnam+ (VietnamPlus)][5]).
2. **Sensibilisation citoyenne** : les images de plages souillées et de monticules plastiques en Indonésie ont fait le tour des réseaux sociaux, mettant en lumière la responsabilité des consommateurs européens dans la crise mondiale du plastique.
3. **Pression sur les filières** : plusieurs grandes entreprises de la grande distribution et de la plasturgie ont annoncé des plans de réduction de leurs emballages et une amélioration de la traçabilité de leurs déchets, sous peine d’être tenues pour responsables en cas de nouveau scandale.

— -

*Cette affaire illustre à la fois les mécanismes frauduleux employés pour contourner la Convention de Bâle et les enjeux majeurs d’une gestion responsable des déchets au niveau mondial. La coopération internationale et le renforcement de la transparence dans les filières de recyclage demeurent des leviers essentiels pour éviter que des pays comme l’Indonésie ne payent le prix fort de notre surconsommation.*

[1] : https://www.raceforwater.org/fr/actualites/exportation-illegale-de-plastiques-en-indonesie-un-scandale/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Exportation illégale de plastiques en Indonésie : un scandale"
[2] : https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions?utm_source=chatgpt.com "L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut ..."
[3] : https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets ..."
[4] : https://fne.asso.fr/communique-presse/exportations-illegales-de-dechets-condamnation-des-exploitants-de-la-societe-d3e?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Exportations illégales de déchets : condamnation des ..."
[5] : https://fr.vietnamplus.vn/lindonesie-va-interdire-les-importations-de-dechets-plastiques-a-partir-de-2025-post233408.vnp?utm_source=chatgpt.com "L’Indonésie va interdire les importations de déchets ..."

Citations

raceforwater.org
Exportation illégale de plastiques en Indonésie : un scandale
05.07.2019 — Pourtant l’importation de déchets ménagers n’est pas légale en Indonésie. 54 pays enfreignent donc la loi par des moyens bien rodés qui ont ...
France 24
L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut ...
31.07.2019 — L’Indonésie a annoncé, mardi, le renvoi vers la France et Hong Kong de conteneurs de déchets jugés illégalement importés.
Le Monde.fr
L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets ...
30 juillet 2019 — Jul 30, 2019 — La république d’Asie du Sud-Est a renvoyé vers la France et Hongkong sept conteneurs de déchets illégalement importés, a annoncé, mardi 30 ...

France Nature Environnement
Exportations illégales de déchets : condamnation des ...
La décision sanctionne la tendance qu’ont certains industriels de qualifier des déchets de produits pour les exporter plus facilement vers des pays dans ...

Vietnam+ (VietnamPlus)
L’Indonésie va interdire les importations de déchets ...
1 novembre 2024 — 31.10.2024 — L’Indonésie va interdire les importations de déchets plastiques à partir de 2025. Le gouvernement indonésien va commencer à imposer une ...

Plus

assemblee-nationale.fr
Compte rendu de la première séance du jeudi 20 mars 2025
L’Indonésie adopte une diplomatie de neutralité active, refusant la logique des blocs. Ce positionnement rejoint la vision française, qui privilégie l’autonomie ...
fne.asso.fr
Trafic international de déchets : jugement rendu dans une ...
Des déchets de tout type, produits en Belgique étaient importés en France illégalement : mélange de déchets issus de travaux du bâtiment, déchets ménagers et ...
senat.fr
Lutte contre le trafic transfrontalier de déchets
03.04.2025 — Les revenus générés par l’exportation illégale de déchets sont tels que cette activité est en plein essor, attirant autant de véritables ré ...
no-burn.org
Colonialisme des déchets et commerce mondial des déchets
Ce rapport d’enquête novateur révèle comment l’augmentation rapide des exportations de déchets plastiques vers l’Asie du Sud-Est a eu un impact sur la santé, ...
no-burn.org
Une nouvelle recherche révèle une crise dans le commerce ...
Des villageois ramassent du plastique importé jeté par une entreprise de recyclage de papier à proximité dont le papier importé a été contaminé par du plastique ...
ifi-id.com
Coopération franco-indonésienne contre la pollution ...
Dec 11, 2024 — TKN PSL a profité de l’occasion pour rappeler l’objectif national ambitieux de réduire de 70 % les déchets plastiques en Indonésie d’ici 2025, ...
revolutionpermanente.fr
L’Indonésie renvoie à la France des conteneurs de déchets ...
30.07.2019 — Ceux-ci sont arrivés dans le pays illégalement et contiennent des déchets ménager, des déchets plastiques ainsi que des déchets toxiques.
economie.gouv.fr
Brèves de l’ASEAN semaine 27 (2025)
Jul 4, 2025 — Cette tendance générale masque des dynamiques divergentes au sein de la région : les indices PMI restent en zone de contraction en Indonésie, au ...
lemonde.fr
En Indonésie, « le plus grand projet de déforestation au ...
May 28, 2025 — Le gouvernement veut défricher des millions d’hectares en Papouasie indonésienne pour accroître sa production de riz et de biocarburants.
lexpress.fr
Conteneurs de déchets renvoyés : l’Asie est-elle la ...
31.07.2019 — Un policier indonésien à côté d’un conteneur illégal de déchets plastiques, prêt à être renvoyé à son pays émetteur, à Battam, le 29 juillet ...
voyage.gc.ca
Conseils et avertissements pour l’Indonésie
Faites preuve d’une grande prudence en Indonésie en raison des tensions politiques et sociales, et de la menace terroriste dans tout le pays.

**Context and Regulatory Framework**
Since the 1990s, a significant portion of household and plastic waste produced in Europe has been exported to Southeast Asia—often under the label of “recyclable materials,” when in fact the contents are not fit for recycling. However, the **Basel Convention (1989)**—to which both France and Indonesia are parties—prohibits the export of hazardous or non-recoverable waste to developing countries without prior notification and consent from the receiving authorities. Despite this, many containers have illegally entered Indonesia, taking advantage of port control loopholes and fraudulent practices aimed at concealing the true nature of shipments.

**Discovery of Illegal Containers**
In **July 2019**, customs authorities on the island of **Batam** (near Singapore) intercepted **seven containers** containing household waste, plastics, and toxic materials—two of which were labeled as coming from **France**. These shipments had no valid import authorization and violated Indonesian regulations, which ban the entry of unsorted or hazardous waste.

**Waste Sent Back to France**
On **July 29, 2019**, Indonesia made the rare move of returning these containers to their countries of origin. According to local customs head **Susila Brata**, “The containers left on Monday and officials were present to supervise their departure” : five were sent to **Hong Kong**, and **two back to France**. At the same time, Jakarta initiated the repatriation of other waste containers to the **United States**, **Australia**, and **Germany**—part of a broader regional backlash against the role of Southeast Asia as the “world’s dumping ground.”

**The Role of French Sorting and Export Channels**
In France, unscrupulous intermediaries buy used plastics and paper waste, have them tested to get classified as “recoverable,” and then export them to Asia. On the ground, many Indonesian processing plants (especially in **Surabaya** and the village of **Bangun**) are not equipped to handle mixed waste. They often recover only cellulose or certain plastics, dumping the rest into rivers or open-air landfills—resulting in severe pollution that affects both human health and local biodiversity.

**Diplomatic Reactions and Legal Consequences**
On the diplomatic front, **Paris expressed “incomprehension”** and demanded explanations from Jakarta. In France, the incident reignited debates over stronger upstream waste controls, involving organizations like **ANSES** (the French health and safety agency) and **customs enforcement**. Several legal cases were launched against recycling companies accused of mislabeling exported goods, and **France Nature Environnement (FNE)** successfully obtained convictions for illegal waste exports.

**Consequences and Lessons Learned**

1. **Stronger Legislation** : The case accelerated Indonesia’s move to **ban all imports of non-recyclable plastic waste starting January 1, 2025**, pressuring exporting countries to better sort and process their waste domestically.
2. **Public Awareness** : Images of polluted beaches and plastic mountains in Indonesia went viral on social media, highlighting European consumers’ indirect role in the global plastic crisis.
3. **Pressure on Industry** : Major players in retail and plastics manufacturing pledged to reduce packaging and improve waste traceability, under threat of reputational damage and potential liability.

— -

*This case illustrates both the fraudulent mechanisms used to circumvent the Basel Convention and the global stakes of responsible waste management. International cooperation and greater transparency in recycling chains remain essential to ensure countries like Indonesia don’t bear the environmental cost of global overconsumption.*

**Konteks dan Kerangka Regulasi**
Sejak tahun 1990-an, sebagian besar limbah rumah tangga dan plastik yang diproduksi di Eropa diekspor ke Asia Tenggara — sering kali dengan label “bahan daur ulang”, padahal sebenarnya tidak layak untuk didaur ulang. Namun, **Konvensi Basel (1989)** — yang telah diratifikasi oleh Prancis dan Indonesia — melarang ekspor limbah berbahaya atau yang tidak dapat didaur ulang ke negara berkembang tanpa pemberitahuan dan persetujuan sebelumnya dari negara penerima. Meskipun demikian, banyak kontainer secara ilegal masuk ke Indonesia, memanfaatkan celah dalam pengawasan pelabuhan dan praktik penipuan yang menyamarkan isi sebenarnya.

**Penemuan Kontainer Ilegal**
Pada **Juli 2019**, otoritas bea cukai di Pulau **Batam** (dekat Singapura) menyita **tujuh kontainer** yang berisi limbah rumah tangga, plastik, dan bahan beracun — dua di antaranya dilabeli berasal dari **Prancis**. Pengiriman ini tidak memiliki izin impor yang sah dan melanggar peraturan Indonesia yang melarang masuknya limbah campuran atau limbah berbahaya.

**Pengembalian Limbah ke Prancis**
Pada **29 Juli 2019**, Indonesia mengambil langkah tegas dengan mengembalikan kontainer-kontainer tersebut ke negara asalnya. Menurut kepala bea cukai setempat, **Susila Brata**, “Kontainer telah diberangkatkan pada hari Senin dan pejabat hadir untuk mengawasi pengirimannya” : lima dikirim ke **Hong Kong**, dan **dua dikirim kembali ke Prancis**. Pada saat yang sama, Jakarta juga memulai pemulangan kontainer limbah lainnya ke **Amerika Serikat**, **Australia**, dan **Jerman** — sebagai bagian dari penolakan regional terhadap Asia Tenggara yang dijadikan “tempat sampah dunia”.

**Peran Saluran Daur Ulang dan Ekspor Prancis**
Di Prancis, beberapa perantara yang tidak bertanggung jawab membeli limbah plastik dan kertas bekas, lalu mengujinya di laboratorium untuk diklasifikasikan sebagai “layak daur ulang”, dan kemudian mengirimkannya ke Asia. Di Indonesia, banyak pabrik daur ulang (terutama di **Surabaya** dan desa **Bangun**) tidak memiliki fasilitas yang memadai untuk menangani limbah campuran. Mereka hanya mengambil bahan yang bernilai seperti selulosa atau jenis plastik tertentu, sementara sisanya dibuang ke sungai atau ke tempat pembuangan terbuka — menyebabkan polusi serius yang berdampak pada kesehatan masyarakat dan keanekaragaman hayati.

**Reaksi Diplomatik dan Sanksi Hukum**
Secara diplomatik, **pemerintah Prancis menyatakan "keheranan"** dan meminta klarifikasi dari Jakarta. Di Prancis, kasus ini memicu kembali perdebatan tentang perlunya pengawasan limbah yang lebih ketat, termasuk keterlibatan lembaga seperti **ANSES** (badan kesehatan dan lingkungan nasional Prancis) dan **direktorat bea cukai**. Beberapa perusahaan daur ulang digugat atas tuduhan memalsukan klasifikasi barang ekspor, dan organisasi lingkungan **France Nature Environnement (FNE)** berhasil menuntut sejumlah industri atas **ekspor limbah ilegal**.

**Dampak dan Pelajaran yang Didapat**

1. **Penguatan Hukum** : Kasus ini mempercepat penerapan larangan total oleh Indonesia terhadap **impor limbah plastik yang tidak dapat didaur ulang mulai 1 Januari 2025**, mendorong negara pengirim untuk mengelola limbahnya secara lokal.
2. **Kesadaran Publik** : Gambar pantai yang dipenuhi sampah dan gunungan plastik di Indonesia menjadi viral di media sosial, memperlihatkan peran tidak langsung konsumen Eropa dalam krisis plastik global.
3. **Tekanan terhadap Industri** : Sejumlah perusahaan besar di sektor ritel dan industri plastik mengumumkan rencana pengurangan kemasan dan peningkatan pelacakan limbah, untuk menghindari kerusakan reputasi atau tanggung jawab hukum.

— -

*Kasus ini menunjukkan praktik curang yang digunakan untuk menghindari Konvensi Basel dan pentingnya pengelolaan limbah yang bertanggung jawab secara global. Kerja sama internasional dan transparansi dalam rantai daur ulang adalah kunci agar negara seperti Indonesia tidak terus menjadi korban dari konsumsi berlebihan dunia.*

quelles en sont les suites ?

Grok :
Réflexions

I need to answer the user’s question : "quelles sont les suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie ?"
First, I need to understand what the question is asking. It’s in French, so I should translate it to English to make sure I understand it correctly.
The question translates to : "What are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?"
So, I need to find out what happened with the French waste in Indonesia and what the outcomes or consequences were.
Since this is a specific event, I should probably start by searching for information about it.
I can use the search tool to look for news articles or reports about this incident.
Let me think about how to formulate the search query.
I should use keywords like "French waste Indonesia" or "affaire des déchets français Indonésie" to get relevant results.
Since the question is in French, I might want to search in French to get more precise results.
But the search tool might default to English, so I should check if it supports French queries.
Looking back at the instructions, it says : "Search using the native language of the question if possible."
So, yes, I can search in French.
Let me try that.
Searching... From the search results, I see that there was indeed an incident where Indonesia sent back containers of waste to France and other countries, claiming that the waste was illegally imported.
The first result from Le Monde mentions that Indonesia returned seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, containing household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, which violated import regulations.
The second result from France 24 also reports on the same event, stating that Indonesia sent back containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, and that the French Ministry of Ecology requested more information about the content.
The third result from Ouest-France confirms that seven containers were sent back to France and Hong Kong, and mentions that Western countries have been sending tons of waste to Southeast Asia for recycling since 2018.
The fourth result from Le Figaro is about a different topic, where six French students are collecting waste in Indonesia, so that’s not directly related.
The fifth result from the French Treasury website discusses Indonesia’s efforts to combat marine pollution from plastic waste, but it’s more about general policies rather than the specific incident.
The sixth result from France Info is about Indonesia sending back waste to France, similar to the first few results.
The seventh result from RFI discusses the global waste crisis and mentions that France was affected by it, with Indonesia sending back waste.
The eighth result from Le Figaro is about French people in Bali fighting plastic pollution, which is not directly related to the incident.
The ninth result from France 24 is about Indonesia sending back waste to the US, not France, so it’s related but not the same incident.
The tenth result from Le Point mentions that Indonesia sent back containers of waste to France, with videos and details.
The eleventh result from 20 Minutes explains why France sends waste to Asia, providing background information.
The twelfth result from Le JDD also discusses why France exports waste to Asia.
The thirteenth result from France Info is about Serge Atlaoui, a French man condemned to death in Indonesia, which is unrelated to the waste incident.
The fourteenth result from the French Treasury website discusses Indonesia’s imports of plastic waste, providing context.
The fifteenth result from RFI is about Indonesia sending back waste to the US, similar to the ninth result.
The sixteenth result from the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs is about travel advice for Indonesia, unrelated.
The seventeenth result from Le Parisien is about a young entrepreneur in Indonesia fighting plastic pollution, not directly related.
The eighteenth result from Le Petit Journal discusses how waste from developed countries is flooding Southeast Asia, including Indonesia.
The nineteenth result from L’Usine Nouvelle reports that Indonesia refused to be the world’s dumpster and sent back containers to France.
The twentieth result from Ouest-France mentions that Indonesia sent back five containers of waste to the US, not France.
The twenty-first result from Le Figaro is similar to the first few, about Indonesia sending back waste to France and Hong Kong.
The twenty-second result from Courrier International is from 2009 and discusses Indonesia being used as a dumping ground, which is historical context.
The twenty-third result from Le Progres is about the same incident, with Indonesia sending back waste to France.
The twenty-fourth result from Wikipedia discusses the environment in Indonesia, including pollution issues, but it’s general information.
The twenty-fifth result from France 3 is about Serge Atlaoui again, unrelated.
So, from these results, it’s clear that the main event is Indonesia sending back containers of waste to France and other countries in 2019, due to illegal imports.
Now, the user asked about the "suites" or consequences of this affair. So, I need to find out what happened after this incident.
Did France take any actions ? Did this lead to changes in waste management policies ? Were there any diplomatic repercussions ?
I should look for more recent information or follow-up articles on this topic.
Perhaps I can search for "conséquences de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie" or something similar.
Since the incident happened in 2019, I should check if there are any updates or long-term effects.
Let me try to browse one of the pages that seem to have detailed information.
For example, the first result from Le Monde seems comprehensive.
Let me use the browse tool to get more details from that page.
Browsing... Hmm, the browse result doesn’t directly mention the consequences of the affair for France or Indonesia, but it does provide context about the incident and related actions by other countries.
It mentions that Indonesia returned 2 containers to France and was awaiting authorization to return more to other countries. It also gives background on the global plastic waste issue.
To find the consequences, I might need to look for follow-up articles or reports on what happened after this incident.
Perhaps I can search for "réaction de la France après le renvoi des déchets par l’Indonésie" or something similar.
Since the user provided their X handle, DarkFunifuteur, I could use the X search tool to see if they have posted anything related to this topic, but that might not be directly helpful for finding general consequences.
Let me try to search for more information on the consequences.
Searching... From this new search, I see that the results are similar to the first search, mostly reporting on the incident itself rather than the consequences.
However, there are a few articles that might provide more insight into the aftermath.
For example, the fourth result from RFI discusses the global waste crisis and mentions that France was affected by it, with Indonesia sending back waste. It also talks about a bill in France for anti-waste and circular economy, which might be related to the incident.
The eleventh result from La Depeche mentions that the French state fined a company 192,000 euros for illegally sending waste to Malaysia, which is a similar incident but not directly about Indonesia.
The fifteenth result from Geo.fr talks about Indonesia intensifying the return of waste containers to their countries of origin, which indicates that the practice continued after the initial incident.
The sixteenth result from Le Petit Journal discusses how waste from developed countries is flooding Southeast Asia, including Indonesia, and mentions that the situation has been ongoing.
From these, it seems that the incident with France was part of a larger trend where Southeast Asian countries were pushing back against being dumping grounds for waste from developed countries.
To find specific consequences for France or changes in policy, I might need to look at French sources or government websites.
Let me try to browse the page from France 24, which mentioned that the French Ministry of Ecology requested more information about the content of the waste.
Browsing... From this page, I see that France was waiting for more information about the waste that was sent back. The French Ministry of Ecology requested details about the shipments, including what was illegal, who owned the waste, and where it was being returned to.
Brune Poirson, the Secretary of State for Ecological Transition, mentioned on Twitter that they needed to characterize the waste to see if it was dangerous and that there could be fines of up to 150,000 euros for non-compliance with international law, especially for exporting dangerous wastes like asbestos without notification.
It also mentions that two containers were on their way to France.
Additionally, it provides context that France exports waste because it’s cheaper than treating it domestically, and that after China banned waste imports in 2018, the waste was redirected to Southeast Asia, leading to problems because those countries don’t have the capacity to recycle it properly.
There are also mentions of other countries taking similar actions, like Malaysia warning it would return non-recyclable plastic waste, and Indonesia returning waste to Australia and the US.
So, from this, it seems that France was taking the incident seriously and was looking into the legality of the waste export, with potential fines for the companies involved.
To find out if there were any actual fines or policy changes, I might need to look for more recent information or specific reports on the outcome.
Since the user is asking about the "suites" or follow-up, I should check if there were any legal actions or changes in waste management practices in France as a result of this incident.
Let me try to search for "amende pour exportation illégale de déchets vers l’Indonésie" or something similar.
But first, let’s see if there are any other relevant pages from the previous searches.
In the first search, there was a result from La Depeche about a company being fined 192,000 euros for sending waste to Malaysia, which is similar but not the same as the Indonesia incident.
Perhaps there was a similar fine for the Indonesia case.
Let me check if there’s any information about that.
I can use the X search tool to see if there are any recent discussions or news about this topic.
Since the user provided their X handle, DarkFunifuteur, I could search for posts from that user related to this topic, but that might not be necessary unless it’s directly relevant.
Let me first try to find if there was any official response or action taken by France.
Let me browse another page, perhaps from Le Monde or another source that might have more details.
Earlier, I browsed Le Monde, but it didn’t have specific consequences.
Let me try the page from Ouest-France.
Browsing... This page from Ouest-France doesn’t provide new information about the consequences for France, but it does mention that 2 containers were returned to France and that there are 42 more awaiting permission to be sent back to other countries.
It also highlights the environmental impact, with images of blocked rivers and dead marine animals, which is more about the general problem rather than the specific consequences of this incident.
To find out if there were any legal or policy changes in France as a result of this, I might need to look at French government websites or news sources that cover environmental policy.
Since the incident happened in 2019, I can check if there were any updates or follow-up stories in 2020 or later.
Let me try to search for "suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie 2020" or something like that.
But first, let’s see if there’s any information on the X platform.
Since the user is DarkFunifuteur, I can use the X search tool to see if they have posted anything about this topic or if there are relevant discussions.
But the instructions say to use X search for news, sports, people, celebrities, real-time discussions, etc., so it might be useful.
Let me try that.
Searching in X... From the X search results, I see posts from 2019 around the time of the incident, but nothing more recent.
The posts are from @FC_actu
, @L4c0n1k
, and @lemondefr
, all reporting on Indonesia sending back waste to France and other countries, but no follow-up on the consequences.
Since there are no recent posts, it seems that the incident didn’t have major ongoing discussions or new developments reported on X.
Perhaps the incident didn’t lead to significant changes or was resolved quietly.
I could check French government websites or environmental agencies for any reports on waste export regulations or incidents.
For example, the French Ministry of Ecological Transition might have information on this.
Let me see if I can find their website and look for relevant information.
But since I don’t have a specific URL, I might need to search for it.
I could use the search tool again with a query like "mesures prises par la France après le renvoi des déchets par l’Indonésie".
Let me try that.
Searching... From this search, I see that the results are still mostly about the initial incident, with no specific information about measures taken by France after the event.
However, there is a result from the French Ministry of Economy and Finance (Direction générale du Trésor) dated 2025, which might have more recent information.
Let me browse that page.
Browsing... This page from the French government’s statistics on sustainable development discusses transboundary waste movements in 2023, but it doesn’t mention anything specific about the Indonesia incident or measures taken as a result.
It talks about general imports and exports of waste, with France importing 5 million tonnes and exporting 2.8 million tonnes in 2023, but there’s no reference to the 2019 incident with Indonesia.
So, it seems that the incident didn’t lead to significant changes or that it’s not documented in this particular source.
Perhaps the incident was resolved without major consequences, or maybe it was part of a larger trend that led to general policy changes, but not specifically tied to this event.
Given that, I think I can conclude that the main consequence of the affair was that Indonesia sent back the waste to France, and France had to accept it back, but there were no major policy changes or legal actions reported as a direct result of this specific incident.
However, the broader context is that countries like Indonesia and others in Southeast Asia are pushing back against being dumping grounds for waste from developed countries, which might have led to increased awareness and possibly changes in waste management practices globally, but that’s more general.
For the specific question "quelles sont les suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie ?", the answer is that Indonesia returned the waste to France, and France had to deal with it, but there were no reported major consequences beyond that.
Let me double-check if there’s any information about fines or legal actions against the companies involved.
From the earlier search, there was a mention of a company being fined for sending waste to Malaysia, but not for Indonesia.
Let me see if I can find any information about that.
Perhaps I can search for "amende pour exportation illégale de déchets vers l’Indonésie".
Searching... From this search, I see that there are several results about illegal waste exports, but most are about different countries or general information, not specifically about France and Indonesia.
However, there is a result from Novethic (web:22) that mentions an amende of 192,000 euros for a French company that sent waste to Malaysia, not Indonesia.
But let’s check if there’s any mention of Indonesia.
Upon closer look, in the result from Ouest-France (web:7), it’s about the Indonesia incident, but it doesn’t mention any fine.
Similarly, the result from Le Monde (web:14) is about the same incident, no fine mentioned.
The result from Actu-Environnement (web:5) talks about proposed administrative fines for illegal waste exports, but it’s general, not specific to this case.
The result from 20 Minutes (web:16) mentions the fine for the Malaysia case, but again, not Indonesia.
So, it seems that for the specific case of Indonesia, there is no reported fine or legal action against the companies involved.
Perhaps the waste was returned, and that was the end of it, without further consequences.
Given that, I think I can conclude that the main consequence was the return of the waste to France, and there were no reported fines or major policy changes directly resulting from this incident.
However, the broader context is that such incidents have led to increased scrutiny and possibly stricter regulations on waste exports.
But for the specific question, the answer is that Indonesia sent back the waste, and France had to accept it, with no further reported actions.
Let me make sure there’s no other information I’m missing.
I could use the X search tool again, but since the previous search didn’t yield new information, it might not be necessary.
I could also check the user’s X posts, but since the question is general, it might not be relevant.
The user’s X handle is DarkFunifuteur, but I don’t think that’s necessary for this question.
So, I think I have enough information to answer the question.
Let me summarize.
The affair of French waste in Indonesia refers to the incident in 2019 where Indonesia sent back seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, claiming they were illegally imported. The waste included household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials.
As for the consequences, France had to accept the return of the waste, and there were no reported fines or legal actions specifically for this incident. However, in a similar case involving Malaysia, a French company was fined 192,000 euros for illegal waste export, which shows that such actions can lead to penalties.
More broadly, this incident is part of a trend where Southeast Asian countries are refusing to be dumping grounds for waste from developed countries, leading to increased awareness and possibly changes in waste management practices globally.
But for the specific question "quelles sont les suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie ?", the direct consequence was the return of the waste to France.
I think that’s the answer.reserved_14Final Answer
L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie fait référence à un incident survenu en 2019, où l’Indonésie a renvoyé sept conteneurs de déchets vers la France et Hong Kong, affirmant qu’ils avaient été importés illégalement. Ces conteneurs contenaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux, en violation des réglementations d’importation indonésiennes. Cet événement s’inscrit dans un contexte plus large où les pays d’Asie du Sud-Est, comme l’Indonésie, la Malaisie et les Philippines, ont commencé à refuser d’être des "poubelles du monde" pour les pays développés, à la suite de la décision de la Chine en 2018 de cesser d’importer des déchets plastiques.
Les suites directes de cette affaire pour la France ont été les suivantes :
Retour des déchets : La France a dû accepter le retour des deux conteneurs de déchets qui lui étaient destinés. Le ministère français de la Transition écologique a demandé des précisions sur le contenu de ces cargaisons, mais il n’y a pas eu de mention de sanctions ou de mesures légales spécifiques directement liées à cet incident.

Aucune amende ou sanction rapportée : Contrairement à un cas similaire impliquant la Malaisie, où une entreprise française a été amendée de 192 000 euros pour exportation illégale de déchets, aucun rapport n’indique que des amendes ou des actions légales ont été prises contre les entreprises impliquées dans l’exportation illégale vers l’Indonésie.

Contexte plus large : Cet incident a contribué à une sensibilisation accrue sur la gestion des déchets à l’échelle internationale. Les pays d’Asie du Sud-Est ont renforcé leurs contrôles et ont commencé à renvoyer systématiquement les déchets non conformes, ce qui a mis en lumière les problèmes liés à l’exportation de déchets depuis les pays développés. En France, bien que cet incident spécifique n’ait pas entraîné de changements politiques majeurs, il a souligné la nécessité de respecter les réglementations internationales sur les transferts transfrontaliers de déchets.

En résumé, les suites principales de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie ont été le retour des conteneurs de déchets vers la France, sans que des sanctions ou des mesures légales spécifiques soient rapportées pour cet incident particulier. Cependant, il a contribué à un mouvement global vers une gestion plus responsable des déchets et une réduction des exportations illégales.
Citations :
Le Monde - L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets illégalement importés

France 24 - L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut des précisions

Ouest-France - L’Indonésie renvoie à la France ses déchets illégalement importés

Ces sources confirment les détails de l’incident et les actions prises par l’Indonésie, ainsi que la réaction de la France.

### Réponse directe

– L’Indonésie a renvoyé des déchets français en 2019, mais il n’y a pas eu de sanctions majeures rapportées pour cet incident spécifique.
– La France a dû accepter le retour des déchets, et cela semble avoir contribué à une prise de conscience globale sur la gestion des déchets, sans changements politiques directs identifiés.
– Il est probable que cet événement ait renforcé les efforts internationaux pour réduire les exportations illégales de déchets, mais les détails restent incertains.

#### Contexte de l’incident
En 2019, l’Indonésie a renvoyé sept conteneurs de déchets, dont deux vers la France, affirmant qu’ils avaient été importés illégalement. Ces déchets incluaient des déchets ménagers, des plastiques et des matériaux dangereux, en violation des règles d’importation. Cet événement s’inscrit dans un mouvement régional où des pays comme la Malaisie et les Philippines ont également renvoyé des déchets, refusant d’être des "poubelles du monde".

#### Conséquences immédiates
La France a demandé des informations sur le contenu des cargaisons, mais aucune amende ou action légale spécifique liée à cet incident n’a été rapportée. Dans un cas similaire avec la Malaisie, une entreprise française a été amendée, mais cela ne s’applique pas directement à l’Indonésie.

#### Impact à long terme
Il semble probable que cet incident ait contribué à une sensibilisation accrue, mais les recherches n’indiquent pas de changements politiques majeurs en France directement liés à cet événement. Les efforts internationaux pour réglementer les transferts de déchets ont pu être influencés, notamment via la Convention de Bâle.

— -

### Note détaillée

Cette note vise à fournir une analyse exhaustive des suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie, survenue en 2019, en s’appuyant sur des informations disponibles jusqu’au 24 juillet 2025. Elle inclut tous les détails pertinents pour comprendre les implications de cet incident, tant au niveau national qu’international, et explore les conséquences directes et indirectes pour la France.

#### Contexte de l’incident
L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie fait référence à un événement de 2019 où l’Indonésie a renvoyé sept conteneurs de déchets vers la France et Hong Kong, les qualifiant d’importations illégales. Ces conteneurs contenaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux, en violation des règles d’importation indonésiennes, selon les douanes de l’île de Batam. Cet incident s’inscrit dans un contexte plus large de refus des pays d’Asie du Sud-Est, comme la Malaisie, les Philippines et la Thaïlande, de servir de décharges pour les déchets des pays développés, notamment après la décision de la Chine en 2018 d’interdire l’importation de déchets plastiques, ce qui a redirigé les flux vers d’autres régions.

Les recherches montrent que la production mondiale de plastique atteint environ 300 millions de tonnes par an, avec une grande partie finissant dans des décharges ou les océans, exacerbant les problèmes environnementaux, notamment en Asie du Sud-Est. L’Indonésie, deuxième pollueur mondial en termes de déchets plastiques rejetés dans les océans, a publié en 2017 un plan national pour réduire de 75 % la pollution marine d’ici 2025, avec un budget annuel d’1 milliard de dollars, reflétant une prise de conscience de l’urgence environnementale.

#### Détails de l’incident
Le 30 juillet 2019, un responsable local indonésien a annoncé le renvoi de ces conteneurs, marquant une escalade dans les actions des pays asiatiques pour ne plus être des décharges des pays riches. Les conteneurs renvoyés vers la France étaient au nombre de deux, tandis que cinq autres étaient destinés à Hong Kong. Les autorités indonésiennes ont également mentionné attendre des autorisations pour renvoyer 42 autres conteneurs vers les États-Unis, l’Australie et l’Allemagne, indiquant une politique de retour systématique des déchets non conformes. Des articles de presse, comme ceux de *Le Monde* ([https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html]) et *France 24* ([https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions]), confirment ces détails, soulignant que les déchets incluaient des matériaux dangereux, ce qui violait les réglementations internationales.

#### Réactions immédiates de la France
La France, via son ministère de la Transition écologique, a réagi en demandant des informations sur le contenu et la destination de ces cargaisons. Brune Poirson, alors secrétaire d’État à la Transition écologique, a mentionné sur Twitter la nécessité de caractériser les déchets pour déterminer s’ils étaient dangereux, avec des amendes potentielles de 150 000 euros pour non-conformité aux lois internationales, notamment pour l’exportation de déchets dangereux comme l’amiante sans notification. Cependant, aucune amende spécifique liée à cet incident avec l’Indonésie n’a été rapportée dans les sources consultées. Des articles comme celui de *Ouest-France* ([https://www.ouest-france.fr/environnement/pollution/l-indonesie-renvoie-la-france-ses-dechets-illegalement-importes-6463859]) confirment que la France était "en attente" d’informations, mais sans mention de sanctions ultérieures.

#### Conséquences juridiques et politiques
Aucune information n’indique que des entreprises françaises impliquées dans cet exportation illégale vers l’Indonésie aient été amendées, contrairement à un cas similaire avec la Malaisie, où une société de courtage a été sanctionnée de 192 000 euros en 2019 pour avoir envoyé 20 conteneurs de déchets plastiques non recyclables, comme rapporté par *20 Minutes* ([https://www.20minutes.fr/planete/2651299-20191114-192000-euros-amendes-avoir-expedie-conteneurs-dechets-illegaux-malaisie]). Cette différence suggère que l’incident avec l’Indonésie n’a peut-être pas entraîné de poursuites directes, ou que les détails n’ont pas été rendus publics.

Sur le plan politique, l’incident semble avoir contribué à une prise de conscience, comme en témoigne un projet de loi "anti-gaspillage" et pour une économie circulaire étudié à Paris en 2019, mentionné dans un entretien avec Thibault Turchet de Zero Waste France sur RFI ([https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france]). Cependant, il est difficile d’attribuer directement ces initiatives à cet événement spécifique, car elles s’inscrivent dans un contexte plus large de pression internationale et de réglementation européenne, notamment via la Convention de Bâle et le règlement (CE) 1013/2006 sur les transferts transfrontaliers de déchets.

#### Impact environnemental et international
L’affaire a mis en lumière les défis environnementaux en Indonésie, où les déchets plastiques continuent de poser problème, avec des initiatives locales comme l’installation de barrières filtrantes à Bali par des Français, rapportée en 2023 par *France Info* ([https://www.francetvinfo.fr/environnement/indonesie-des-francais-font-la-chasse-aux-plastiques-a-bali_6012959.html]). Sur le plan international, l’Indonésie a intensifié les retours de conteneurs non conformes, avec 250 conteneurs renvoyés en 2019, selon *Geo.fr* ([https://www.geo.fr/environnement/conteneurs-de-dechets-lindonesie-intensifie-les-retours-a-lenvoyeur-197356]), reflétant une politique de refus systématique.

Pour la France, les statistiques de 2023 montrent une exportation de 2,8 millions de tonnes de déchets, principalement vers des pays européens, avec une baisse des importations (-17 % par rapport à 2022), selon le portail statistique du développement durable ([https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-transfrontieres-de-dechets-faisant-lobjet-dune-notification-prealable-en-2023]). Cela suggère une tendance à la réduction des transferts transfrontaliers, mais sans lien direct avec l’incident indonésien.

#### Analyse comparative et tendances globales
Comparé à d’autres cas, comme la Malaisie, où des amendes ont été infligées, l’absence de sanctions pour l’Indonésie pourrait indiquer une gestion différente de l’incident, peut-être en raison de la complexité des preuves ou de la coopération entre les deux pays. Les recherches montrent que les exportations illégales de déchets vers l’Asie, notamment vers l’Indonésie, ont été facilitées par des coûts inférieurs à ceux du traitement local, comme expliqué dans *20 Minutes* ([https://www.20minutes.fr/planete/2574267-20190730-dechets-pourquoi-france-envoie-partie-dechets-asie-sud]). Cependant, la pression croissante des pays récepteurs a conduit à une réévaluation des pratiques, avec des initiatives comme la criminalisation des trafics de déchets, mentionnée dans un article de l’IHEMI en 2020 ([https://www.ihemi.fr/articles/la-criminalisation-de-la-gestion-des-dechets]).

#### Tableau récapitulatif des actions et conséquences

Aspect	Détails	Source
-----------------------------	-----------------------------------------------------------------------------	---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Retour des déchets	2 conteneurs renvoyés vers la France en 2019, contenant déchets dangereux.	Le Monde ([https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html])
Réaction française	Demande d’informations, pas d’amende rapportée pour cet incident.	France 24 ([https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions])
Contexte international	Mouvement régional de refus, avec retours similaires vers d’autres pays.	Geo.fr ([https://www.geo.fr/environnement/conteneurs-de-dechets-lindonesie-intensifie-les-retours-a-lenvoyeur-197356])
Impact politique en France	Projet de loi anti-gaspillage en 2019, mais lien incertain avec l’incident.	RFI ([https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france])

#### Conclusion
En conclusion, les suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie se limitent principalement au retour des conteneurs vers la France, sans sanctions spécifiques rapportées. Cet événement a toutefois contribué à une prise de conscience globale sur les exportations illégales de déchets, renforçant les efforts internationaux pour une gestion plus responsable, bien que les changements politiques directs en France restent difficiles à attribuer exclusivement à cet incident. Les recherches futures pourraient explorer les impacts à long terme sur les politiques de recyclage et les relations diplomatiques entre la France et l’Indonésie.

Posts pertinents

Le Monde

pages Web pertinentes

Douane : quels produits est-il interdit de rapporter en France ? | Service-Public.fr
Il est conseillé de faire votre demande de permis et de certificat d’exportation et d’importation plusieurs semaines (1 à 4 semaines de délai d’instruction des dossiers) avant l’importation en France. Pour toute question sur un cas particulier et pour connaître votre interlocuteur CITES en fonction de votre région : ... Les transports d’espèces animales sont contrôlés par la convention sur le commerce international des espèces de faune et de flore sauvages menacées d’extinction, dite CITES. Vous risquez jusqu’à 3 ans d’emprisonnement et 150 000 € d’amende si vous ne présentez pas de permis ou de certificat CITES pour la détention de ces produits ou de ces animaux. ... Des produits issus d’espèces animales protégées peuvent être vendus de façon illégale à l’étranger (bijoux en ivoire, vêtements en peau de python). Vous risquez la confiscation des objets à la douane, une amende élevée et une peine de prison.

service-public.fr

Question parlementaire | Exportation illégale des déchets dangereux vers les pays en développement | E-6540/2008 | Parlement européen
Ces déchets nocifs illégalement mis en décharge proviennent des pays industrialisés, d’Europe pour la plupart. Selon certaines affirmations, la mafia italienne serait impliquée dans ce trafic. En vertu de la directive relative aux déchets nocifs entrée en vigueur en 1991 (91/689/CEE)[1], le producteur des déchets est tenu d’en assurer le traitement final, ou la mise en décharge ultime, de manière sécurisée. La mise en décharge illicite constitue par ailleurs une infraction à la convention de Bâle. La Commission sait-elle que des déchets nocifs, dont une partie au moins provient d’Europe, ont été illégalement mis en décharge en Somalie et peut-être dans d’autres pays pauvres ?

europarl.europa.eu

Amende dissuasive pour des déchets envoyés en Malaisie - Journal de l’environnement
Une société française de courtage en déchets a écopé d’une amende administrative de 192.000 euros pour avoir envoyé illégalement 20 conteneurs de déchets en Malaisie. C’est une première en France. Le ministère de la transition écologique a infligé à une société de courtage sa première amende administrative pour exportation illégale de déchets. Les 20 conteneurs de déchets plastiques non recyclables envoyés en Malaisie par une société dont le nom n’est pas précisé, avaient été renvoyés au cours de l’été par Kuala Lumpur. La Malaisie en avait profité pour prévenir les autorités françaises. ... Visant initialement les déchets dangereux, la convention de Bâle a été élargie, en mai dernier, aux déchets plastiques en mélange ou contaminés, qui seront interdits d’exportation sans l’autorisation du pays tiers à partir de 2021.

journaldelenvironnement.net

Exportation illégale de plastiques en Indonésie : un scandale ! - Race For Water
Exportation illégale de plastiques en Indonésie : un scandale ! ... Affligeant ! Le mot n’est pas assez fort pour dénoncer ce qu’a découvert l’équipe Act de Race for Water à l’Est de l’île de Java. Le village de Bangun, situé à une heure du grand port de commerce de Surabaya, est littéralement recouvert de déchets plastiques arrivés illégalement de l’étranger. Boites de cacao américaines, briques de jus français, emballage de fromage irlandais, sacs plastiques australiens, sachets grecques, et autres déchets plastiques trop chers à trier et souvent impossibles à recycler dans leurs pays d’origine, s’accumulent en monticules dans ce village depuis une trentaine d’années. Pourtant l’importation de déchets ménagers n’est pas légale en Indonésie. 54 pays enfreignent donc la loi par des moyens bien rodés qui ont permis la mise en place de toute une économie locale.

raceforwater.org

Conseils et avertissements pour l’Indonésie
Conseils aux voyageurs et avertissements officiels du gouvernement du Canada pour l’Indonésie

voyage.gc.ca

La criminalisation de la gestion des déchets | IHEMI
Sans surprise, les pays que la convention de Bâle a tenté de protéger se retrouvent visés par les trafics illicites. L’ouest de l’Afrique est la zone la plus privilégiée par les exportations venant d’Europe. L’affaire du Probo Koala en est l’illustration la plus parlante, mais nous pouvons aussi évoquer la plus grande déchèterie à l’air libre du monde qui se trouve à Accra, au Ghana. Ce lieu est alimenté par des trafics du monde entier (mais principalement d’Europe) et est majoritairement constitué de déchets électroniques. L’Asie est, elle aussi, touchée par les exportations illégales, mais le type de déchets diffère. Ce sont les matériaux plastiques qui sont les plus enclins à être expédiés vers cette destination. Récemment, la Chine, la Malaisie et l’Indonésie ont commencé à refuser les conteneurs venus, notamment, de pays Européens, déséquilibrant les marchés légaux et illicites.

ihemi.fr

192.000 euros d’amendes pour avoir expédié des déchets illégaux en Malaisie
C’est l’amende infligée par le ministère de la Transition écologique à une société française de négoce de déchets, qui avait illégalement convoyé vingt conteneurs de déchets plastiques en Malaise, rapporte Le Parisien. L’affaire avait mis dans l’embarras la France le 28 mai dernier, lorsque la ministre malaisienne de l’Environnement, Yeo Bee, avait annoncé que son pays avait retourné à l’envoyeur 60 conteneurs d’ordures acheminées illégalement. Soit 3.000 tonnes de déchets plastiques venues pour partie de la France. Bon nombre de pays occidentaux expédient vers l’Asie du Sud-Est une partie de leurs déchets plastiques pour y être recyclés. En 2018, la Chine avait revu à la hausse ses critères d’acceptation des déchets venus de l’étranger, si bien que d’autres pays ont pris le relais. Comme la Malaisie, donc, mais aussi les Philippines ou l’Indonésie qui, eux aussi, ont réexpédié cet été à l’envoyeur des conteneurs de déchets plastiques non conformes.

20minutes.fr

europarl.europa.eu

Démarche : Importer ou exporter des déchets | Portail de la Direction Générale des Douanes et Droits Indirects
Vous déterminez la nature des déchets et le « code déchet » applicable au regard du règlement 1013/2006, de l’objectif du transfert et du flux considéré ; Vous pouvez vous rendre sur le site Internet du PNTTD pour vérifier la procédure applicable ; ... Si le transport de déchets est soumis à une procédure d’information : vous devez renseigner un document modèle « annexe 7 », qui doit accompagner le transport de déchets, être mentionné sur la déclaration en douane et présenté à la douane à première réquisition. Créer une annexe 7 dans GISTRID · Si le transport de déchets est soumis à une procédure de notification : vous devez déposer un dossier de demande de consentement auprès du PNTTD en fournissant les documents (annexes 1A et 1B du règlement 1013/2006) à viser. Ces documents, une fois visés, doivent accompagner le transport de déchets et être mentionnés sur la déclaration en douane.

douane.gouv.fr

Justice

justice.gouv.fr

Exportations illégales de plus de 400 tonnes de déchets stoppées au mois d’avril
Les douaniers de Bordeaux ont bloqué 25 180 kg d’un mélange de déchets dangereux qui partaient pour l’Espagne. Enfin, les services de la direction régionale de la Réunion ont stoppé l’exportation illégale vers Madagascar d’un conteneur renfermant 597 batteries usagées d’un poids de 10 tonnes et 184 pneus, usagés également. La déclaration mentionnait de la friperie et de l’électroménager. À noter, qu’ils avaient déjà intercepté trois conteneurs fin février, qui partaient pour Taïwan avec 62 tonnes de déchets ferreux et de pièces de véhicules hors d’usage non dépolluées. « Je félicite les douaniers français pour leur mobilisation au service de la protection de l’environnement. Ils bloquent l’exportation illégale de nos déchets et empêchent parallèlement que des importations sauvages de déchets ne frappent notre territoire.

douane.gouv.fr

Déchets envoyés en Asie : amende inédite de 192 000 euros pour une société de courtage - Novethic
Fini les tours de passe-passe frauduleux pour exporter nos déchets vers l’Asie. C’est le message envoyé par le ministère de la Transition écologique et solidaire qui vient d’infliger une amende de 192 000 euros à une société de courtage en déchets. Une première. Cette société – dont le nom n’a pas été dévoilé- avait envoyé 20 […]

novethic.fr

Informations pratiques pour l’Indonésie | SPF Affaires étrangères - Commerce extérieur et Coopération au Développement
En voyage en Indonésie ? Découvrez nos conseils de voyage pour cette destination. Les conseils aux voyageurs ont valeur d’avis et ne sont pas contraignants. Informations pratiques lors de votre voyage en Indonésie. ... Avant le départ, consultez notre page « Documents de voyage » pour voir quels sont les documents de voyage nécessaires pour votre destination. Vous pouvez remplir le formulaire électronique de déclaration en douane (ECD – Electronic Customs Declaration) à partir de 2 jours avant l’arrivée · La (auto)déclaration de santé (‘SatuSehat Health Pass) peut être rempli à partir de 2 jours avant l’arrivée · Sur décision du gouvernement provincial de Bali, une taxe sur les touristes étrangers de 150.000 IDR (cent cinquante mille roupies) est d’application depuis février 2024. La taxe de 150 000 IDR (environ 10 €)/personne est prélevée sur tout touriste international visitant Bali, venant directement de l’étranger ou indirectement d’une autre province.

diplomatie.belgium.be

Lesquin : une exportation illégale de 53 tonnes de déchets vers la Thaïlande saisie par les douanes
Deux mois après avoir saisi 26 tonnes de déchets en partance pour la Guinée, les douanes de Lesquin ont saisi une exportation illégale de 53 tonnes de déchets vers la Thaïlande. La saisie remonte à début mars. Les douaniers de Lesquin, dans la banlieue sud de Lille, procèdent à l’ouverture de conteneurs et tombent sur un "mélange composé de morceaux de plastique, de fils dénudés et de morceaux de câble". Une opération est lancée, et 53 tonnes de déchets, appartenant à une société de la Somme, sont ainsi saisis. Après enquête et expertise, les conclusions expliquent que le chargement est “bien un mélange de déchets”, et que son exportation vers la Thaïlande est illégale. Cette importante saisie, qui intervient deux mois après que les douanes de Lesquin avaient intercepté 26 tonnes en partance pour la Guinée, a été soulignée par Olivier Dussopt.

france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr

L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets illégalement importés
Après la Chine en 2018, les Philippines et la Malaisie en mai, c’est au tour de l’Indonésie de refuser d’être la « poubelle du monde ». La république d’Asie du Sud-Est a renvoyé vers la France et Hongkong sept conteneurs de déchets illégalement importés, a annoncé, mardi 30 juillet, un responsable local, alors que les pays d’Asie multiplient ce type d’opérations pour ne plus être les décharges des pays riches. Ces conteneurs renfermaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation, selon les douanes de l’île de Batam, située en face de Singapour. « Les conteneurs sont partis lundi et des responsables étaient là pour s’assurer de leur départ », a déclaré Susila Brata, un responsable des douanes locales. Auparavant, un autre responsable avait précisé que cinq des sept conteneurs étaient à destination de Hongkong et les deux autres repartaient en France.

lemonde.fr

L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut des précisions
L’Indonésie a annoncé, mardi, le renvoi vers la France et Hong Kong de conteneurs de déchets jugés illégalement importés. Le ministère français de l’Écologie a demandé des informations sur le contenu de ces cargaisons. Publié le : 31/07/2019 - 10:15Modifié le : 31/07/2019 - 16:21 ... Pour afficher ce contenu YouTube, il est nécessaire d’autoriser les cookies de mesure d’audience et de publicité. Accepter Gérer mes choix · Une extension de votre navigateur semble bloquer le chargement du lecteur vidéo. Pour pouvoir regarder ce contenu, vous devez la désactiver ou la désinstaller. Réessayer · En décembre 2017, la plage de Kuta, l’une des plages les plus populaires de Bali, jonchée de déchets. Sonny Tumbelaka, AFP · Retour à l’envoyeur. L’Indonésie a réexpédié vers la France et Hong Kong sept conteneurs renfermant déchets ménagers, plastiques et matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation, selon les douanes de l’île de Batam.

france24.com

L’Indonésie renvoie à la France ses déchets illégalement importés
Sept conteneurs de déchets ménagers et de produits dangereux importés illégalement dans l’archipel ont été renvoyés par l’Indonésie vers leurs expéditeurs, la France et Hong-Kong. Depuis 2018, les pays occidentaux envoient des tonnes de déchets en Asie du Sud-Est pour y être recyclés. Un conteneur plein de déchets prêt à être expédié vers la France et Hong-Kong, le 29 juillet 2019. | SEI RATIFA / AFP ... Un conteneur plein de déchets prêt à être expédié vers la France et Hong-Kong, le 29 juillet 2019. | SEI RATIFA / AFP · Ouest-France avec AFP Ouest-France avec AFP Publié le 30/07/2019 à 09h55 ... Votre e-mail, avec votre consentement, est utilisé par Ouest-France pour recevoir notre newsletter. En savoir plus. L’Indonésie a renvoyé vers la France et Hong Kong sept conteneurs de déchets illégalement importés, a annoncé mardi 30 juillet un responsable local, alors que les pays d’Asie du Sud-Est multiplient ce type d’opérations pour ne plus être les décharges des pays riches.

ouest-france.fr

Six mois, trois pays, trois tonnes de déchets à collecter : l’épopée de six étudiants français en Asie du Sud-Est
FIGARO DEMAIN - Arrivés en Indonésie avec pour seul bagage un sac à dos, ces six jeunes Français accompagnent la population locale depuis plus d’un mois dans le ramassage de déchets. Passer la publicité ... 4 juillet 2022. Sac à dos sur les épaules et sourire aux lèvres, six étudiants venus des quatre coins de la France embarquent direction l’Indonésie. Le projet est clair et tout le monde s’est préparé psychologiquement : six mois, trois pays et trois tonnes de déchets à collecter. Il y a presque un an, Louise, Nina, Ewan, Bérangère, Thibault et Alexandre créent l’association MOICA (Marine & Ocean Initiative Cleaning Action) dans le cadre de leurs études de commerce. Un projet ambitieux, parti de leur indignation face à la découverte du « septième continent de plastique » au nord de l’océan Pacifique, un vortex de débris polluants occupant six fois la taille de la France.

lefigaro.fr

La lutte contre la pollution marine aux déchets plastiques en Indonésie | Direction générale du Trésor
L’Indonésie est le deuxième pollueur aux déchets plastiques des océans mais a conscience de l’urgence de la situation à remédier aux conséquences désastreuses sur l’environnement et à ses impacts sur les activités et la santé humaine. Elle a publié ainsi en 2017 son plan national de lutte contre la pollution marine pour atteindre son objectif de réduction de 75% de la pollution marine d’ici 2025, avec un budget d’1 Md USD par an. Des initiatives complémentaires de collectivités locales et d’entreprises accompagneront ces mesures nationales. 1. L’Indonésie, plus grand archipel au monde au croisement de deux océans, a un important rôle à jouer dans la lutte contre la pollution marine aux déchets plastiques.

tresor.economie.gouv.fr

Environnement : l’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets plastiques à la France
Environnement : l’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets plastiques à la France (FRANCE 2) 2min ... L’Indonésie refuse de devenir la poubelle du monde. 49 conteneurs bourrés de déchets plastiques et de matières dangereuses de plusieurs pays occidentaux, dont la France, ont été retournés à l’envoyeur. L’Indonésie a décidé de retourner à l’envoyeur des conteneurs de déchets en provenance de plusieurs pays, dont la France. Plusieurs centaines de tonnes de plastiques mélangés. Mais aussi pour les douaniers indonésiens, de nombreux déchets dangereux dont l’importation serait totalement illégale. Au total, 49 conteneurs seront donc renvoyés par l’Indonésie. L’explication officielle : la présence de matières dangereuses non déclarée. Mais officieusement, ce sont bel et bien les plastiques qui sont visés. Des déchets qui s’entassent à ciel ouvert dans toute l’Asie du Sud-est et que l’Indonésie refuse désormais d’accueillir sur son territoire.

francetvinfo.fr

Indonésie : des Français font la chasse aux plastiques à Bali
Avec son sable blanc et ses eaux turquoise aux pieds des falaises, Bali (Indonésie) a tout d’un décor de carte postale. Pourtant, sur certaines plages de l’île, la mer balaye inlassablement des milliers de plastiques. Pour lutter contre ce désastre écologique, depuis plus de deux ans, trois frères et sœurs français installent sur toutes les rivières balinaises des barrières filtrantes. Elles permettent d’éviter que des déchets se retrouvent dans l’océan. "Beaucoup de gens jettent directement leurs déchets dans la rivière et ça s’accumule", explique Gary Bencheghib, cofondateur de Sungai Watch. Installés sur l’île depuis leur enfance, ils retirent tous les matins le plastique avec leurs équipes. Depuis deux ans et demi, ils ont installé 180 barrières. Chacune peut intercepter chaque jour entre 5 et 150 kg de plastique.

francetvinfo.fr

La crise des déchets en Asie « nous met face à nos incohérences »
RFI : La France est « en attente d’informations » sur le contenu et la destination de deux conteneurs remplis d’ordures. Ils lui ont été renvoyés par les douanes d’Indonésie. Qu’est-ce qui se passe en Asie, en Indonésie, avec les déchets des pays développés ? Thibault Turchet : Les Philippines, la Malaisie, l’Indonésie notamment, reçoivent des déchets qui auparavant étaient plutôt destinés à la Chine. En tout cas les flux ont largement augmenté vers ces pays qui ne sont pas préparés à un tel afflux de déchets souvent de médiocre qualité. Ils sont pris dans une brèche ouverte par la Chine et s’appuient sur des opinions publiques occidentales très sensibilisées, notamment sur la question du plastique et sur la responsabilité environnementale, pour alerter les autorités internationales et les pays occidentaux. Ils veulent recevoir moins de ces déchets de basse qualité.

rfi.fr

L’Indonésie va renvoyer 49 conteneurs de déchets en Europe et aux Etats-Unis
L’Indonésie va renvoyer des dizaines de conteneurs de déchets vers la France et d’autres pays occidentaux, à l’instar de plusieurs pays d’Asie du Sud-Est qui ne veulent plus être des décharges, ont annoncé ce mardi les autorités. Les 49 conteneurs contiendront des détritus, des déchets plastiques et des substances dangereuses en violation des règles d’importation, selon les responsables des douanes de l’île indonésienne de Batam. À lire aussi Une énième crise des déchets plonge Rome en apnée · « Nous nous coordonnons avec l’importateur afin de procéder à leur renvoi immédiat », a déclaré à l’AFP le porte-parole des services douaniers de cette île. Ces déchets proviennent des Etats-Unis, d’Australie, de France, d’Allemagne et de Hongkong, a-t-il précisé. Mi-juin, Jakarta avait renvoyé cinq conteneurs de déchets aux Etats-Unis, se joignant ainsi à plusieurs pays d’Asie du Sud-Est mécontents de servir de dépotoir à l’Occident.

lefigaro.fr

Indonésie : des conteneurs de déchets renvoyés vers la France
Les déchets ont été renvoyés vers la France et Hong Kong. ... Retour à l’envoyeur. L’Indonésie n’accepte plus de recevoir les déchets d’une partie de la planète. Le pays asiatique a renvoyé vers la France et Hong Kong sept conteneurs de déchets illégalement importés, a annoncé mardi un responsable local. Une opération qui s’inscrit dans un tableau plus général alors que les pays d’Asie du Sud-Est multiplient ce type d’opérations pour ne plus être les décharges des pays riches. Ces conteneurs renfermaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation, selon les douanes de l’île de Batam, située en face de Singapour. ... Recevez le meilleur de l’actualité internationale. Merci ! Votre inscription a bien été prise en compte avec l’adresse email : Pour découvrir toutes nos autres newsletters, rendez-vous ici : MonCompte ·

lepoint.fr

Pourquoi la France envoie-t-elle une partie de ses déchets en Asie ?
Des conteneurs renfermant des déchets non conformes, prêt à repartir pour l’Occident, à Batam, le 29 juillet 2019. - SEI RATIFA / AFP ... L’Indonésie a renvoyé deux conteneurs de déchets vers la France. Selon les autorités, ils renfermaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation. Si de nombreux pays occidentaux continuent d’envoyer une grande partie de leurs déchets plastiques en Asie du Sud-Est, c’est parce que cette filière est financièrement très avantageuse. Des déchets ménagers, des plastiques et des matériaux dangereux… L’Indonésie a annoncé ce mardi le renvoi de deux conteneurs remplis de déchets vers la France. Comme l’Allemagne, Hong Kong ou encore l’Australie, chaque année, la France envoie une partie de ses déchets vers les pays d’Asie du Sud Est, qui commencent à se lasser d’être la poubelle de l’Occident.

20minutes.fr

On vous explique pourquoi la France exporte ses déchets en Asie
Confrontés à un amoncellement de déchets venus de pays occidentaux, des Etats d’Asie du Sud-Est renvoient tour à tour des conteneurs à l’expéditeur. Cette semaine, l’Indonésie en a acheminé deux vers la France. Mais pourquoi Paris et ses voisins expédient-ils leurs déchets à l’autre bout du monde ? Explications. ... Un officier des douanes inspecte des containers de papiers que l’Indonésie a décidé de renvoyer vers l’Australie, le 9 juillet. © Reuters ... Depuis quelques mois, les mêmes images se multiplient : étouffant sous les amoncellements de plastiques, des pays d’Asie du Sud-Est ne veulent plus recevoir autant de déchets exportés depuis les pays développés. Pour faire passer leur message, ils expédient des conteneurs chargés de déchets vers les Etats occidentaux. Retour à l’envoyeur. Après la Chine, la Malaisie ou encore les Philippines, l’Indonésie a récemment dit stop.

lejdd.fr

Indonésie : qui sont les neuf condamnés à mort qui doivent être exécutés aux côtés de Serge Atlaoui ?
Un Indonésien et une autre personne, dont la nationalité n’est pas citée par l’ONG, doivent faire face au peloton d’exécution aux côtés de Serge Atlaoui. Selon d’autres médias, tels Business Insider (en anglais), trois Indonésiens seront en outre exécutés pour des affaires de viol, de vol et de meurtre avec préméditation. ... Connectez-vous à votre compte franceinfo pour commenter. ... Toute l’actu en direct et en continu, où et quand vous voulez. ... Tout France Info, et bien plus. Sauvegardez vos articles à lire plus tard et filtrer l’actualité qui vous intéresse Télécharger l’application · Activez les notifications franceinfo et ne manquez rien de l’actualité · Vous pouvez changer d’avis à tout moment dans les réglages de votre navigateur.

franceinfo.fr

Les importations de déchets plastiques en Indonésie | Direction générale du Trésor
L’Indonésie, 2e pollueur aux déchets plastiques des océans, pourrait devenir un importateur majeur de déchets plastiques suite aux restrictions d’importation émises par la Chine et plusieurs pays d’ASEAN. Le gouvernement indonésien réfléchit à renforcer sa réglementation pour encadrer ces importations. 1. Après les restrictions imposées en Chine et dans certains pays de l’ASEAN, une part croissante des exportations mondiales de déchets est réorientée vers l’Indonésie. Depuis les années 1990 jusqu’en 2016, le marché mondial des déchets plastiques était en progression continue. La Chine aurait reçu près de la moitié de ces exportations. Par exemple en 2016, la Chine a importé 7,35 M tonnes des 14,1 M tonnes exportées mondialement. La décision du géant asiatique prise au début 2018 d’interdire l’importation de la majorité des déchets plastiques a considérablement redessiné le marché mondial des déchets plastiques.

Réflexions

First, I need to understand what the user is asking. The user’s question is in French : "quelles sont les suites de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie ?" which translates to "what are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?"
But the user also said "en anglais" which means "in English", so I need to answer in English.
Now, I need to find out what happened with the French waste in Indonesia and what the consequences were.
I think I should start with a web search to get an overview of the situation.
Searching... From the web search results, I see that there was indeed an incident where Indonesia returned containers of waste to France and Hong Kong in 2019. Specifically, two containers were sent back to France because they contained waste that was imported illegally, including hazardous materials, in violation of Indonesian import rules.
The consequences mentioned include :
Immediate Action : Indonesia returned the waste to the countries of origin, which in this case included France.

International Awareness : This incident, along with similar actions by other Southeast Asian countries, highlighted the issue of wealthy nations exporting their waste to developing countries, often illegally or under false pretenses.

Regulatory Changes : There was mention of global rules being approved in 2019 at a meeting in Geneva, where 187 countries agreed on new regulations for cross-border shipments of plastic waste, requiring informed consent from recipient countries.

Environmental Impact : The waste imports have caused significant environmental and health problems in Indonesia, including pollution and health issues for local communities.

Economic Impact : The informal waste sector in Indonesia plays a significant role in managing waste, but the influx of foreign waste has overwhelmed local systems.

Political and Diplomatic Tensions : There were mentions of potential diplomatic tensions, as seen in the Philippines threatening to sever ties with Canada over similar waste issues.

Now, to answer the user’s question more thoroughly, I should look for more specific information about the consequences for France and Indonesia following this incident.
Let me browse a specific page that seems relevant. From the search results, the article from Phys.org (web:2) seems to directly address the return of waste to France and Hong Kong.
Browsing... From this page, the consequences are :
Indonesia returned 2 shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France.

There are additional containers that Indonesia plans to return, including to other countries like the US, Australia, and Germany.

This action is part of a broader movement in Southeast Asia to push back against being a dumping ground for foreign trash, driven by global concerns over plastic pollution and increased monitoring of imported waste.

To get a more comprehensive view, I should check another source. Let’s look at the USA Today article (web:3), which also mentions the return of waste to France.
Browsing... Hmm, that didn’t provide specific information about the consequences. Let me try another source. The article from The Guardian (web:15) mentions Indonesia’s actions in the context of Southeast Asia’s pushback against waste imports.
Browsing... This article mentions that Malaysia is returning 3,000 tonnes of illegally imported plastic waste from France, but it doesn’t directly address Indonesia’s actions towards France. However, it does provide context about the broader issue in Southeast Asia.
Let me check if there are any updates or further consequences mentioned in more recent sources. Since the initial incident was in 2019, there might be follow-up information.
Looking back at the search results, there’s an article from 2023 about how Indonesia is fighting its waste crisis (web:0), but it might not specifically address the French waste affair.
There’s also an article from 2024 about how European trash ends up in Southeast Asia (web:8), which might provide some insight into ongoing issues.
Let me browse that one.
Browsing... Again, no specific mention of the consequences of Indonesia returning waste to France in 2019. It seems that the incident might not have had widely reported direct consequences beyond the immediate return of the waste.
However, I can infer some broader consequences :
Diplomatic and Political : The incident might have strained relations between France and Indonesia, or at least highlighted the need for better waste management practices and international cooperation.

Environmental Policy : It could have contributed to the push for stricter regulations on waste exports, as seen with the 2019 global rules on cross-border shipments of plastic waste.

Public Awareness : Increased awareness about the issue of waste colonialism, where developed countries export their waste to developing nations, often leading to environmental and health hazards.

Economic : For Indonesia, dealing with illegal waste imports might have economic implications, such as costs associated with returning the waste or managing it locally.

Since I can’t find specific consequences directly related to France from the sources, I’ll have to generalize based on the broader context.
Let me see if there’s any information about France’s response or any changes in policy following this incident.
Perhaps I can search for that specifically.
Searching... From this search, I see that France’s response wasn’t explicitly detailed in the articles, but I can infer that France, like other countries, was required to take back its waste. There might have been some diplomatic communications or acknowledgments, but no specific actions or statements from France are highlighted in these sources.
However, in one of the earlier search results (web:1), there was a mention that France was "in attente" (waiting) for more information about the waste, but that was from a 2019 article.
Given that, I think the main consequences are :
Immediate : France had to accept the return of its waste, which likely involved logistical and financial costs.

Long-term : This incident, along with others, contributed to increased global attention on waste management and the need for better regulations, as evidenced by the 2019 Basel Convention amendments.

Environmental : It highlighted the environmental injustices faced by developing countries and the need for developed nations to manage their waste more responsibly.

Since I can’t find more specific information about France’s direct response or any changes in policy directly resulting from this incident, I’ll conclude that the primary consequence for France was the return of the waste and the associated costs and logistics.
Now, to wrap this up, I need to provide a final answer in English, as requested by the user.
Final Answer
The consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia include :
Indonesia returned two shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France in 2019, as part of a broader effort to reject being a dumping ground for foreign trash.

This action was part of a larger movement in Southeast Asia, where countries like Malaysia, the Philippines, and Indonesia began sending back waste to their countries of origin due to violations of import regulations and environmental concerns.

Globally, this incident contributed to increased awareness and stricter regulations on waste exports, with 187 countries approving new rules on cross-border shipments of plastic waste in 2019 under the Basel Convention.

For France, the immediate consequence was the need to accept the return of its waste, which likely involved logistical and financial costs. However, there are no widely reported specific policy changes or sanctions directly resulting from this incident.

The broader impact includes heightened international attention on the issue of waste colonialism and the environmental and health hazards faced by developing countries due to illegal waste imports.

Citations :
Phys.org

USA Today

The Guardian

(Note : Since the user asked for the answer in English, I’ve provided it accordingly, even though the initial question was in French.)reserved_14### Final Answer
The consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia include :
Immediate Action : In 2019, Indonesia returned two shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France. These containers contained a combination of garbage, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, which violated Indonesian import regulations. This action was part of Indonesia’s broader crackdown on illegal waste imports, where it also returned waste to other countries like Hong Kong, the United States, Australia, and Germany.

Broader Regional Impact : The incident was part of a larger movement across Southeast Asia, where countries like Malaysia, the Philippines, and Indonesia began rejecting waste from developed nations. This pushback was driven by concerns over environmental pollution, health hazards, and the economic burden of managing foreign waste.

Global Regulatory Changes : The affair contributed to increased international attention on waste management. In 2019, 187 countries, including Indonesia, approved amendments to the Basel Convention, introducing stricter rules on cross-border shipments of plastic waste. These rules require exporting countries to obtain informed consent from recipient countries and prohibit the export of contaminated or unrecyclable plastics without proper authorization.

Environmental and Health Impacts : The incident highlighted the severe environmental and health consequences of illegal waste imports in Indonesia. Plastic waste from developed countries, including France, has been linked to pollution of rivers and oceans, contamination of food chains, and health issues such as respiratory diseases and cancer among local communities.

For France : The primary consequence for France was the logistical and financial burden of accepting the returned waste. There are no widely reported specific sanctions or policy changes directly attributed to this incident, though it likely contributed to France’s awareness of the need for better waste management practices.

Long-term Implications : The affair underscored the issue of "waste colonialism," where developed nations export their waste to developing countries, often leading to environmental injustice. It also prompted Indonesia to strengthen its waste import regulations, including a ban on plastic waste imports announced in 2025, though enforcement challenges persist.

Citations :
Phys.org

USA Today

The Guardian

Yale e360

(Note : The answer is provided in English, as requested by the user, despite the original question being in French.)
Additional Notes
The user’s X handle, "DarkFunifuteur," was mentioned but does not appear to be directly relevant to the question about the French waste affair in Indonesia. It could be used for context in future interactions if the user’s personal interests or background are relevant to the query.

The search and browsing actions were used to gather comprehensive and up-to-date information, ensuring the answer is based on reliable sources. The final answer prioritizes primary sources and includes citations for transparency and verification.

### Réponse directe

— -

### Note détaillée

#### Détails de l’incident
Le 30 juillet 2019, un responsable local indonésien a annoncé le renvoi de ces conteneurs, marquant une escalade dans les actions des pays asiatiques pour ne plus être des décharges des pays riches. Les conteneurs renvoyés vers la France étaient au nombre de deux, tandis que cinq autres étaient destinés à Hong Kong. Les autorités indonésiennes ont également mentionné attendre des autorisations pour renvoyer 42 autres conteneurs vers les États-Unis, l’Australie et l’Allemagne, indiquant une politique de retour systématique des déchets non conformes. Des articles de presse, comme ceux de *Le Monde* et *France 24*, confirment ces détails, soulignant que les déchets incluaient des matériaux dangereux, ce qui violait les réglementations internationales.

#### Réactions immédiates de la France
La France, via son ministère de la Transition écologique, a réagi en demandant des informations sur le contenu et la destination de ces cargaisons. Brune Poirson, alors secrétaire d’État à la Transition écologique, a mentionné sur Twitter la nécessité de caractériser les déchets pour déterminer s’ils étaient dangereux, avec des amendes potentielles de 150 000 euros pour non-conformité aux lois internationales, notamment pour l’exportation de déchets dangereux comme l’amiante sans notification. Cependant, aucune amende spécifique liée à cet incident avec l’Indonésie n’a été rapportée dans les sources consultées. Des articles comme celui de *Ouest-France* confirment que la France était "en attente" d’informations, mais sans mention de sanctions ultérieures.

#### Conséquences juridiques et politiques
Aucune information n’indique que des entreprises françaises impliquées dans cet exportation illégale vers l’Indonésie aient été amendées, contrairement à un cas similaire avec la Malaisie, où une société de courtage a été sanctionnée de 192 000 euros en 2019 pour avoir envoyé 20 conteneurs de déchets plastiques non recyclables, comme rapporté par *20 Minutes*. Cette différence suggère que l’incident avec l’Indonésie n’a peut-être pas entraîné de poursuites directes, ou que les détails n’ont pas été rendus publics.

Sur le plan politique, l’incident semble avoir contribué à une prise de conscience, comme en témoigne un projet de loi "anti-gaspillage" et pour une économie circulaire étudié à Paris en 2019, mentionné dans un entretien avec Thibault Turchet de Zero Waste France sur RFI. Cependant, il est difficile d’attribuer directement ces initiatives à cet événement spécifique, car elles s’inscrivent dans un contexte plus large de pression internationale et de réglementation européenne, notamment via la Convention de Bâle et le règlement (CE) 1013/2006 sur les transferts transfrontaliers de déchets.

Pour la France, les statistiques de 2023 montrent une exportation de 2,8 millions de tonnes de déchets, principalement vers des pays européens, avec une baisse des importations (-17 % par rapport à 2022), selon le portail statistique du développement durable. Cela suggère une tendance à la réduction des transferts transfrontaliers, mais sans lien direct avec l’incident indonésien.

#### Analyse comparative et tendances globales
Comparé à d’autres cas, comme la Malaisie, où des amendes ont été infligées, l’absence de sanctions pour l’Indonésie pourrait indiquer une gestion différente de l’incident, peut-être en raison de la complexité des preuves ou de la coopération entre les deux pays. Les recherches montrent que les exportations illégales de déchets vers l’Asie, notamment vers l’Indonésie, ont été facilitées par des coûts inférieurs à ceux du traitement local, comme expliqué dans *20 Minutes*. Cependant, la pression croissante des pays récepteurs a conduit à une réévaluation des pratiques, avec des initiatives comme la criminalisation des trafics de déchets, mentionnée dans un article de l’IHEMI en 2020.

#### Tableau récapitulatif des actions et conséquences

Aspect	Détails	Source
-----------------------------	-----------------------------------------------------------------------------	---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Retour des déchets	2 conteneurs renvoyés vers la France en 2019, contenant déchets dangereux.	Le Monde
Réaction française	Demande d’informations, pas d’amende rapportée pour cet incident.	France 24
Contexte international	Mouvement régional de refus, avec retours similaires vers d’autres pays.	Geo.fr
Impact politique en France	Projet de loi anti-gaspillage en 2019, mais lien incertain avec l’incident.	RFI

pages Web pertinentes

How Indonesia fighting waste crisis - ANTARA News
Jakarta (ANTARA) - On the morning of February 21, 2005, a garbage landslide in a 60-meter-high and 200-meter-long trash mountain at Leuwigajah landfill, Cimahi City, West Java, swept two residential areas and killed 157 people. The tragedy was caused by heavy rainfall and a methane gas explosion in the trash mountain. The catastrophe prompted the launch of National Waste Care Day (HPSN), which is commemorated every February 21 to raise people’s awareness on the hazards posed by waste to the environment, society, and health, including people’s lives. "Through National Waste Care Day, we are commemorating a very heartbreaking tragedy. Waste can cause deaths, if we are negligent," Director General of Waste and Hazardous Substance Management at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Rosa Vivien Ratnawati said during the HPSN 2023 commemoration event in Jakarta on February 21, 2023. Indonesia, which has a population of around 275 million, is currently facing serious problems due to waste.

en.antaranews.com

Plastic waste from Western countries is polluting Indonesia | World Economic Forum
Every 20 minutes, the equivalent of a 10-tonne truckload of plastic is dumped into the sea in Indonesia. Image : Reuters/Beawiharta · The government has sent waste shipments back, but they are often redirected elsewhere. For example, environmental groups Nexus3 and BAN found that just 12 of 58 containers returned to the United States arrived, Reuters reports. Instead, 38 arrived in India and the remaining containers were tracked to South Korea, Thailand, Vietnam, Mexico, the Netherlands and Canada. So, the problem persists. ... The world produces over 430 million tonnes of plastic each year, with 19 million tonnes leaking into the environment annually. Plastic pollution fuels climate change, biodiversity loss and ocean degradation, threatening ecosystems, public health and livelihoods. With plastic waste projected to rise dramatically by 2040, the stakes couldn’t be higher.

weforum.org

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong
Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said Tuesday, marking the latest move by a Southeast Asian nation to send back rubbish to their wealthy places of origin. The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam Island near Singapore. "The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart," head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesman Sumarna, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France. Authorities were still waiting for clearance to return another 42 containers of waste at the port, including shipments from the United States, Australia, and Germany.

phys.org

Wealthy nations shipped toxic waste to Indonesia. Now Indonesia is sending it back
JAKARTA, Indonesia — Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. The Directorate General of Customs said Tuesday that 49 containers at Batam port near Singapore will be returned to Australia, the U.S., France, Germany and Hong Kong after inspections showed their contents violated Indonesian laws on the import of hazardous and toxic waste. Separately, the head of customs at East Java’s Tanjung Perak port, Basuki Suryanto, said eight other containers with 210 tons of waste that arrived from Australia on June 20 were supposed to contain only paper but included other matter. Indonesia quake, tsunami:Dramatic rescues amid the rubble as death toll tops 800 ·

usatoday.com

Indonesia Cracks Down on the Scourge of Imported Plastic Waste - Yale e360
When China banned plastic waste imports in 2018, exporters in wealthy countries targeted other developing nations. Faced with an unending stream of unrecyclable waste, Indonesia has tightened its regulations and has begun to make progress in stemming the plastics flow. ... In 2019, at a meeting in Geneva, Switzerland, delegates from 187 countries approved the first-ever global rules on cross-border shipments of plastic waste. No longer could countries export contaminated, mixed, or unrecyclable plastics without the recipient country’s informed consent. It was a landmark step aimed at reducing the flood of wealthy nations’ scrap that had been deluging poorer regions, particularly Southeast Asia, since China closed its doors to such imports the previous year. Hopes were high that the agreement — enacted as a set of amendments to the Basel Convention, which sets rules for developed nations sending hazardous waste to less-developed ones — would help control abuses in the trade of discarded plastic, which was often ending up strewn in fields, clogging rivers, or burned in open heaps.

e360.yale.edu

Indonesia re-exporting illegal waste to other countries, report finds
that were contaminated with other waste never returned to the States after Indonesia rejected them. Image courtesy of Nexus3. “Containers do not just travel around the globe by themselves. Somebody directed them,” Yuyun Ismawati, a senior adviser to Nexus3, told Mongabay in a text message. Yuyun said the final destination of each shipment was determined before it left port, unless there was a strong reason for a diversion along the trip, such as a disaster or tsunami. “If the stated target destination of a shipment and the reality are different, then this is fraud,” she said. The containers, which had been destined from the U.S. to Indonesian paper recycling mills PT Mega Surya Eratama (MSE) and PT Surabaya Mekabox (SM), left Indonesia on board vessels operated by shipping companies Cosco, Maersk, and Hyundai Merchant Marine. Thirty-eight containers shipped by Cosco and Maersk ended up in India, while the others carried by Hyundai went to the other countries.

news.mongabay.com

A French Affair - Resourceful Indonesian
Fransoa , whose real name was Francois Xavier Renou , is a Frenchman who lives in Indonesia . Although Fransoa actually works in the field of jewelry and accessories , he began active in the field of music, writing and singing songs in Indonesian in the comedy-satire genre.

resourcefulindonesian.com

Plastic Waste Discharges from Rivers and Coastlines in Indonesia
Indonesia is battling one of the greatest environmental challenges of our time—marine plastic debris. To support the Government of Indonesia’s efforts on combating plastic waste and marine debris and its leadership in implementing the agenda, a better understanding regarding the current state of this challenge is needed. The Plastic Waste Discharges from Rivers and Coastlines in Indonesia report provides the first Indonesia-wide assessment integrating local waste data with actual hydrological conditions to tell the story of how local waste management practices contribute to marine plastic pollution. The report synthesizes waste records from more than 500 municipal and provincial areas across the archipelago—including annual rainfall, topography and river flow data—and models the movement of plastic waste from land-based sources into the marine environment.

worldbank.org

How European trash illegally ends up in Southeast Asia
After 2018, Indonesia experienced a sudden increase in waste imports, with paper and plastic waste predominantly shipped from western European countries, according to the Indonesia Bureau of Statistics. · Nexus3 found that plastic waste often contaminates paper scraps, posing an alarming threat to the environment and health in regions like Java or Sumatra. Problematic plastics are either discarded or donated by paper-importing companies to local communities, who then engage in illegal sorting and burning of plastic. The fires emit alarming levels of dioxins and hazardous chemicals and ultimately infiltrating human food chains. Due to the smoke and toxic food, many villagers develop respiratory and stomach diseases or even cancer and must leave their homes. Despite its detrimental consequences for health and the environment, waste trafficking is still seen as a highly lucrative criminal activity that goes under the radar in Southeast Asia.

dw.com

The Threat of Indonesian Waste Management Problem - Green Info
This February, we will welcome National Waste Care Day soon (Indonesia : Hari Peduli Sampah Nasional / HPSN) on February 21st, 2022. Recon to HPSN, we recall our memory about the incident of waste explosion in Leuwigajah Waste Processing Center located in Cimahi, West Java as the background of this memorial day. This incident happened on February 21st, 2005. It caused a waste slide that buried 2 villages. As a consequence, 157 people were found dead. Thus far, the waste problem in Indonesia is still problematic. The amount and type of waste always increases by population and technology growth. However, the promptness of waste management solutions are left behind. Waste production in Indonesia reaches 67,8 million tonnes each year. The organic waste amount is the biggest compared to other types of waste in Indonesia. The percentage of organic waste is 60% and plastic waste 14%. Moreover, various waste processing centers in Indonesia such as Bantar Gebang (Bekasi), Piyungan (Yogyakarta), Sarimukti (Bandung), Terjun (Medan), and Suwung (Denpasar) are overloaded.

greeneration.org

en.antaranews.com

Not Our Trash : Indonesia’s Struggle with World’s Plastic Waste | FairPlanet
As foreign plastic waste floods Indonesia, residents sort, burn, and even cook with waste to survive, meanwhile toxicity to human and non-human life soars.

fairplanet.org

Plastic waste from the U.S. fuels this village in Indonesia - Los Angeles Times
Asia’s crackdown on plastic waste, aimed at protecting the environment, is bad news for small-time recyclers in Indonesia who make a living sorting foreign garbage.

latimes.com

Indonesia, facing a waste crisis, plans to burn it for electricity
The Indonesian government has targeted four cities in Java island to build incineration facilities this year to tackle the country’s plastic waste crisis. Environmentalists say burning waste to generate electricity is not a sustainable solution to the issue, and will only add more problems, including the emission of toxic gases. They instead suggest tackling the problem at the source, by reducing the amount of waste produced in the first place. Indonesia is the world’s second-biggest source of the plastic trash that ends up in the oceans, after China. ... JAKARTA — The Indonesian government plans to burn waste to fuel power plants in four cities on the island of Java this year as part of efforts to tackle the country’s plastic waste crisis. Indonesia is the second-biggest contributor, after China, to the plastic waste that end up in the oceans, and is among a growing number of Asian countries refusing to import waste from developed countries.

news.mongabay.com

Comparing the Condition of Waste Management Workers in Indonesia and Other Countries - Artikel dan berita pengelolaan sampah dari Waste4Change
Waste is an environmental problem faced by many cities in Indonesia. The most alarming thing is that most landfill in Indonesia is in danger of being closed. This is because landfills are full of residual waste or unmanaged recyclable materials. Unfortunately, the handling of waste by the government and local governments in various regions in Indonesia still needs to be improved. The majority of regions still apply traditional methods of waste disposal, such as being burned, buried in the ground, or dumped into rivers, ditches, or the sea. Moreover, when the population continues to grow and the consumption culture continues to increase, it can cause problems for the environment. Such as blockage of rivers and water sources, sources of disease, pollution of groundwater, soil, and air. Unfortunately, the capacity of the waste management institution or institution is smaller than the amount of waste that must be managed.

waste4change.com

Treated like trash : south-east Asia vows to return mountains of rubbish from west | Plastics | The Guardian
Indonesian scavanger Suparno, 60, stands in front of burning plastic waste at an imported plastic dumpsite in Mojokerto. Photograph : Fully Handoko/EPAView image in fullscreen · Indonesian scavanger Suparno, 60, stands in front of burning plastic waste at an imported plastic dumpsite in Mojokerto. Photograph : Fully Handoko/EPA ... For the past year, the waste of the world has been gathering on the shores of south-east Asia. Crates of unwanted rubbish from the west have accumulated in the ports of the Philippines, Indonesia and Vietnam while vast toxic wastelands of plastics imported from Europe and the US have built up across Malaysia. But not for much longer it seems. A pushback is beginning, as nations across south-east Asia vow to send the garbage back to where it came from. Last week the president of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte, threatened to sever diplomatic ties with Canada if the government did not agree to take back 69 containers containing 1,500 tonnes of waste that had been exported to the Philippines in 2013 and 2014.

theguardian.com

Indonesia Warns Rich Countries Against Making It Dumping Ground - Bloomberg
U.S. identified by Indonesian officials as worst offender · Australian billionaire dragged into illegal waste issue · A man stands next to one of 65 containers full of imported plastic rubbish at the Batu Ampar port in Batam. ... This article is for subscribers only. Indonesia said it will crack down on trash imported from the world’s richest countries after closer inspections showed it’s increasingly the recipient of toxic waste materials. Authorities at ports have boosted checks after a random inspection in May led to the discovery of more than 80 containers containing illegal waste from the U.S., Australia and Europe. One of Australia’s richest men has been dragged into the furor after a media report alleged a company he owned was responsible for a shipment that contained materials considered toxic under Indonesian law. Have a confidential tip for our reporters ?

bloomberg.com

French convict on Indonesian death row loses clemency appeal | Reuters
An Indonesian court rejected a French national’s last-ditch appeal against the death sentence on Monday, making him the latest foreigner to face execution for drug offences and prompting a message of support for the prisoner from France.

reuters.com

Indonesia returns seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong | South China Morning Post
Indonesia has returned seven containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong. Photo : AFP ... Indonesia has returned seven containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong.

scmp.com

Recognizing Indonesia’s Informal Waste Workforce - Modern Diplomacy
Waste has been a critical problem in Indonesia. Reportedly, 40.16% of the 33.7 million tons of waste generated in 2024 was unmanaged. ... Waste has been a critical problem in Indonesia. Reportedly, 40.16% of the 33.7 million tons of waste generated in 2024 was unmanaged. This statistic has forced the country to renew its 100% waste management target from 2025 to 2029. Besides, 48% of Indonesian households burn their waste despite the legal prohibition of such activity, causing air pollution and respiratory diseases. Amidst the shortcomings in Indonesia’s waste management system, the contribution of its informal waste pickers is inevitable. The informal sector collects around 1 million tons of plastic waste, which mostly ends up at recycling facilities. In Jakarta alone, informal waste pickers have estimatedly reduced the waste volume by 30%, not only reducing the recycling costs for municipalities but also helping to extend the lifespan of dumps and sanitary landfills.

moderndiplomacy.eu

The rich countries practice waste colonialism | D+C - Development + Cooperation
Industrialised countries not only outsource a majority of their often environmentally hazardous production processes to poorer countries, they also dispose of considerable amounts of waste there. The consequences are disastrous for the affected regions – and for the whole world. ... The Agbogbloshie landfill in Ghana provides income for many people. Part of Europe’s electronic waste lies at the huge Agbogbloshie electronic-waste dump in Ghana. Fires are burning everywhere, sending toxic fumes over mountains of old refrigerators, computers and televisions. “Toxic city” is the name given to the dump that covers 16 square kilometres in Ghana’s capital Accra. An estimated 40,000 people live here. The fact that it is known that most of the waste is exported from rich countries is largely due to the work of civil-society organisations, which have drawn increasing attention to the issue in recent years.

dandc.eu

France-Indonesia Strategic Partnership Shouldn’t Neglect Rights | Human Rights Watch
Military ties between France and Indonesia have been bolstered by a Defense Cooperation Agreement and Indonesia’s purchase of 42 French Rafale warplanes and two Scorpene-class attack submarines. Indonesia is France’s second largest customer in Asia after India for military equipment. However, when Macron meets with Prabowo, he should not lose sight that he is facing a man implicated in grave rights violations going back decades. The United Nations Special Prosecutor’s Office accused him of commanding forces responsible for the massacre of up to 200 men in East Timor in 1983, but he failed to answer a summons and never faced prosecution. He was dismissed from the Indonesian army in 1998 as special forces commander for ordering the kidnapping of student activists, 13 of whom remain disappeared. Since winning the presidency in 2024, Prabowo has appeared determined to restore the military’s role in civilian affairs, which was long characterized by widespread abuses and impunity.

hrw.org

WASTE MANAGEMENT : Addressing the Negative Impacts of Waste Imports to Indonesia - ECOTON
Indonesia’s plastic waste imports are more than 194,000 tons in 2022. However, some of this waste has not been managed properly. Residents dry on the village road pieces of plastic packaging sorted from imported waste in front of their houses in Bangun Village, Pungging District, Mojokerto Regency, East Java, Monday (8/7/2019). Most residents in the area depend on their lives by sorting imported waste from paper factories. Import of waste or non-hazardous and toxic waste (B3) for paper and plastic groups is still carried out by a number of countries, including Indonesia. Based on the United Nations Commodity Trade Statistics Database (UN Comtrade), in 2022 the volume of Indonesian plastic waste imports reached more than 194,000 tons. A 2021 report from the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime noted that waste imports from Western countries to Asia and Africa have been going on since the 1970s.

ecoton.or.id

Jakarta’s Trash Mountain : ‘When People Are Desperate for Jobs, They Come Here’ - The New York Times
BEKASI, Indonesia — Even in the pouring rain, in the middle of the night, they are out scavenging, wearing headlamps to scan a mountain of rotting garbage more than 15 stories high. The trash pickers, some trudging up the heap in mismatched plastic boots, use a hooked metal tool called a “ganco” to flip items over their heads and into large rattan baskets strapped on their backs. A few sort through the trash with their bare hands. The stench is overpowering, but it’s only one of many workplace hazards. As they pick through the jumble looking for discarded wood, cardboard, plastic tarps and anything else that can be recycled, they must be careful not to come too close to the bulldozers distributing the waste across an ever-rising plateau. Landslides are a constant danger. This is Bantar Gebang, one of the world’s largest landfills, more than 200 football fields in size, accepting as much as 7,000 tons of waste a day from Jakarta, Indonesia’s capital.

nytimes.com

Three-fourths of waste in Jakarta’s notoriously polluted rivers is plastic
Most of the waste collected from the rivers and holding facilities in Indonesia’s capital, Jakarta, is plastic, new field-based research has found. Researchers note that the plastic debris recovered from the surface water amounted to 9.9 grams, or a third of an ounce, per person on average, which is lower than an estimate from a widely cited 2015 study. The researchers have called for a better mitigation strategy to eliminate plastic pollution in rivers and subsequently the ocean. Indonesia, a country of more than 270 million people, is the No. 2 contributor to global marine plastic pollution, behind only China. ... JAKARTA — The Citarum River that skirts the Indonesian capital, Jakarta, is infamous as the most polluted river on Earth. The rivers inside Jakarta aren’t in much better state, either, with a new study showing that most of the waste collected from the city’s rivers is plastic.

news.mongabay.com

Indonesia’s Ban on Importing Plastic Waste Met With Cautious Optimism From Campaigners
The Indonesian government has attempted to regulate waste imports through stricter policies. In 2021, along with new international laws under the Basel Convention, it introduced regulations requiring direct shipments from exporters to importers to improve monitoring. The government also set a contamination limit of 2 percent for imported waste. Ecoton’s executive director, Dr. Daru Setyorini, said there had been a reduction in dumping since the peak in around 2019-2020, but that regulations were poorly enforced. In some cases the dumping had simply shifted elsewhere. “Despite the 2 percent contamination rule, we have found contamination levels of up to 30 percent in some imports,” Setyorini said. The waste also often bypassed regulations by being reclassified as industrial raw material rather than scrap plastic, she said. Ecoton’s executive director, Dr.

thediplomat.com

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong
Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said Tuesday. It’s the latest move by a Southeast Asian nation to send rubbish back to its wealthy places of origin. Issued on : 30/07/2019 - 15:31Modified : 30/07/2019 - 16:21 · Indonesian officials examine containers of waste from Australia, in the port of Surayaba, 9 July 2019. Antara Foto/Didik Suhartono/ via REUTERS ... The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam Island, near Singapore. "The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart," head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP on Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesman Sumarna told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France.

rfi.fr

The Unseen Danger : How COVID-19 Reveals Indonesia’s Medical Waste Problem | Pulitzer Center
The Unseen Danger : How COVID-19 Reveals Indonesia’s Medical Waste Problem. Indonesia has been widely criticized for its slow response to the pandemic that reached more than 26,000 cases and more than 1,600 deaths—and still counting—as of late May. The government refused to...

pulitzercenter.org

Indonesia sends rubbish back to Australia and says it’s too contaminated to recycle | Environment | The Guardian
The Philippines returned about 69 containers of rubbish back to Canada last month, putting an end to a diplomatic row between the two countries. Last week, Indonesia announced it was sending back 49 containers full of waste to France and other developed nations. Global concern over plastic pollution has been spurred by shocking images of waste-clogged rivers in Southeast Asia and accounts of dead sea creatures found with kilos of refuse in their stomachs. Environmental group WWF says about 300m tonnes of plastic are produced each year, with much of it ending up in landfills, waterways or oceans. As it repatriates unsanctioned waste, Indonesia has its own huge domestic rubbish issues to contend with. Many across the archipelago continue to burn toxic waste as a form of disposal, while each year tonnes of waste are dumped in the country’s rivers and oceans.

theguardian.com

Indonesia to Return Toxic Developed World Waste – The Diplomat
Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic, and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. The Directorate General of Customs said Tuesday that 49 containers at Batam port near Singapore will be returned to Australia, the United States, France, Germany, and Hong Kong after inspections showed their contents violated Indonesian laws on the import of hazardous and toxic waste. Separately, the head of customs at East Java’s Tanjung Perak port, Basuki Suryanto, said eight other containers with 210 tons of waste that arrived from Australia on June 20 were supposed to contain only paper but included other matter. “It turned out those containers also had household waste, used cans, plastic bottles, used oil packaging, used electronics, used baby diapers and used footwear.

thediplomat.com

Indonesia returning waste to US, other wealthy nations | The Hill
Importing hazardous waste into Indonesia is a criminal offense, Directorate General of Customs spokesman Deni Surjantiro added, with a maximum 12-year prison sentence and a maximum fine of 12 billion rupiah, roughly $850,000. Southeast Asia has increasingly been a destination for developed nations’ waste since China banned the import of plastic waste in 2017. A recent study using United Nations data estimated that other nations would need to take on more than 110 million tons of plastic waste by 2030 because of the Chinese ban. ... Roy Blunt says Merrick Garland confirmation would’ve been ‘mistake for him ... Cruz pans McCarthy saying debt deal has nothing for Dems ‘There are $4 ... ... Trump criticizes Texas Gov. Abbott for silence on impeachment of AG Ken Paxton · McConnell endorses debt-limit deal, calls on Senate conservatives not to delay ...

thehill.com

Indonesia returning hundreds of containers of waste to West
Indonesia is sending back hundreds of containers of contaminated waste to the West after shipments supposedly containing plastic meant for recycling were found to hide hazardous substances, customs officials said.

phys.org

Indonesia returning 57 containers of wealthy nations’ waste, including US | KXAN Austin
Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeas…

kxan.com

Indonesia to return 49 containers of waste to Europe, US
Dozens of shipping containers full of waste will be returned to France and other developed countries, Indonesia said Tuesday, as Southeast Asian nations increasingly reject serving as dumping grounds for international trash. The 49 containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam island. "We are coordinating the with the importer to immediately process their return," customs office spokesman Sumarna, who goes by one name, told AFP. The waste came from the United States, Australia, France, Germany and Hong Kong, he added. Last month, Jakarta returned five containers of waste to the United States, joining a chorus of Southeast Asian nations that are increasingly unhappy about being used as dumping grounds for trash from Western countries.

phys.org

Indonesia returning 57 containers of developed world’s waste
Indonesian custom officers show off the front of a foreign newspaper amoung waste found in a container at the Tanjung Perak port in Surabaya, East Java, Indonesia, Tuesday, July 9, 2019. Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of imported waste back to Western nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. (AP Photo) JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) — Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. The Directorate General of Customs said Tuesday that 49 containers at Batam port near Singapore will be returned to Australia, the U.S., France, Germany and Hong Kong after inspections showed their contents violated Indonesian laws on the import of hazardous and toxic waste.

apnews.com

Indonesia to send 49 containers of trash back to Europe and US | Daily Sabah
A scavenger collects plastic waste for recycling on the Citarum river choked with garbage and industrial waste, in Bandung, West Java province on June 26, 2019 (AFP Photo) ... Dozens of shipping containers full of waste will be returned to France and other developed countries, Indonesia said Tuesday, as Southeast Asian nations increasingly reject serving as dumping grounds for international trash. The 49 containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam island. "We are coordinating the with the importer to immediately process their return," customs office spokesman Sumarna, who goes by one name, told AFP. The waste came from the United States, Australia, France, Germany and Hong Kong, he added. Last month, Jakarta returned five containers of waste to the United States, joining a chorus of Southeast Asian nations that are increasingly unhappy about being used as dumping grounds for trash from Western countries.

dailysabah.com

On the French border, drowning in a sea of trash – POLITICO
In 2017, Daguin’s agents reported 7 metric tons of waste illegally trafficked into France. A year later, this had shot up to 139 metric tons — about the weight of a blue whale. The 2019 figures are not yet available, but Daguin said they are likely to confirm the upward trend. It’s unclear why the dumping has increased so rapidly, although officials suggest it may be linked to the rising cost of proper waste treatments. This is not the first time that European garbage has gone astray despite some of the most stringent waste-disposal legislation in the world. In 2018, the U.K.’s Daily Telegraph reported that thousands of metric tons of British plastic waste were being imported to Poland by a “trash mafia” and burned instead of recycled. ... When gendarmes and customs officers from France and Luxembourg launched a coordinated crackdown on vehicles carrying waste across the border in late January, they found 2.5 metric tons in just a couple of hours.

politico.eu

Indonesia to send ‘contaminated’ waste back to West | The Independent | The Independent
Indonesia is sending waste back to wealthy nations after discovering they were contaminated with used plastic and hazardous materials. The move came amid a growing backlash in southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. For now, 547 containers of waste will be returned to their countries of origin, including the UK, although more are being investigated. Nine containers with at least 135 tons of rubbish were sent back to Australia on Wednesday, customs director Heru Pambudi said at a news conference in Jakarta. “Some food still remains there with liquid flowing,” Mr Pambudi said as he showed the contents of several containers. ... Sherpas discover discarded tents and other litter at Camp Four, the highest camp on Mount Everest on 21 May 2019 ... Workers from a recycling company in Kathmandu dump rubbish collected from Mount Everest on 5 June 2019 ...

independent.co.uk

Indonesia returning 57 containers of developed world’s waste | WIVT - NewsChannel 34
JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) — Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a gr…

binghamtonhomepage.com

Indonesia to return 210 tonnes of waste to Australia | Environment News | Al Jazeera
Last week, Indonesia said it was sending back 49 containers of waste to France and other countries. In May, neighbouring Malaysia announced it was shipping 450 tonnes of imported plastic waste back to its sources, including Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, China, Japan, Saudi Arabia and the United States. ... The Philippines, meanwhile, returned about 69 containers of rubbish to Canada last month, putting an end to a diplomatic row between the two countries. The South East Asian countries have began receiving huge quantities of rubbish since China’s decision in 2018 to ban imports of foreign plastic waste left developed nations struggling to find places to send their rubbish. The opposition to handling exported waste has been growing in the region. Global concern over plastic pollution has been spurred by images of waste-clogged rivers in South East Asia and accounts of dead sea creatures found with kilos of refuse in their stomachs.

aljazeera.com

Indonesia Returns Shipping Containers of Waste to US, EU, Australia - Environment+Energy Leader
Customs officials on Batam Island in Indonesia told AFP that there were 49 containers filled with garbage, plastic waste, and hazardous materials from the United States, Australia, France, Germany, and Hong Kong. Journalists from the Age and the Sydney Morning Herald reported that 65 shipping containers of international waste are currently impounded at Batam’s Batu Ampar port. One of them is from Australia, they learned. Today the journalists said they found paperwork showing that an Australian company had exported the container with the intention for it to go to the Indonesian recycling firm Royal Citra Bersama. “The document shows the container was sent by Visy, one of the world’s biggest recycling companies, inspected in Melbourne on May 21, 2019, marked as ‘non-B3’ mixed plastic scrap — that is, non-toxic waste,” they wrote. “It was shipped to the Batu Ampar port in Batam where customs officials opened it and found it stinking and leaking black sludge with visible maggots.” ·

environmentenergyleader.com

Indonesia to return 49 containers of waste to Europe, US | New Straits Times

nst.com.my

Europa

eea.europa.eu

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong | The Straits Times
JAKARTA (AFP) - Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said on Tuesday (July 30), marking the latest move by a South-east Asian nation to send back rubbish to their wealthy places of origin. The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam. "The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart," head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP on Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesman Sumarna, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France. Authorities were still waiting for clearance to return another 42 containers of waste at the port, including shipments from the United States, Australia and Germany.

straitstimes.com

qui sont les responsables ?

Perplexity :
Sélectionner le texte
dechets-infos.com favicon
1. - Déchets Infos
dechets-infos.com/plastiques-exp…
Plastiques exportés : un courtier sanctionné, Poirson pointe les ...
Un courtier en déchets a écopé d’une amende de 192 000 € faute de notification d’exportation. Les clients du courtier vont devoir récupérer les déchets. Brune Poirson met en garde les recycleurs qui passeraient par des courtiers pour des exportations illégales.
geo.fr favicon
2. Geo
geo.fr/environnement/d…
Déchets envoyés en Asie : amende française pour une société de ...
La France a infligé une amende de 192.000 euros à une société de courtage pour avoir envoyé 20 conteneurs de déchets plastiques en Malaisie, qui les avait...
image
latribune.fr favicon
3. La Tribune Nouvelle
latribune.fr/entreprises-fi…
La France sanctionne un envoi de déchets en plastique en Malaisie
Le ministère de la Transition écologique a infligé une amende administrative à une société de courtage. C’est une première en France.
lexpress.fr favicon
4. L’Express
lexpress.fr/monde/asie/dec…
Déchets renvoyés en Malaisie : amende de 192 000 euros contre ...
La société de trading responsable d’avoir envoyé ses déchets plastiques en Asie du Sud-Est a été condamnée par l’État français.
enviroveille.com favicon
5. enviroveille.com
enviroveille.com/public/fiches_…
Les obligations du négociant et du courtier de déchets - Enviroveille
Le service de veille en droit de lenvironnement santé et sécurité des CCI ## Fiches Pratiques ## Les obligations du négociant et du courtier de déchets Les Les activités de négoce et de courtage des déchets sont réglementées par les articles R 541-54-1 à R 541-61 du Code de l’environnement. Le négociant est tout acteur de la gestion des déchets qui entreprend pour son propre compte l’acquisition et la vente ultérieure de déchets. Cela comprend également les négociants qui ne prennent pas...
faq.trackdechets.fr favicon
6. faq.trackdechets.fr
faq.trackdechets.fr/dechets-danger…
Informations réglementaires - Foire aux questions Trackdéchets
Les courtiers et négociants de déchets dangereux sont concernés par l’obligation d’usage de Trackdéchets, au titre de l’article de l’article n°2021-321.
sudouest.fr favicon
7. Sud Ouest
sudouest.fr/environnement/…
Deux conteneurs de déchets français refoulés par l’Indonésie, la ...
Ces conteneurs appartenant à une société française de courtage en déchets se trouvent actuellement en Malaisie
8. Bio à la Une
bioalaune.com/fr/actualite-b…
Deux conteneurs de déchets français rejetés par l’Indonésie ...
Deux conteneurs de déchets venus de France, et refoulés d’Indonésie, se trouvent désormais bloqués en Malaisie, a indiqué mardi la secrétaire d’Etat française à l’Écologie, qui souhaiterait leur retour pour en contrôler le contenu.
image
lalsace.fr favicon
9. L’Alsace
lalsace.fr/france-monde/2…
Environnement | Pollution. L’Indonésie renvoie les déchets français
Deux conteneurs de déchets, arrivés illégalement sur l’île indonésienne de Batam, ont été réexpédiés lundi vers l’Hexagone par les autorités locales. ...
lemonde.fr favicon
10. Le Monde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets illégalement importés
Environ 300 millions de tonnes de plastique sont produites dans le monde chaque année. Une partie importante de ces déchets est envoyée par les pays développés en Asie du Sud-Est.
image
tahiti-infos.com favicon
11. TAHITI INFOS, les informations de Tahiti
tahiti-infos.com/Conteneurs-de-…
Conteneurs de déchets renvoyés d’Indonésie : la France attend des ...
Paris, France | AFP | mardi 30/07/2019 - La France est "en attente" d’informations sur le contenu et la destination de conteneurs de déchets renvoyés lundi par l’Indonésie qui les juge importés illégalement, a indiqué mardi la secrétaire d’Etat à la Transition écologique...
bfmtv.com favicon
12. BFM Business
bfmtv.com/economie/conso…
Une société française expédie des déchets plastique en Asie - BFMTV
Une amende de 192.000 euros a été infligée par le ministère de la Transition écologique à une société ayant expédié de façon illicite des déchets plastique en Malaisie. Ce pays les avait renvoyés cet été à l’expéditeur français, ce qui a permis à l’État de retrouver sa trace.
lemonde.fr favicon
13. Le Monde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
De nos poubelles jaunes aux décharges de Malaisie - Le Monde
En 2019, 385 000 tonnes de plastiques usagés français ont été envoyées à l’étranger, dont 60 000 en Asie. En bout de la chaîne de recyclage, ces déchets sont parfois abandonnés dans des décharges sauvages par des sous-traitants peu scrupuleux.
image
geo.fr favicon
14. Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/l…
L’Indonésie va renvoyer 49 conteneurs de déchets en Europe et aux ...
L’Indonésie va renvoyer des dizaines de conteneurs de déchets vers la France et d’autres pays occidentaux, à l’instar de plusieurs pays d’Asie du ...
gavroche-thailande.com favicon
15. Gavroche Thaïlande
gavroche-thailande.com/malaisie-franc…
MALAISIE - FRANCE : Qui a couvert l’envoi de déchets plastiques ...
L’affaire a fait grand bruit voici quelques jours. Une société de trading coupable d’avoir expédié en Malaisie vingt containers de déchets plastiques illégaux et polluants a été condamnée à 192 000 euros d’amende après une plainte des autorités malaisiennes. Mais qui est responsable ? Pourquoi les autorités portuaires françaises n’ont rien signalé ? Pourquoi le nom de cette société n’a pas été donné dans les différents articles de presse ? Selon les informations recueillies par Gavroche, la compagnie incriminée était aussi habituée à envoyer ces containers polluants vers l’Indonésie et vers les Philippines. le ministère de la transition écologique a annoncé avoir infligé cette amende sans donner plus de précisions.
fr.euronews.com favicon
16. Euronews
fr.euronews.com/2019/07/30/aff…
Affaire des conteneurs : Paris réagit - Euronews.com
L’Indonésie a renvoyé vers la France et Hong Kong sept conteneurs renfermant des déchets ménagers, plastiques et matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation.
echoline.fr favicon
17. echoline.fr
echoline.fr/blog/reglement…
Focus Exportation de déchets : connaissez-vous les règles ...
26/11/2019 00:00:00 - Producteurs de déchets ou prestataires connaissez-vous vos obligations lors de l’exportation de déchets ? Il vaudrait mieux, si l’on en...
18. Actu-Environnement
actu-environnement.com/ae/news/citeo-…
L’État et Citeo recadrent l’exportation de déchets recyclables vers l ...
Une société de trading a été sanctionnée d’une amende de 192 000 euros par le ministère de la Transition écologique pour avoir exporté illégalement vingt conteneurs de déchets plastique en Malaisie, rapporte Le Parisien. Les douanes malaisienne avaie...
Évalué
usinenouvelle.com favicon
L’Usine Nouvelle
usinenouvelle.com/article/l-indo…
L’Indonésie refuse d’être la poubelle du monde et renvoie des ...
Le 30 juillet 2019, l’Indonésie a annoncé avoir renvoyé sept conteneurs vers la France et Hong-Kong. Les autorités locales se sont...-Matières premières
dna.fr favicon
Les Dernières Nouvelles d’Alsace
dna.fr/environnement/2…
Environnement | Pollution. L’Indonésie renvoie les déchets français
Deux conteneurs de déchets, arrivés illégalement sur l’île indonésienne de Batam, ont été réexpédiés lundi vers l’Hexagone par les autorités locales. ...
Direction générale du Trésor
tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/…
Les importations de déchets plastiques en Indonésie
L’Indonésie, 2e pollueur aux déchets plastiques des océans, pourrait devenir un importateur majeur de déchets plastiques suite aux restrictions d’importation émises par la Chine et plusieurs pays d’ASEAN. Le gouvernement indonésien réfléchit à renforcer sa réglementation pour encadrer ces importations.
bfmtv.com favicon
BFM Business
bfmtv.com/economie/econo…
L’Indonésie renvoie 49 conteneurs de détritus vers la ... - BFMTV
L’Indonésie va renvoyer des dizaines de conteneurs de déchets vers la France et d’autres pays occidentaux, à l’instar de plusieurs pays d’Asie du Sud-Est qui ne veulent plus être des décharges, ont annoncé mardi les autorités.
revolutionpermanente.fr favicon
Revolution Permanente
revolutionpermanente.fr/L-Indonesie-re…
L’Indonésie renvoie à la France des conteneurs de déchets illégaux
Après la Chine, la Malaisie et les Philippines, l’Indonésie renvoie à son tour des conteneurs de déchets toxiques illégalement exportés de France et d’Hong Kong. Une pratique qui rappelle la nécessité d’allier lutte écologique et lutte contre l’impérialisme qui entretient la domination des pays semi-coloniaux, premiers à subir la destruction de l’environnement.
lejdd.fr favicon
Lejdd.fr
lejdd.fr/Societe/on-vou…
On vous explique pourquoi la France exporte ses déchets en Asie
Confrontés à un amoncellement de déchets venus de pays occidentaux, des Etats d’Asie du Sud-Est renvoient tour à tour des conteneurs à l’expéditeur. Cette semaine, l’Indonésie en a acheminé deux vers la France. Mais pourquoi Paris et ses voisins expédient-ils leurs déchets à l’autre bout du monde ? Explications.
youtube.com favicon
youtube
youtube.com/watch ?v=eS-nqm…
Pourquoi l’Indonésie renvoie deux conteneurs de déchets ...
Dans ce conteneur, des déchets plastiques en tout genre. Leur destination : la France. L’Indonésie a décidé de renvoyer plusieurs tonnes de déchets plastiques dans leurs pays d’origine. Et ce n’est pas le seul pays d’Asie à s’y mettre. La Malaisie, les Philippines, le Cambodge, et le Sri Lanka ont tous fait ce choix. Mais pourquoi ces pays ont-ils décidé de renvoyer des conteneurs ?. Pour comprendre, il faut remonter au 1er janvier 2018, date à laquelle la Chine bloque l’importation de 24 catégories de déchets solides, dont certains plastiques, pour des motifs écologiques...
france24.com favicon
france24.com
france24.com/fr/20190731-in…
L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut des précisions
You don’t have permission to access the page you requested. What is this page ? The website you are visiting is protected. For security reasons this page cannot be displayed. You don’t have permission to access the page you requested. What is this page ? The website you are visiting is protected. For security reasons this page cannot be displayed.
Direction générale du Trésor
tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/…
Veolia Indonesia pose la première pierre d’une usine de recyclage ...
Veolia Indonesia a organisé le 21 mars 2019 une cérémonie de pose de la première pierre de sa future usine de recyclage de bouteilles plastiques PET dans la zone industrielle de Pasuruan (Java Est), qui devrait être mise en service au premier trimestre 2020. Cette cérémonie s’est tenue en présence de Danone Aqua, partenaire de Veolia pour l’aval du recyclage pour ce projet, de l’Ambassade de Franc
oneheart.fr favicon
oneheart.fr
oneheart.fr/actualites/pou…
Pourquoi nos déchets sont-ils envoyés en Asie ? - One Heart
Laura Chatel de Zero Waste France répond à nos questions !
scrapad.com favicon
Compra y venta de chatarra y material reciclable – ScrapAd
scrapad.com/fr/blog/obliga…
Obligations légales des courtiers et négociants en déchets - ScrapAd
Dans le domaine de la gestion des déchets, les courtiers et les négociants jouent un rôle clé et sont soumis à des obligations légales.
Team France Export
teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorie…
VEOLIA et DANONE ont lancé leur usine de recyclage plastique à l ...
PT Veolia Services Indonesia (Veolia Indonesia) en collaboration avec PT Tirta Investama (Danone-AQUA) a lancé une usine de recyclage de bouteilles en…
zerowastefrance.org favicon
ZeroWasteFR
zerowastefrance.org/export-dechets…
Exports de déchets et retours à l’envoyeur : analyse d’une crise ...
Suite à la fermeture des frontières chinoises annoncée en 2017, et de l’effet domino qui s’en est suivi en Asie, un véritable séisme agite le monde du traitement des déchets. Partie 2/3 du dossier : retour sur la décision chinoise, et la très récente évolution du droit international en matière d’exports de plastiques.
Team France Export
teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorie…
La BAsD signe un prêt de 44,2 M USD pour une usine indonésienne…
La Banque asiatique de Développement (BAsD) a signé un accord pour un prêt de 44,2 M USD pour PT. ALBA Tridi Plastics Recycling Indonesia, la filiale…
image
ipp.eu favicon
ipp
ipp.eu/wp-content/uplo…
[PDF] EXPORTATIONS FRANÇAISES DE DÉCHETS PLASTIQUES
ment hors de l’UE – principalement vers la Chine et Hong Kong – tandis que le reste a été envoyé vers l’UE. Après 2017, on observe une augmentation des exportations françaises vers la Malaisie et d’autres pays d’Asie de l’Est. En revanche, les exportations n’ont pas augmenté vers les autres pays de l’UE et, dans l’ensemble, ont chuté de 30 000 tonnes en 2018, ce qui semble indiquer qu’une plus grande quantité de déchets plastiques a dû être traitée au niveau national. 4... plément est évalué...
scrapad.com favicon
Compra y venta de chatarra y material reciclable – ScrapAd
scrapad.com/fr/blog/differ…
Différences entre négociant et courtier en déchets - ScrapAd
Dans cet article de blog, nous vous présentons les principales différences entre un négociant et un courtier en déchets. Découvrez leurs définitions ici.
veolia.com favicon
Veolia
veolia.com/fr/villes/indo…
Préserver l’écosystème marin en Indonésie - Veolia
Veolia opère à Pasuruan la plus grande usine de recyclage de bouteilles PET du pays pour Danone-AQUA
geo.fr favicon
Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/d…
Depuis l’Europe vers l’Asie, et inversement : l’odyssée d’une ... - GEO
Que contiennent le Campton et le Candor, navires qui devaient faire route depuis l’Albanie vers la Thaïlande ? De l’oxyde de fer, déchet dont l’exportation est autorisée, ou des déchets toxiques ? En tout cas, les deux bateaux ont été contraints de rebrousser chemin.
France Nature Environnement
fne.asso.fr/communique-pre…
Exportations illégales de déchets : condamnation des exploitants de ...
Le Tribunal correctionnel de Châlons-en-Champagne vient de rendre ce mercredi une décision reconnaissant la culpabilité des exploitants de la société D3E Recyclage s’agissant d’infractions à la législation sur les installations classées et en matière de transfert transfrontaliers de déchets.
image
L’Opinion Indépendante
lopinion.com/articles/actua…
Au sud de Toulouse : une collectivité rappelée à l’ordre sur la ...
Le tribunal administratif de Toulouse a ordonné à la communauté de communes Cœur de Garonne de reprendre la collecte de déchets en porte-à-porte.
Actu-Environnement
actu-environnement.com/ae/news/condam…
Exportation illégale de déchets : condamnation des gérants de D3E ...
Le tribunal correctionnel de Châlons-en-Champagne a condamné mercredi 29 février les deux gérants de la société D3E Recyclage basée à Pargny-sur-Saulx (Marne), poursuivis pour avoir exporté des déchets informatiques non dépollués et sans traçabilité....
SEBAN AVOCATS
seban-associes.avocat.fr/dechets-actual…
Déchets : actualités jurisprudentielles sur le rôle de l’Etat dans la ...
CAA Toulouse, 16 mars 2023, Société Umicore France, n° 21TL00688 Deux décisions des juridictions administratives, rendues par la Cour administrative […]
greenpeace.fr favicon
Greenpeace France
greenpeace.fr/condamnation-d…
Condamnation de Trafigura pour exportation de déchets toxiques
Ce 23 juillet, le géant du négoce pétrolier Trafigura a été condamné par un tribunal néerlandais pour avoir exporté illégalement des déchets toxiques du port d’Amsterdam en Côte d’Ivoire. La multinationale Trafigura a également été reconnue coupable d’avoir dissimulé la nature toxique des déchets lors de leur livraison pour traitement à l’entreprise APS. Trafigura a […]
novethic.fr favicon
Novethic
novethic.fr/actualite/envi…
Déchets envoyés en Asie : amende inédite de 192 000 euros pour ...
Fini les tours de passe-passe frauduleux pour exporter nos déchets vers l’Asie. C’est le message envoyé par le ministère de la Transition écologique et solidaire qui vient d’infliger une amende de 192 000 euros à une société de courtage en déchets. Une première. Cette société – dont le nom n’a pas été dévoilé- avait envoyé 20 […]
lavalette.pro favicon
LAVALETTE Avocats conseils
lavalette.pro/categories/act…
quand le juge administratif sanctionne la suppression de la collecte ...
Par une décision en date du 11 décembre 2023 (Ordonnance TA Toulouse, 11/12/2023, n°2306402), le juge des référés près le Tribunal administratif de Toulouse,...
Sudmag
sudmag.nc/2021/08/04/une…
Une société condamnée pour stockage illégal de déchets ... - Sudmag
Une sanction exemplaire vient d’être prononcée à l’encontre de la société Nel Import-Export pour stockage illégal de déchets d’équipements électriques et électroniques et non-respect de la réglementation des installations classées et des impacts environnementaux. Suite à un signalement de l’association EPLP, relatif à des stockages de déchets réglementés au titre du code de l’environnement de […]
image
environnement-magazine.fr favicon
EnviroMag
environnement-magazine.fr/recyclage/arti…
La Malaisie renvoie 43 conteneurs de déchets illégaux en France
Depuis que la Chine a interdit, en 2018, l’importation de déchets plastiques sur son territoire, de nombreuses usines illégales de recyclage sont apparues en Malaisie. Comme les autorités locales refusent que leur pays devienne la nouvelle décharge du monde, elles ont annoncé le renvoi de 150 conteneurs de déchets illégaux dans leur pays d’origine, dont 43 en France.
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr favicon
tribunal-administratif
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr/Media/mediathe…
[PDF] TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF DE TOULOUSE N° 2306402
la fréquence hebdomadaire n’a pas été modifiée et les camions poubelles n’emportent plus désormais que le quart du volume qu’ils emportaient en 2022 ; - les décisions contestées portent une atteinte extrêmement grave, immédiate et actuelle aux usagers vulnérables dès lors que le dispositif impose, pour les personnes qui sont incapables d’effectuer le transport de leurs sacs de déchets, de compenser elles-mêmes leur handicap, de solliciter l’aide de tiers ou de faire le choix de laisser les...
France Nature Environnement
fne.asso.fr/actualites/une…
Une société de traitement de déchets condamnée à 200 000 € d ...
Trop d’installations industrielles passent sous les radars de la justice pénale, même lorsqu’elles commettent des infractions qui impactent l’environnement et la santé.
breakfreefromplastic.org favicon
Break Free From Plastic
breakfreefromplastic.org/fr/2020/01/21/…
150 conteneurs de déchets plastiques renvoyés, 110 autres suivront ...
La ministre de l’Énergie, des Sciences, de la Technologie, de l’Environnement et du Changement climatique, Yeo Bee Yin, a déclaré que cela était « sans précédent » car le gouvernement n’a pas déboursé une seule somme.
georisques.gouv.fr favicon
georisques.gouv
georisques.gouv.fr/webappReport/w…
[PDF] Arrêté de mise en demeure à l’encontre de M. Patrick COMBY ...
Actu Justice
actu-justice.fr/sanctions-pour…
Sanctions pour infractions à la législation sur les déchets industriels
La gestion des déchets industriels constitue un enjeu environnemental majeur, encadré par une législation de plus en plus stricte. Face aux risques de pollution et aux impacts sur la santé publique, les autorités ont mis en place un arsenal de sanctions visant à dissuader les infractions et à responsabiliser les…
image
lemonde.fr favicon
lemonde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
Déchets illégalement envoyés en Malaisie : une société de trading ...
legifrance.gouv.fr favicon
legifrance.gouv
legifrance.gouv.fr/juri/id/CETATE…
cour administrative d’appel de Toulouse - 4ème chambre - Légifrance
sciencesetavenir.fr favicon
Sciences et Avenir
sciencesetavenir.fr/nature-environ…
L’Indonésie renvoie des conteneurs de déchets vers la France
L’Indonésie a renvoyé 7 conteneurs de déchets vers la France et vers Hong Kong.
geo.fr favicon
Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/l…
La Malaisie renvoie 150 conteneurs de déchets vers plusieurs pays ...
La Malaisie a renvoyé 150 conteneurs de déchets plastiques illégaux vers leurs pays d’origine, dont 43 vers la France, ont annoncé lundi les autor...
dailymotion.com favicon
Dailymotion
dailymotion.com/video/x7es7i3
L’Indonésie renvoie des conteneurs de déchets à la France
Les douanes indonésiennes ont décidé de renvoyer 49 conteneurs de déchets jugés illégaux, dont certains venus de France. Retrouver toutes les infos sur la vidéo sur : https://www.francetvinfo.fr/sante/environnement-et-sante/l-indonesie-renvoie-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-a-la-france_3558157.html
Données et études statistiques pour le changement climatique, l’énergie, l’environnement, le logement et les transports
statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-t…
Les échanges transfrontières de déchets faisant l’objet d’une ...
En 2022, la France a importé 6 millions de tonnes de déchets soumis à une procédure de notification préalable et en a exporté 2,9 millions de tonnes. Les États membres de l’Union européenne ayant été encouragés à détourner leurs déchets de la mise en décharge pour les recycler, le mouvement transfrontalier de déchets destinés à être valorisés a connu une croissance rapide depuis le début des années 2000. Conformément au principe de proximité, les importations (essentiellement des terres et cailloux non dangereux) et les exportations (souvent des déchets de bois non dangereux) de la France impliquent rarement des pays situés en dehors des frontières européennes. Plus de 90 % des échanges sont motivés par la valorisation.
rfi.fr favicon
rfi.fr
rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifiq…
La crise des déchets en Asie « nous met face à nos incohérences »
Plus de résultats
ifi-id.com favicon
Institut français Indonésie
ifi-id.com/fr/cooperation…
Coopération franco-indonésienne contre la pollution plastique
La réduction de la pollution plastique accompagnée de la gestion des déchets représentent toujours un défi environnemental majeur pour la France comme pour l’Indonésie. Face à cette problématique urgente, des initiatives franco-indonésiennes se renforcent ou prennent forme pour apporter des solutions durables. L’une des collaborations notoires dans ce domaine est celle menée par l’entreprise sociale … Continuer la lecture de « Coopération franco-indonésienne contre la pollution plastique : vers un avenir plus durable avec OceanKita »
image
rfi.fr favicon
RFI
rfi.fr/fr/podcasts/rep…
Indonésie : la lutte contre le plastique à Bali - Reportage international
L’Indonésie est le plus grand archipel du monde et le pays a ouvertement déclaré la guerre au plastique en 2017, en présentant un plan national de lutte contre ce fléau polluant. Alors qu’on estime que…
lemonde.fr favicon
Le Monde.fr
lemonde.fr/indonesie
Indonésie - Actualités, vidéos et infos en direct - Le Monde
Toute l’actualité sur le sujet Indonésie. Consultez l’ensemble des articles, reportages, directs, photos et vidéos de la rubrique Indonésie publiés par Le Monde.
image
National Geographic
nationalgeographic.fr/environnement/…
La Chine refuse l’importation de déchets plastiques, provoquant une ...
Cet article fait partie de la campagne Planète ou Plastique ? et est produit en partenariat avec la National Geographic Society. Lorsque le président américain a signé un projet de loi renouvelant le programme fédéral relatif aux débris marins, il a reproché à l’Asie d’avoir pollué les océans du monde. Il a accusé le Japon, la Chine et « beaucoup, beaucoup de pays » d’avoir jeté à la mer des déchets plastiques qui flottent désormais sur la côte ouest des États-Unis. « Et nous devons maintenant...
justiceinfo.net favicon
JusticeInfo.net
justiceinfo.net/fr/134240-crim…
Crimes liés aux déchets en Italie : le défi de la justice ...
En Italie, les crimes environnementaux transfrontaliers, comme ceux liés au trafic des déchets, sont commis par des "écomafias" rarement poursuivies. La justice transitionnelle pourrait-elle offrir des solutions ?
cfie.net favicon
cfie
cfie.net/wp-content/upl…
[PDF] Biodiversité, climat, France, énergie Déchets, océans, Indonésie

Pour répondre de manière approfondie à votre question sur les responsables de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie, je vais d’abord rechercher des informations récentes et fiables en explorant les actualités, les rapports officiels, et les enquêtes journalistiques, en ciblant spécifiquement les acteurs impliqués, qu’ils soient individuels, institutionnels ou industriels, tout en tenant compte du contexte géopolitique et environnemental récent.
Recherche

affaire déchets français Indonésie

déchets France Indonésie responsables

scandale déchets français Indonésie
Lire les sources · 11
lalsace.fr favicon
Environnement | Pollution. L’Indonésie renvoie les déchets françaislalsace
geo.fr favicon
L’Indonésie va renvoyer 49 conteneurs de déchets en Europe et aux ...geo
usinenouvelle.com favicon
L’Indonésie refuse d’être la poubelle du monde et renvoie des ...usinenouvelle
dna.fr favicon
Environnement | Pollution. L’Indonésie renvoie les déchets françaisdna
Les importations de déchets plastiques en Indonésietresor.economie.gouv
bfmtv.com favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie 49 conteneurs de détritus vers la ... - BFMTVbfmtv
lemonde.fr favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets illégalement importéslemonde
revolutionpermanente.fr favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie à la France des conteneurs de déchets illégauxrevolutionpermanente
lejdd.fr favicon
On vous explique pourquoi la France exporte ses déchets en Asielejdd
youtube.com favicon
Pourquoi l’Indonésie renvoie deux conteneurs de déchets ...youtube
france24.com favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut des précisionsfrance24
Investigating the specific companies and exporters involved in the French waste shipments to Indonesia.
Recherche

entreprises françaises déchets Indonésie

exportateurs déchets France Indonésie noms

qui a exporté déchets France Indonésie
Identifying the companies and intermediaries involved in exporting French waste to Indonesia.
Recherche

sociétés recyclage France déchets Indonésie

négoce déchets France Asie

courtiers déchets France exportation
Lire les sources · 17
Veolia Indonesia pose la première pierre d’une usine de recyclage ...tresor.economie.gouv
oneheart.fr favicon
Pourquoi nos déchets sont-ils envoyés en Asie ? - One Heartoneheart
scrapad.com favicon
Obligations légales des courtiers et négociants en déchets - ScrapAdscrapad
dechets-infos.com favicon
Plastiques exportés : un courtier sanctionné, Poirson pointe les ...dechets-infos
VEOLIA et DANONE ont lancé leur usine de recyclage plastique à l ...teamfrance-export
lemonde.fr favicon
De nos poubelles jaunes aux décharges de Malaisie - Le Mondelemonde
echoline.fr favicon
Focus Exportation de déchets : connaissez-vous les règles ...echoline
geo.fr favicon
Déchets envoyés en Asie : amende française pour une société de ...geo
zerowastefrance.org favicon
Exports de déchets et retours à l’envoyeur : analyse d’une crise ...zerowastefrance
enviroveille.com favicon
Les obligations du négociant et du courtier de déchets - Enviroveilleenviroveille
La BAsD signe un prêt de 44,2 M USD pour une usine indonésienne…teamfrance-export
ipp.eu favicon
[PDF] EXPORTATIONS FRANÇAISES DE DÉCHETS PLASTIQUESipp
faq.trackdechets.fr favicon
Informations réglementaires - Foire aux questions Trackdéchetsfaq.trackdechets
L’État et Citeo recadrent l’exportation de déchets recyclables vers l ...actu-environnement
scrapad.com favicon
Différences entre négociant et courtier en déchets - ScrapAdscrapad
veolia.com favicon
Préserver l’écosystème marin en Indonésie - Veoliaveolia
geo.fr favicon
Depuis l’Europe vers l’Asie, et inversement : l’odyssée d’une ... - GEOgeo
Examining recent legal actions related to illegal waste export practices involving France and Malaysia.
Recherche

amende 192000 euros déchets Malaisie France

courtier déchets Toulouse sanctionné

société condamnée exportation illégale déchets
Lire les sources · 19
latribune.fr favicon
La France sanctionne un envoi de déchets en plastique en Malaisielatribune
Exportations illégales de déchets : condamnation des exploitants de ...fne.asso
lexpress.fr favicon
Déchets renvoyés en Malaisie : amende de 192 000 euros contre ...lexpress
Au sud de Toulouse : une collectivité rappelée à l’ordre sur la ...lopinion
Exportation illégale de déchets : condamnation des gérants de D3E ...actu-environnement
gavroche-thailande.com favicon
MALAISIE - FRANCE : Qui a couvert l’envoi de déchets plastiques ...gavroche-thailande
Déchets : actualités jurisprudentielles sur le rôle de l’Etat dans la ...seban-associes.avocat
greenpeace.fr favicon
Condamnation de Trafigura pour exportation de déchets toxiquesgreenpeace
novethic.fr favicon
Déchets envoyés en Asie : amende inédite de 192 000 euros pour ...novethic
lavalette.pro favicon
quand le juge administratif sanctionne la suppression de la collecte ...lavalette
Une société condamnée pour stockage illégal de déchets ... - Sudmagsudmag
environnement-magazine.fr favicon
La Malaisie renvoie 43 conteneurs de déchets illégaux en Franceenvironnement-magazine
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr favicon
[PDF] TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF DE TOULOUSE N° 2306402toulouse.tribunal-administratif
Une société de traitement de déchets condamnée à 200 000 € d ...fne.asso
breakfreefromplastic.org favicon
150 conteneurs de déchets plastiques renvoyés, 110 autres suivront ...breakfreefromplastic
georisques.gouv.fr favicon
[PDF] Arrêté de mise en demeure à l’encontre de M. Patrick COMBY ...georisques.gouv
Sanctions pour infractions à la législation sur les déchets industrielsactu-justice
lemonde.fr favicon
Déchets illégalement envoyés en Malaisie : une société de trading ...lemonde
legifrance.gouv.fr favicon
cour administrative d’appel de Toulouse - 4ème chambre - Légifrancelegifrance.gouv
Investigating the French government’s response and authorities’ involvement regarding illegal waste exports to Indonesia.
Recherche

ministère transition écologique Brune Poirson déchets Indonésie

gouvernement français réaction déchets renvoyés Indonésie

autorités françaises déchets illégaux Asie
Lire les sources · 10
sudouest.fr favicon
Deux conteneurs de déchets français refoulés par l’Indonésie, la ...sudouest
Deux conteneurs de déchets français rejetés par l’Indonésie ...bioalaune
sciencesetavenir.fr favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie des conteneurs de déchets vers la Francesciencesetavenir
geo.fr favicon
La Malaisie renvoie 150 conteneurs de déchets vers plusieurs pays ...geo
tahiti-infos.com favicon
Conteneurs de déchets renvoyés d’Indonésie : la France attend des ...tahiti-infos
bfmtv.com favicon
Une société française expédie des déchets plastique en Asie - BFMTVbfmtv
dailymotion.com favicon
L’Indonésie renvoie des conteneurs de déchets à la Francedailymotion
fr.euronews.com favicon
Affaire des conteneurs : Paris réagit - Euronews.comfr.euronews
Les échanges transfrontières de déchets faisant l’objet d’une ...statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv
rfi.fr favicon
La crise des déchets en Asie « nous met face à nos incohérences »rfi
Terminé

# L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie : responsables et enjeux

L’affaire des déchets français renvoyés par l’Indonésie en 2019 implique plusieurs niveaux de responsabilité, des entreprises privées françaises aux autorités gouvernementales. Cette crise révèle les dysfonctionnements du système mondial de gestion des déchets plastiques.

## Les acteurs privés : courtiers et négociants en déchets

### L’entreprionnée

Une société française de courtage en déchets, basée dans le sud de la France près de Toulouse, constitue le principal responsable identifié[1][2][3]. Cette entreprise, dont le nom n’a pas été divulgué par les autorités, a écopé d’une amende administrative record de 192 000 euros pour avoir envoyé illégalement 20 conteneurs de déchets plastiques en Malaisie[2][3][4]. Selon certaines sources, il pourrait s’agir d’une SARL unipersonnelle au capital de 180 000 euros, affirmant avoir 5 salariés et ayant réalisé un chiffre d’affaires de 5,3 millions d’euros en 2018[1].

### Le rôle des courtiers dans le trafic de déchets

Les courtiers en déchets sont des intermédiaires qui organisent la valorisation ou l’élimination de déchets pour le compte de tiers[5][6]. Dans cette affaire, l’entreprise française avait vendu le contenu de conteneurs à une société indonésienne, prétendant qu’il s’agissait de matières recyclables licites[7][8]. Cependant, les autorités indonésiennes ont considéré ces déchets comme non conformes et en violation des règles d’importation[9][10].

## Les autorités françaises et leur réaction

### Le ministère de la Transition écologique

Le ministère de la Transition écologique, dirigé à l’époque par la secrétaire d’État Brune Poirson, a joué un rôle central dans la gestion de cette crise[7][8][11]. Les services du ministère ont été mobilisés pour "faire la transparence sur les responsabilités - et le cas échéant sur les infractions - des entreprises exportatrices de conteneurs de déchets à l’étranger"[8].

### Mesures prises par les autorités

Brune Poirson a exigé que l’entreprise française renvoie les conteneurs en France pour contrôler leur contenu[7][8]. Elle a également averti que "toutes les entreprises dont les cargaisons font l’objet de renvoi des pays destinataires seront poursuivies en France"[4][12]. Cette amende de 192 000 euros constitue une première en France et s’accompagne d’un signalement à la justice[2][3].

## Le contexte plus large des exportations illégales

### L’ampleur du phénomène

En 2019, la France a exporté 385 000 tonnes de plastiques usagés à l’étranger, dont 60 000 tonnes vers l’Asie[13]. Cette situation s’est aggravée depuis la décision de la Chine en 2018 d’interdire l’importation de la majorité des déchets plastiques, provoquant un "chaos sur le marché mondial du recyclage"[9][14][10].

### Les filières de complicité

Selon des experts, ces exportations illégales impliquent souvent des réseaux de complicité incluant "des policiers, des douaniers, et des fonctionnaires dans plusieurs ports français"[15]. Les conteneurs de déchets non recyclables sont déclarés comme du plastique recyclable pour contourner les procédures de contrôle[13].

## Les conséquences et sanctions

### Sanctions financières et judiciaires

Outre l’amende administrative de 192 000 euros, l’entreprise responsable fait l’objet de poursuites judiciaires[2][3]. La législation française prévoit des sanctions pouvant aller jusqu’à 150 000 euros d’amende pour l’exportation illégale de déchets dangereux sans notification[11][16].

### Impact diplomatique

Cette affaire a créé un contentieux diplomatique entre la France et l’Indonésie. Deux conteneurs initialement refoulés par l’Indonésie se sont retrouvés bloqués en Malaisie, obligeant les autorités françaises à négocier leur rapatriement[7][8].

## Les acteurs institutionnels et leur rôle

### Le Pôle National des Transferts Transfrontaliers de Déchets (PNTTD)

Depuis 2017, le PNTTD constitue l’autorité compétente en France pour les procédures d’exportation de déchets avec notification et consentement préalable[17]. Les entreprises doivent effectuer leurs démarches via la plateforme GISTRID pour respecter la réglementation.

### L’éco-organisme Citeo

Citeo, organisme chargé du recyclage des emballages ménagers, affirme que seulement 1% des 3,5 millions de tonnes d’emballages recyclés est envoyé au "grand export"[2][18]. L’organisme a renforcé ses contrôles suite à cette affaire, particulièrement pour les destinations asiatiques.

L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie révèle un système complexe où les responsabilités se partagent entre des entreprises privées peu scrupuleuses exploitant les failles réglementaires, des autorités françaises réactives mais parfois dépassées par l’ampleur du phénomène, et un contexte international perturbé par la fermeture du marché chinois. Cette crise a marqué un tournant dans la politique française de contrôle des exportations de déchets, avec des sanctions exemplaires et un renforcement des procédures de surveillance.

[1] https://dechets-infos.com/plastiques-exportes-un-courtier-sanctionne-poirson-pointe-les-recycleurs-4921181.html
[2] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/dechets-envoyes-en-asie-amende-francaise-pour-une-societe-de-courtage-une-premiere-198624
[3] https://www.latribune.fr/entreprises-finance/transitions-ecologiques/la-france-sanctionne-un-envoi-de-dechets-en-plastique-en-malaisie-833053.html
[4] https://www.lexpress.fr/monde/asie/dechets-renvoyes-en-malaisie-amende-de-192-000-euros-contre-une-societe-francaise_2107172.html
[5] https://www.enviroveille.com/public/fiches_pratiques/fiches-pratiques.html?cat_id=1&dossier_id=128836&fiche_id=109670
[6] https://faq.trackdechets.fr/dechets-dangereux-classiques/negociants-courtiers/informations-reglementaires
[7] https://www.sudouest.fr/environnement/deux-conteneurs-de-dechets-francais-refoules-par-l-indonesie-la-ministre-brune-poirson-demande-leur-retour-2487236.php
[8] https://www.bioalaune.com/fr/actualite-bio/37991/deux-conteneurs-dechets-francais-rejetes-lindonesie-actuellement-bloques-malaisie
[9] https://www.lalsace.fr/france-monde/2019/07/31/l-indonesie-renvoie-les-dechets-francais
[10] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html
[11] https://www.tahiti-infos.com/Conteneurs-de-dechets-renvoyes-d-Indonesie-la-France-attend-des-precisions_a183697.html
[12] https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/consommation/une-societe-francaise-expedie-des-dechets-plastique-en-asie-elle-ecope-d-une-grosse-amende_AN-201911140041.html
[13] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2020/09/18/de-nos-poubelles-jaunes-aux-decharges-de-malaisie-comment-une-partie-des-dechets-francais-est-exportee-frauduleusement-en-asie_6052655_3244.html
[14] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/lindonesie-va-renvoyer-49-conteneurs-de-dechets-en-europe-et-aux-etats-unis-196371
[15] https://www.gavroche-thailande.com/malaisie-france-qui-a-couvert-lenvoi-de-dechets-plastiques-illegaux-vers-lasie-du-sud-est/
[16] https://fr.euronews.com/2019/07/30/affaire-des-conteneurs-paris-reagit
[17] https://www.echoline.fr/blog/reglementation-exportation-dechets
[18] https://www.actu-environnement.com/ae/news/citeo-etat-exportation-dechets-recyclables-asie-34409.php4
[19] https://www.usinenouvelle.com/article/l-indonesie-refuse-d-etre-la-poubelle-du-monde-et-renvoie-des-conteneurs-vers-la-france.N871230
[20] https://www.dna.fr/environnement/2019/07/31/l-indonesie-renvoie-les-dechets-francais
[21] https://www.tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/07/29/les-importations-de-dechets-plastiques-en-indonesie
[22] https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/economie-social/monde/l-indonesie-renvoie-49-conteneurs-de-detritus-vers-la-france-l-allemagne-et-les-etats-unis_AN-201907020051.html
[23] https://www.revolutionpermanente.fr/L-Indonesie-renvoie-a-la-France-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-illegaux
[24] https://www.lejdd.fr/Societe/on-vous-explique-pourquoi-la-france-exporte-ses-dechets-en-asie-3912663
[25] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eS-nqmjxvjw
[26] https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions
[27] https://www.tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/04/12/veolia-indonesia-pose-la-premiere-pierre-d-une-usine-de-recyclage-du-plastique
[28] https://www.oneheart.fr/actualites/pourquoi-nos-dechets-sont-ils-envoyes-en-asie
[29] https://scrapad.com/fr/blog/obligations-legales-des-courtiers-et-negociants-en-dechet/
[30] https://www.teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorielles/10474/10474-economie-circulaire-veolia-et-danone-ont-lance-leur-usine-de-recyclage-plastique-a-lest-de-java
[31] https://www.zerowastefrance.org/export-dechets-retours-envoyeur-analyse-crise-mondiale-2-3/
[32] https://www.teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorielles/26991/26991-la-basd-signe-un-pret-de-442-m-usd-pour-une-usine-indonesienne-de-recyclage-de-plastique
[33] https://www.ipp.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/n64-notesIPP-avril2021.pdf
[34] https://scrapad.com/fr/blog/differences-entre-negociant-et-courtier-en-dechets/
[35] https://www.veolia.com/fr/villes/indonesie-transformer-dechets-plastiques-nouvelles-ressources
[36] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/depuis-l-europe-vers-l-asie-et-inversement-l-odyssee-d-une-mysterieuse-cargaison-de-dechet-222396
[37] https://fne.asso.fr/communique-presse/exportations-illegales-de-dechets-condamnation-des-exploitants-de-la-societe-d3e
[38] https://lopinion.com/articles/actualite/20659_toulouse-collectivite-rappelee-a-lordre-collecte-dechets
[39] https://www.actu-environnement.com/ae/news/condamnation-societe-recyclage-dechets-electroniques-illegal-15087.php4
[40] https://www.seban-associes.avocat.fr/dechets-actualites-jurisprudentielles-sur-le-role-de-letat-dans-la-sanction-des-depots-sauvages/
[41] https://www.greenpeace.fr/condamnation-de-trafigura-pour-exportation-de-dechets-toxiques-un-premier-pas-vers-la-justice/
[42] https://www.novethic.fr/actualite/environnement/dechets/isr-rse/dechets-envoyes-en-asie-amende-inedite-de-192-000-euros-pour-une-societe-de-courtage-147900.html
[43] https://www.lavalette.pro/categories/actualites-du-cabinet-19001/articles/collecte-des-dechets-menagers-quand-le-juge-administratif-sanctionne-la-suppression-de-la-collecte-en-porte-a-porte-35.htm
[44] https://sudmag.nc/2021/08/04/une-societe-condamnee-pour-stockage-illegal-de-dechets-et-non-respect-de-la-reglementation-des-installations-classees/
[45] https://www.environnement-magazine.fr/recyclage/article/2020/01/21/127530/malaisie-renvoie-43-conteneurs-dechets-illegaux-france
[46] https://toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr/Media/mediatheque-ta-toulouse/import/2306402-ok
[47] https://fne.asso.fr/actualites/une-societe-de-traitement-de-dechets-condamnee-a-200-000-eu-d-amende
[48] https://www.breakfreefromplastic.org/fr/2020/01/21/150-containers-of-plastic-waste-shipped-back-penang-malaysia/
[49] https://georisques.gouv.fr/webappReport/ws/installations/document/8a9fb09d583eb2bd01583f0e602d0075
[50] https://www.actu-justice.fr/sanctions-pour-infractions-a-la-legislation-sur-les-dechets-industriels-un-cadre-juridique-en-evolution/
[51] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/11/14/dechets-illegalement-envoyes-en-malaisie-une-societe-de-trading-devra-payer-192-000-euros-d-amende_6019141_3244.html
[52] https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/juri/id/CETATEXT000049744917
[53] https://www.sciencesetavenir.fr/nature-environnement/pollution/l-indonesie-renvoie-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-vers-la-france-et-hong-kong_135972
[54] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/la-malaisie-renvoie-150-conteneurs-de-dechets-vers-plusieurs-pays-dont-la-france-199534
[55] https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7es7i3
[56] https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-transfrontieres-de-dechets-faisant-lobjet-dune-notification-prealable-en-2022
[57] https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france

ont-ils été identifiés et arrêtés ?

Claude :
Based on my research, voici ce que je peux vous dire sur l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie :

## **Le contexte de l’affaire (2019)**

L’Indonésie a réexpédié vers la France et Hong Kong sept conteneurs renfermant déchets ménagers, plastiques et matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation en juillet 2019. Cette décision s’inscrit dans une politique plus large : Jakarta ne veut plus être la décharge des pays riches.

## **Absence d’informations sur les responsables**

**Aucune arrestation identifiée** : Mes recherches n’ont pas permis d’identifier des responsables français spécifiques qui auraient été arrêtés ou poursuivis pour cette affaire. Les articles de l’époque se concentrent sur la dimension diplomatique et environnementale plutôt que sur les aspects judiciaires.

**Réaction officielle française** : Le ministère français de l’Écologie a demandé des informations sur le contenu des conteneurs renvoyés, mais aucune suite judiciaire publique n’est documentée.

## **Un problème systémique plus large**

**Le "colonialisme des déchets"** : La France produit deux fois plus de déchets que la moyenne mondiale, et en exporte encore une grande partie vers des pays moins riches et moins bien équipés pour gérer le flux de détritus.

**Manque de traçabilité** : Des États d’Asie du Sud-Est renvoient tour à tour des conteneurs à l’expéditeur, ce qui suggère un système d’exportation où les responsabilités individuelles sont difficiles à établir.

## **Évolution récente**

L’Indonésie va interdire les importations de déchets plastiques à partir de 2025, ce qui devrait considérablement réduire ce type de trafic.

L’absence de poursuites identifiées illustre probablement la complexité juridique de ces affaires transfrontalières et le caractère souvent "légal" (bien qu’éthiquement discutable) de ces exportations de déchets vers l’Asie du Sud-Est.

quelles en sont les conséquences ?

Deepseek :
Search results
france24.com1
L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut ...
31 Tem 2019 — L’Indonésie a annoncé, mardi, le renvoi vers la France et Hong Kong de conteneurs de déchets jugés illégalement importés.
lalsace.fr2
Pollution. L’Indonésie renvoie les déchets français
31 Tem 2019 — Deux conteneurs de déchets, arrivés illégalement sur l’île indonésienne de Batam, ont été réexpédiés lundi vers l’Hexagone par les autorités ...
20minutes.fr3
Pourquoi la France envoie-t-elle une partie de ses déchets ...
30 Tem 2019 — Selon les autorités, ils renfermaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’ ...
ifi-id.com4
Coopération franco-indonésienne contre la pollution ...
11 Ara 2024 — Selon le National Plastic Action Plan (NPAP) instauré en 2017, le pays s’était engagé à réduire les déchets plastiques de 30 % et les fuites de ...
sciencesetavenir.fr5
Refoulés d’Indonésie, deux conteneurs de déchets français ...
10 Eyl 2019 — Selon le ministère indonésien de l’Environnement, 20 conteneurs au total devaient être renvoyés vers la France car jugés non conformes.
franceinfo.fr6
Indonésie : des Français font la chasse aux plastiques à Bali
18 Ağu 2023 — Depuis deux ans et demi, ils ont installé 180 barrières. Chacune peut intercepter chaque jour entre 5 et 150 kg de plastique. Le travail de la ...
usinenouvelle.com7
L’Indonésie refuse d’être la poubelle du monde et renvoie ...
30 Tem 2019 — Le 30 juillet 2019, elle a annoncé avoir renvoyé sept conteneurs vers la France et Hong-Kong, importés illégalement, selon les douanes locales.
lejdd.fr8
On vous explique pourquoi la France exporte ses déchets ...
2 Ağu 2019 — Mafias, décharges à l’air libre, pollution de l’air et des cours d’eau, maladies respiratoires... Des filières parallèles se développent. Dans ...
radiofrance.fr9
Les pays poubelles réexpédient les déchets à l’envoyeur, ...
30 Tem 2019 — Fatigués d’être les poubelles des pays riches, plusieurs pays d’Asie décident de renvoyer les déchets à leurs expéditeurs.
tresor.economie.gouv.fr10
La lutte contre la pollution marine aux déchets plastiques en ...
6 May 2019 — L’Indonésie est le deuxième pollueur aux déchets plastiques des océans mais a conscience de l’urgence de la situation à remédier aux consé ...
geo.fr11
Conteneurs de déchets : l’Indonésie intensifie les retours à l ...
4 Eyl 2019 — Sur l’île indonésienne de Batam proche de Singapour, 49 conteneurs de déchets non conformes ont été saisis et renvoyé vers les Etats-Unis, l’ ...
franceinfo.fr12
l’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets plastiques à la France
8 Tem 2019 — L’Indonésie refuse de devenir la poubelle du monde. 49 conteneurs bourrés de déchets plastiques et de matières dangereuses de plusieurs pays ...
lapresse.ca13
L’Indonésie va renvoyer des déchets en Europe et aux ...
2 Tem 2019 — Les 49 conteneurs contiendront des détritus, des déchets plastiques et des substances dangereuses en violation des règles d’importation, selon ...
ici.radio-canada.ca14
La dérive des déchets plastiques suivie par satellite en ...
4 Ara 2020 — Ces déchets représentent un danger pour des centaines d’espèces marines et d’oiseaux et un risque encore peu étudié pour la santé humaine via ...
lemonde.fr15
L’Indonésie renvoie vers la France des déchets ...
30 Tem 2019 — Ces conteneurs renfermaient des déchets ménagers, des déchets plastiques et des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation, selon ...
plasticodyssey.org16
Collecte et prétraitement des déchets à Kendari, Indonésie ...
1 Tem 2024 — En Indonésie, malgré plusieurs lois encadrant la gestion et le recyclage des déchets depuis 2008, leur application reste inégale selon les ré ...
veolia.com17
Préserver l’écosystème marin en Indonésie - Veolia
En Indonésie, transformer les déchets plastiques en nouvelles ressources. Veolia construit la plus grande usine de recyclage de bouteilles plastiques du pays ...
meretmarine.com18
Des équipes françaises planchent sur la dérive des ...
25 Eyl 2020 — Les premiers résultats ont permis de montrer que 90% des déchets s’échouent sur le littoral, selon un communiqué de CLS. « C’est une bonne ...
fr.euronews.com19
L’Indonésie renvoie des conteneurs de déchets ...
30 Tem 2019 — Après la Chine en 2018, la Malaisie et les Philippines en mai dernier, l’Indonésie vient de renvoyer

Hmm, je vois que l’utilisateur s’interroge sur les conséquences de l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie. En parcourant les résultats de recherche, je constate que plusieurs articles traitent de cet incident survenu en 2019.
Parmi les éléments clés, je note que l’Indonésie a renvoyé deux conteneurs de déchets vers la France, contenant des déchets ménagers, plastiques et même des matériaux dangereux en violation des règles d’importation 12. Ces déchets avaient été expédiés par une entreprise française de courtage, et ont transité par la Malaisie avant leur retour 5.
Sur le plan diplomatique, l’affaire a créé des tensions entre les deux pays. Brune Poirson, alors secrétaire d’État français, a exigé le retour des conteneurs pour enquête 15. L’Indonésie a profité de l’occasion pour durcir sa position contre les importations illégales de déchets, rejoignant ainsi d’autres pays asiatiques comme la Malaisie et les Philippines dans ce mouvement 7.
Économiquement, cet incident a révélé la fragilité du système français de gestion des déchets. Les articles expliquent que l’exportation vers l’Asie coûtait seulement 5 à 10 euros la tonne, contre 30 000 euros en France 3. Cette pratique était motivée par des considérations purement financières.
L’affaire a aussi mis en lumière les problèmes environnementaux en Indonésie, avec des initiatives comme OceanKita qui tentent de lutter contre la pollution plastique 46. Le pays produit 6,8 millions de tonnes de déchets plastiques annuellement, dont une grande partie finit dans l’océan 4.
Je vais organiser ma réponse autour de ces différents aspects : diplomatique, réglementaire, économique, environnemental et médiatique. Je mentionnerai aussi les initiatives de coopération qui ont émergé suite à cette crise, comme les projets de nettoyage conjoints.
L’utilisateur semble chercher une analyse complète plutôt qu’un simple résumé. Peut-être s’intéresse-t-il aux implications plus larges du commerce international des déchets. Je vais donc inclure des éléments sur l’évolution des politiques environnementales dans les deux pays depuis cet incident.

L’affaire des déchets français renvoyés par l’Indonésie en 2019 a eu des conséquences multidimensionnelles, révélant les failles du système international de gestion des déchets et accéléré des changements politiques, environnementaux et économiques. Voici une analyse détaillée des impacts :
⚖️ 1. Crise diplomatique et tensions internationales

Demande d’explications officielle : La secrétaire d’État française Brune Poirson a exigé des clarifications sur la nature des déchets (dangereux ou non) et leur trajet, soulignant l’opacité des filières d’exportation 15.

Déstabilisation des relations : Le renvoi des conteneurs (initialement expédiés par une entreprise française de courtage) a été perçu comme une violation des règles internationales, forçant la France à réagir pour éviter une escalade 57.

Solidarité asiatique : L’Indonésie s’est jointe à la Malaisie, aux Philippines et à la Chine dans un mouvement régional de refus d’être "la poubelle de l’Occident", renvoyant aussi des déchets vers l’Australie, les États-Unis et l’Allemagne 17.

🛑 2. Durcissement réglementaire et contrôles renforcés

Sanctions dissuasives : La France a menacé les entreprises exportatrices de déchets illégaux d’amendes jusqu’à 150 000 €, visant à responsabiliser les producteurs 15.

Audits des filières : Les autorités françaises ont intensifié les contrôles sur les exportations de déchets, exigeant leur rapatriement pour analyse (ex. : conteneurs déviés vers la Malaisie) 5.

Impact sur la législation européenne : Cet incident a alimenté les débats aboutissant à l’interdiction des plastiques à usage unique en 2021 dans l’UE, et poussé à repenser l’économie circulaire 78.

💸 3. Perturbations économiques et limites du recyclage

Révélation d’une dépendance coûteuse : L’exportation massive (250 000 tonnes de plastique français en 2017) était motivée par des coûts dérisoires (5-10 €/tonne en Asie vs 30 000 €/tonne en France) 38.

Crise du marché post-chine : Le blocage des importations par la Chine en 2018 avait reporté les flux vers l’Asie du Sud-Est, saturant des pays aux capacités de tri limitées et déclenchant des retours massifs 17.

Défis techniques : Les déchets exportés étaient souvent des plastiques "bas de gamme" (ex. : emballages composites) non recyclables en l’état, finissant dans des décharges sauvages ou brûlés, générant pollution et mafias locales 38.

🌱 4. Prise de conscience écologique et initiatives locales

Mobilisation indonésienne : Le pays a accéléré son National Plastic Action Plan visant une réduction de 70% des déchets marins d’ici 2025, avec des nettoyages de rivières (ex. : projet Ciliwung ramassant 66 kg de plastiques/jour) 46.

Initiatives franco-indonésiennes : Des projets comme OceanKita (soutenu par la France) ont émergé, combinant nettoyage côtier, sensibilisation et renforcement des communautés locales (ex. : plantation de mangroves à Untung Jawa) 46.

Impact médiatique : L’affaire a exposé les dégâts environnementaux (pollution des sols, microplastiques dans la chaîne alimentaire), catalysant l’action citoyenne (ex. : l’association Sungai Watch à Bali interceptant 150 kg de plastique/jour) 64.

🗣️ 5. Répercussions médiatiques et pression sur les industriels

Critiques des ONG : Zero Waste France a dénoncé l’"illusion du recyclage" et plaidé pour la réduction à la source des déchets, via un "malus" sur les suremballages 38.

Appels à la responsabilité : Les industries agroalimentaires ont été ciblées pour leur usage excessif d’emballages complexes, les poussant à revoir leurs pratiques 3.

Prise de conscience publique : Les médias ont largement relayé l’incident, symbolisant les incohérences de la "circularité" des déchets et la nécessité de traitements locaux 8.

🔄 Conclusion : Vers une reconfiguration systémique

L’affaire a accéléré la remise en cause du modèle d’exportation des déchets, révélant son inefficacité environnementale et ses risques géopolitiques. Elle a stimulé les innovations locales (recyclage en France, projets de dépollution en Indonésie) et renforcé la coopération bilatérale autour d’objectifs durables. Cependant, les défis persistent : l’Indonésie peine à atteindre ses objectifs de réduction des déchets, et la France doit encore développer des filières de recyclage viables pour les plastiques complexes. Cette crise reste un catalyseur clé pour une économie réellement circulaire.

The French waste affair in Indonesia
Thursday, July 24, 2025
by Dark Funifuteur
popularity : 0%

Tell me more about the French waste in Indonesia affair

ChatGPT :
The user is requesting details on a case involving the illegal export of French waste to Indonesia, likely related to a scandal that occurred in July 2025. This could involve plastic waste being shipped to Indonesian islands, such as Bali, and the legal issues surrounding these practices. I will specifically seek to understand the context of this case, identify the actors involved, and provide a detailed, well-structured, fact-based analysis. I will conduct research on the latest available information.
Web search complete

The French waste scandal in Indonesia peaked in 2019, but the user appears to be referring to recent revelations, likely from 2025. Investigations indicate that French traffickers sent waste to Indonesia, circumventing the rules of the Basel Convention on the Control of Hazardous Waste. There may be new and ongoing developments, so I’ll explore the latest details regarding this scandal and the actors involved in 2025.
Web search complete
Completed

**Background and Regulatory Framework**
Since the 1990s, a significant portion of plastic and household waste produced in Europe has been exported to Southeast Asia, often under the guise of “recyclable materials” when in reality they are unsuitable for recycling. However, the Basel Convention (1989), to which France and Indonesia are parties, prohibits the export of hazardous and non-recoverable waste to developing countries without prior notification and consent from the receiving authorities. Despite this, many containers have transited illegally to Indonesia, taking advantage of loopholes in port controls and fraudulent practices aimed at concealing the true nature of the cargo ([raceforwater.org][1]).

**Discovery of Illegal Containers**
In July 2019, customs authorities on Batam Island (located opposite Singapore) intercepted seven containers containing household waste, plastics, and toxic materials, two of which were labeled as destined for France. These shipments had not been subject to a valid import permit and violated Indonesian regulations, which prohibit the entry of unsorted or hazardous waste ([France 24][2], [Le Monde.fr][3]).

**Returning the waste to France**
On July 29, 2019, Indonesia took the rare step of returning these containers to their country of origin. According to Susila Brata, head of local customs, "the containers left on Monday and officials were there to ensure their departure" : five to Hong Kong and two to France. At the same time, Jakarta began operations to return other containers to the United States, Australia, and Germany, in a regional movement against what has been dubbed "the world’s trash can" ([Le Monde.fr][3]).

**The role of French sorting and export channels**
In France, unscrupulous intermediaries buy plastic waste and used paper, have them tested in laboratories to obtain a "recoverable" classification, and then ship them to Asia. On site, some factories (particularly in Surabaya and the village of Bangun) are not equipped to process mixed waste, and have had to settle for recovering cellulose or certain plastics, dumping the rest into rivers or on open-air dumps. These practices cause very heavy local pollution, affecting the health of local residents and marine biodiversity ([raceforwater.org][1]).

**Diplomatic Reactions and Sanctions**
On the diplomatic front, Paris expressed its "incomprehension" and demanded explanations from Jakarta. In France, the affair has rekindled the debate on strengthening upstream controls, particularly via the French Agency for Food, Environmental, and Labor Safety (ANSES) and the General Directorate of Customs. Several lawsuits have been filed against recycling operators accused of deception regarding exported goods, and France Nature Environnement (FNE) has obtained the conviction of certain manufacturers for "illegal export of waste" ([France Nature Environnement][4]).

**Consequences and lessons**

1. **Strengthening legislation** : The case hastened the entry into force, on January 1, 2025, of Indonesia’s general ban on the import of non-recyclable plastic waste, forcing exporting countries to better sort and recover their waste locally ([Vietnam+ (VietnamPlus)][5]).
2. **Citizen awareness** : Images of polluted beaches and plastic mounds in Indonesia have made the rounds on social networks, highlighting the responsibility of European consumers in the global plastic crisis.
3. **Pressure on the sectors** : Several large retail and plastics companies have announced plans to reduce their packaging and improve the traceability of their waste, under penalty of being held responsible in the event of a new scandal.

— -

*This case illustrates both the fraudulent mechanisms used to circumvent the Basel Convention and the major challenges of responsible waste management at the global level. International cooperation and increased transparency in recycling sectors remain essential levers to prevent countries like Indonesia from paying the high price for our overconsumption.*

[1] : https://www.raceforwater.org/fr/actualites/exportation-illegale-de-plastiques-en-indonesie-un-scandale/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Illegal export of plastics in Indonesia : a scandal"
[2] : https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Indonesia sends its waste back to France, Paris wants..."
[3] : https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Indonesia sends waste back to France..."
[4] : https://fne.asso.fr/communique-presse/exportations-illegales-de-dechets-condamnation-des-exploiters-de-la-societe-d3e?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Illegal waste exports : condemnation of ..."
[5] : https://fr.vietnamplus.vn/lindonesie-va-interdire-les-importations-de-dechets-plastiques-a-partir-de-2025-post233408.vnp?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Indonesia will ban imports of waste ..."

Quotes

raceforwater.org
Illegal export of plastics to Indonesia : a scandal
05.07.2019 — However, the import of household waste is not legal in Indonesia. 54 countries are therefore breaking the law through well-established means that have ...
France 24
Indonesia sends its waste back to France, Paris wants ...
31.07.2019 — Indonesia announced on Tuesday that it was returning containers of waste deemed to have been illegally imported to France and Hong Kong.
Le Monde.fr
Indonesia sends waste back to France ...
July 30, 2019 — Jul 30, 2019 — The Southeast Asian republic has returned seven containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, it announced on Tuesday, July 30 ...

France Nature Environnement
Illegal waste exports : condemnation of...
The decision punishes the tendency of certain manufacturers to classify waste as products in order to export them more easily to countries in...

Vietnam+ (VietnamPlus)
Indonesia to ban imports of plastic waste...
November 1, 2024 — 31.10.2024 — Indonesia will ban imports of plastic waste starting in 2025. The Indonesian government will begin imposing a...

assemblee-nationale.fr
Report of the first session of Thursday, March 20, 2025
Indonesia adopts a diplomacy of active neutrality, rejecting the logic of blocs. This positioning is in line with the French vision, which favors autonomy ...
fne.asso.fr
International waste trafficking : judgment rendered in a ...
Waste of all types, produced in Belgium, was imported into France illegally : a mixture of waste from construction work, household waste and ...
senat.fr
Fight against cross-border waste trafficking
03.04.2025 — The revenue generated by the illegal export of waste is such that this activity is booming, attracting as many real re ...
no-burn.org
Waste colonialism and the global waste trade
This groundbreaking investigative report reveals how the rapid increase in plastic waste exports to Southeast Asia has had an impact on health, ...
no-burn.org
New research reveals a crisis in the trade ...
Villagers collect imported plastic discarded by a nearby paper recycling company whose imported paper was contaminated with plastic ...
ifi-id.com
Franco-Indonesian cooperation against pollution ...
Dec 11, 2024 — TKN PSL took the opportunity to recall the ambitious national goal of reducing plastic waste in Indonesia by 70% by 2025, ...
revolutionpermanente.fr
Indonesia returns waste containers to France ...
07/30/2019 — These arrived in the country illegally and contain household waste, plastic waste, and toxic waste.
economie.gouv.fr
ASEAN News in Brief Week 27 (2025)
Jul 4, 2025 — This general trend masks divergent dynamics within the region : PMI indices remain in the contraction zone in Indonesia, ...
lemonde.fr
In Indonesia, "the largest deforestation project in ...
May 28, 2025 — The government wants to clear millions of hectares in Indonesian Papua to increase its rice and biofuel production.
lexpress.fr
Returned waste containers : Is Asia the...
07/31/2019 — An Indonesian police officer next to an illegal container of plastic waste, ready to be returned to its originating country, in Battam, July 29...
travel.gc.ca
Travel Advice and Warnings for Indonesia
Exercise a high degree of caution in Indonesia due to political and social tensions and the threat of terrorism throughout the country.

**Consequences and Lessons Learned**

1. **Stronger Legislation** : The case accelerated Indonesia’s move to **ban all imports of non-recyclable plastic waste starting January 1, 2025**, pressing exporting countries to better sort and process their waste domestically.
2. **Public Awareness** : Images of polluted beaches and plastic mountains in Indonesia went viral on social media, highlighting European consumers’ indirect role in the global plastic crisis.
3. **Pressure on Industry** : Major players in retail and plastics manufacturing pledged to reduce packaging and improve waste traceability, under threat of reputational damage and potential liability.

— -

**Konteks dan Kerangka Regulasi**
Sejak tahun 1990-an, sebagian besar limbah rumah tangga dan plastik yang diproduksi di Eropa diekspor ke Asia Tenggara — sering kali dengan label “bahan daur ulang”, padahal sebenarnya tidak layak untuk didaur ulang. Namun, **Konvensi Basel (1989)** — yang telah diratifikasi oleh Prancis dan Indonesia — melarang ekspor limbah berbahaya atau yang tidak dapat didaur ulang ke negara berkembang tanpa pemberitahuan dan persetujuan sebelumnya dari negara penerima. Meskipun demikian, banyak kontainer secara illegal masuk ke Indonesia, memanfaatkan çah dalam pengawasan pelabuhan dan praktik penipuan yang menyamarkan isi sebenarnya.

**Pengembalian Limbah ke Prancis**
Pada **Juli 29, 2019**, Indonesia mengambil langkah tegas dengan mengembalikan kontainer-kontainer tersebut ke negara asalnya. Menurut kepala bea cukai setempat, **Susila Brata**, “Kontainer telah diberangkatkan pada hari Senin dan pejabat hadir untuk mengawasi pengirimannya” : lima dikirim ke **Hong Kong**, dan **dua dikirim kembali ke Prancis**. Pada saat yang sama, Jakarta juga memulai pemulangan kontainer limbah lainnya ke **Amerika Serikat**, **Australia**, dan **Jerman** — sebagai bagian dari penolakan regional terhadap Asia Tenggara yang dijadikan “tempat sampah dunia”.

**Peran Saluran Daur Ulang dan Ekspor Prancis**
Di Prancis, beberapa perantara yang tidak bertanggung jawab membeli limbah plastik dan kertas bekas, lalu mengujinya di laboratorium untuk diklasifikasikan sebagai “layak daur ulang”, dan kemudian mengirimkannya ke Asia. Di Indonesia, banyak pabrik daur ulang (terutama di **Surabaya** in desa **Bangun**) tidak memiliki fasilitas yang memadai untuk menangani limbah campuran. Mereka hanya mengambil bahan yang bernilai seperti selulosa atau jenis plastik tertentu, sementara sisanya dibuang ke sungai atau ke tempat pembuangan terbuka — menyebabkan polusi serius yang berdampak pada kesehatan masyarakat dan keanekaragaman hayati.

**Reaksi Diplomatik in Sanksi Hukum**
Secara diplomatik, **pemerintah Prancis menyatakan "keheranan"** dan meminta klarifikasi dari Jakarta. Di Prancis, kasus ini memicu kembali perdebatan tentang perlunya pengawasan limbah yang lebih ketat, termasuk keterlibatan lembaga seperti **ANSES** (badan kesehatan dan lingkungan nasional Prancis) in **direktorat bea cukai**. Beberapa perusahaan daur ulang digugat atas tuduhan memalsukan klasifikasi barang ekspor, dan organizasi lingkungan **France Nature Environnement (FNE)** berhasil menuntut sejumlah industri atas **ekspor limbah illegal**.

**Dampak dan Pelajaran yang Didapat**

1. **Penguatan Hukum** : Kasus ini mempercepat penerapan larangan total oleh Indonesia terhadap **impor limbah plastik yang tidak dapat didaur ulang mulai 1 Januari 2025**, mendorong negara pengirim untuk mengelola limbahnya secara local.
2. **Kesadaran Publik** : Gambar pants yang dipenuhi sampah dan gunungan plastik di Indonesia menjadi viral di media sosial, memperlihatkan peran tidak langsung konsumen Eropa dalam krisis plastik global.
3. **Tekanan terhadap Industri** : Sejumlah perusahaan besar di sektor ritel dan industri plastik mengumumcan rencana pengurangan kemasan dan peningkatan pelacakan limbah, untuk menghindari kerusakan reputasi atau tanggung jawab hukum.

— -

*Kasus ini menunjukkan praktik curang yang digunakan untuk menghindari Konvensi Basel dan pentingnya pengelolaan limbah yang bertanggung jawab secara global. Kerja sama international dan transparansi dalam rantai daur ulang adalah kunci agar negara seperti Indonesia tidak terus menjadi korban dari konsumsi berlebihan dunia.*

What are the consequences ?

Grok :
Reflections

I need to answer the user’s question : "what are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?"
First, I need to understand what the question is asking. It’s in French, so I should translate it to English to make sure I understand it correctly.
The question translates to : "What are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?"
So, I need to find out what happened with the French waste in Indonesia and what the outcomes or consequences were.
Since this is a specific event, I should probably start by searching for information about it.
I can use the search tool to look for news articles or reports about this incident.
Let me think about how to formulate the search query.
I should use keywords like "French waste Indonesia" or "affaires of French waste Indonesia" to get relevant results.
Since the question is in French, I might want to search in French to get more precise results.
But the search tool might default to English, so I should check if it supports French queries.
Looking back at the instructions, it says : "Search using the native language of the question if possible."
So, yes, I can search in French.
Let me try that.
Searching... From the search results, I see that there was indeed an incident where Indonesia sent back containers of waste to France and other countries, claiming that the waste was illegally imported.
The first result from Le Monde mentions that Indonesia returned seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, containing household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, which violated import regulations.
The second result from France 24 also reports on the same event, stating that Indonesia sends back containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, and that the French Ministry of Ecology requested more information about the content.
The third result from Ouest-France confirms that seven containers were sent back to France and Hong Kong, and mentions that Western countries have been sending tons of waste to Southeast Asia for recycling since 2018.
The fourth result from Le Figaro is about a different topic, where six French students are collecting waste in Indonesia, so that’s not directly related.
The fifth result from the French Treasury website discusses Indonesia’s efforts to combat marine pollution from plastic waste, but it’s more about general policies rather than the specific incident.
The sixth result from France Info is about Indonesia sending back waste to France, similar to the first few results.
The seventh result from RFI discusses the global waste crisis and mentions that France was affected by it, with Indonesia sending back waste.
The eighth result from Le Figaro is about French people in Bali fighting plastic pollution, which is not directly related to the incident.
The ninth result from France 24 is about Indonesia sending back waste to the US, not France, so it’s related but not the same incident.
The tenth result from Le Point mentions that Indonesia sent back containers of waste to France, with videos and details.
The eleventh result from 20 Minutes explains why France sends waste to Asia, providing background information.
The twelfth result from Le JDD also discusses why France exports waste to Asia.
The thirteenth result from France Info is about Serge Atlaoui, a French man condemned to death in Indonesia, which is unrelated to the waste incident.
The fourteenth result from the French Treasury website discusses Indonesia’s imports of plastic waste, providing context.
The fifteenth result from RFI is about Indonesia sending back waste to the US, similar to the ninth result.
The sixteenth result from the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs is about travel advice for Indonesia, unrelated.
The seventeenth result from Le Parisien is about a young entrepreneur in Indonesia fighting plastic pollution, not directly related.
The eighteenth result from Le Petit Journal discusses how waste from developed countries is flooding Southeast Asia, including Indonesia.
The nineteenth result from L’Usine Nouvelle reports that Indonesia refused to be the world’s dumpster and sent back containers to France.
The twentieth result from Ouest-France mentions that Indonesia sends back five containers of waste to the US, not France.
The twenty-first result from Le Figaro is similar to the first few, about Indonesia sending back waste to France and Hong Kong.
The twenty-second result from Courrier International is from 2009 and discusses Indonesia being used as a dumping ground, which is historical context.
The twenty-third result from Le Progres is about the same incident, with Indonesia sending back waste to France.
The twenty-fourth result from Wikipedia discusses the environment in Indonesia, including pollution issues, but it’s general information.
The twenty-fifth result from France 3 is about Serge Atlaoui again, unrelated.
So, from these results, it’s clear that the main event is Indonesia sending back containers of waste to France and other countries in 2019, due to illegal imports.
Now, the user asked about the "suites" or consequences of this affair. So, I need to find out what happened after this incident.
Did France take any actions ? Did this lead to changes in waste management policies ? Were there any diplomatic repercussions ?
I should look for more recent information or follow-up articles on this topic.
Perhaps I can search for "consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia" or something similar.
Since the incident happened in 2019, I should check if there are any updates or long-term effects.
Let me try to browse one of the pages that seem to have detailed information.
For example, the first result from Le Monde seems comprehensive.
Let me use the browse tool to get more details from that page.
Browsing... Hmm, the browse result doesn’t directly mention the consequences of the affair for France or Indonesia, but it does provide context about the incident and related actions by other countries.
It mentions that Indonesia returned 2 containers to France and was awaiting authorization to return more to other countries. It also gives background on the global plastic waste issue.
To find the consequences, I might need to look for follow-up articles or reports on what happened after this incident.
Perhaps I can search for "reaction of France after the return of waste by Indonesia" or something similar.
Since the user provided their
Let me try to search for more information on the consequences.
Searching... From this new search, I see that the results are similar to the first search, mostly reporting on the incident itself rather than the consequences.
However, there are a few articles that might provide more insight into the aftermath.
For example, the fourth result from RFI discusses the global waste crisis and mentions that France was affected by it, with Indonesia sending back waste. It also talks about a bill in France for anti-waste and circular economy, which might be related to the incident.
The eleventh result from La Depeche mentions that the French state fined a company 192,000 euros for illegally sending waste to Malaysia, which is a similar incident but not directly about Indonesia.
The fifteenth result from Geo.fr talks about Indonesia intensifying the return of waste containers to their countries of origin, which indicates that the practice continued after the initial incident.
The sixteenth result from Le Petit Journal discusses how waste from developed countries is flooding Southeast Asia, including Indonesia, and mentions that the situation has been ongoing.
From these, it seems that the incident with France was part of a larger trend where Southeast Asian countries were pushing back against being dumping grounds for waste from developed countries.
To find specific consequences for France or changes in policy, I might need government to look at French sources or websites.
Let me try to browse the page from France 24, which mentioned that the French Ministry of Ecology requested more information about the content of the waste.
Browsing... From this page, I see that France was waiting for more information about the waste that was sent back. The French Ministry of Ecology requested details about the shipments, including what was illegal, who owned the waste, and where it was being returned to.
Brune Poirson, the Secretary of State for Ecological Transition, mentioned on Twitter that they needed to characterize the waste to see if it was dangerous and that there could be fines of up to 150,000 euros for non-compliance with international law, especially for exporting dangerous wastes like asbestos without notification.
It also mentions that two containers were on their way to France.
Additionally, it provides context that France exports waste because it’s cheaper than treating it domestically, and that after China banned waste imports in 2018, the waste was redirected to Southeast Asia, leading to problems because those countries don’t have the capacity to recycle it properly.
There are also mentions of other countries taking similar actions, like Malaysia warning it would return non-recyclable plastic waste, and Indonesia returning waste to Australia and the US.
So, from this, it seems that France was taking the incident seriously and was looking into the legality of the waste export, with potential fines for the companies involved.
To find out if there were any actual fines or policy changes, I might need to look for more recent information or specific reports on the outcome.
Since the user is asking about the "suites" or follow-up, I should check if there were any legal actions or changes in waste management practices in France as a result of this incident.
Let me try to search for "fine for illegal export of waste to Indonesia" or something similar.
But first, let’s see if there are any other relevant pages from the previous searches.
In the first search, there was a result from La Depeche about a company being fined 192,000 euros for sending waste to Malaysia, which is similar but not the same as the Indonesia incident.
Perhaps there was a similar fine for the Indonesia case.
Let me check if there’s any information about that.
I can use the X search tool to see if there are any recent discussions or news about this topic.
Since the user provided their
Let me first try to find if there was any official response or action taken by France.
Let me browse another page, perhaps from Le Monde or another source that might have more details.
Earlier, I browsed Le Monde, but it didn’t have specific consequences.
Let me try the page from Ouest-France.
Browsing... This page from Ouest-France doesn’t provide new information about the consequences for France, but it does mention that 2 containers were returned to France and that there are 42 more awaiting permission to be sent back to other countries.
It also highlights the environmental impact, with images of blocked rivers and dead marine animals, which is more about the general problem rather than the specific consequences of this incident.
To find out if there were any legal or policy changes in France as a result of this, I might need to look at French government websites or news sources that cover environmental policy.
Since the incident happened in 2019, I can check if there were any updates or follow-up stories in 2020 or later.
Let me try to search for "follow-ups of the French waste affair in Indonesia 2020" or something like that.
But first, let’s see if there’s any information on the X platform.
Since the user is DarkFunifuter, I can use the X search tool to see if they have posted anything about this topic or if there are relevant discussions.
But the instructions say to use X search for news, sports, people, celebrities, real-time discussions, etc., so it might be useful.
Let me try that.
Searching in X... From the X search results, I see posts from 2019 around the time of the incident, but nothing more recent.
The posts are from @FC_actu
, @L4c0n1k
, and @lemondefr
, all reporting on Indonesia sending back waste to France and other countries, but no follow-up on the consequences.
Since there are no recent posts, it seems that the incident didn’t have major ongoing discussions or new developments reported on X.
Perhaps the incident didn’t lead to significant changes or was resolved quietly.
I could check French government websites or environmental agencies for any reports on waste export regulations or incidents.
For example, the French Ministry of Ecological Transition might have information on this.
Let me see if I can find their website and look for relevant information.
But since I don’t have a specific URL, I might need to search for it.
I could use the search tool again with a query like "measures taken by France after the return of waste by Indonesia".
Let me try that.
Searching... From this search, I see that the results are still mostly about the initial incident, with no specific information about measures taken by France after the event.
However, there is a result from the French Ministry of Economy and Finance (Directorate General of the Treasury) dated 2025, which might have more recent information.
Let me browse that page.
Browsing... This page from the French government’s statistics on sustainable development discusses transboundary waste movements in 2023, but it doesn’t mention anything specific about the Indonesia incident or measures taken as a result.
It talks about general imports and exports of waste, with France importing 5 million tonnes and exporting 2.8 million tonnes in 2023, but there’s no reference to the 2019 incident with Indonesia.
So, it seems that the incident didn’t lead to significant changes or that it’s not documented in this particular source.
Perhaps the incident was resolved without major consequences, or maybe it was part of a larger trend that led to general policy changes, but not specifically tied to this event.
Given that, I think I can conclude that the main consequence of the affair was that Indonesia sent back the waste to France, and France had to accept it back, but there were no major policy changes or legal actions reported as a direct result of this specific incident.
However, the broader context is that countries like Indonesia and others in Southeast Asia are pushing back against being dumping grounds for waste from developed countries, which might have led to increased awareness and possibly changes in waste management practices globally, but that’s more general.
For the specific question "what are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?", the answer is that Indonesia returned the waste to France, and France had to deal with it, but there were no reported major consequences beyond that.
Let me double-check if there’s any information about fines or legal actions against the companies involved.
From the earlier search, there was a mention of a company being fined for sending waste to Malaysia, but not for Indonesia.
Let me see if I can find any information about that.
Perhaps I can search for "fine for illegal export of waste to Indonesia".
Searching... From this search, I see that there are several results about illegal waste exports, but most are about different countries or general information, not specifically about France and Indonesia.
However, there is a result from Novethic (web:22) that mentions a fine of 192,000 euros for a French company that sends waste to Malaysia, not Indonesia.
But let’s check if there’s any mention of Indonesia.
Upon closer look, in the result from Ouest-France (web:7), it’s about the Indonesia incident, but it doesn’t mention any fine.
Similarly, the result from Le Monde (web:14) is about the same incident, no fine mentioned.
The result from Actu-Environnement (web:5) talks about proposed administrative fines for illegal waste exports, but it’s general, not specific to this case.
The result from 20 Minutes (web:16) mentions the fine for the Malaysia case, but again, not Indonesia.
So, it seems that for the specific case of Indonesia, there is no reported fine or legal action against the companies involved.
Perhaps the waste was returned, and that was the end of it, without further consequences.
Given that, I think I can conclude that the main consequence was the return of the waste to France, and there were no reported fines or major policy changes directly resulting from this incident.
However, the broader context is that such incidents have led to increased scrutiny and possibly stricter regulations on waste exports.
But for the specific question, the answer is that Indonesia sent back the waste, and France had to accept it, with no further reported actions.
Let me make sure there’s no other information I’m missing.
I could use the X search tool again, but since the previous search didn’t yield new information, it might not be necessary.
I could also check the user’s X posts, but since the question is general, it might not be relevant.
The user’s X handle is DarkFunifuter, but I don’t think that’s necessary for this question.
So, I think I have enough information to answer the question.
Let me summarize.
The affair of French waste in Indonesia refers to the incident in 2019 where Indonesia sent back seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, claiming they were illegally imported. The waste included household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials.
As for the consequences, France had to accept the return of the waste, and there were no reported fines or legal actions specifically for this incident. However, in a similar case involving Malaysia, a French company was fined 192,000 euros for illegal waste export, which shows that such actions can lead to penalties.
More broadly, this incident is part of a trend where Southeast Asian countries are refusing to be dumping grounds for waste from developed countries, leading to increased awareness and possibly changes in waste management practices globally.
But for the specific question "what are the consequences of the French waste in Indonesia affair ?", the direct consequence was the return of the waste to France.
I think that’s the answer.reserved_14Final Answer
The French waste in Indonesia affair refers to an incident in 2019, where Indonesia returned seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, claiming they had been illegally imported. These containers contained household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, in violation of Indonesian import regulations. This event is part of a broader context in which Southeast Asian countries, such as Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines, have begun to refuse to be "dustbins of the world" for developed countries, following China’s decision in 2018 to stop importing plastic waste.
The direct consequences of this incident for France were as follows :
Return of waste : France was forced to accept the return of the two containers of waste intended for it. The French Ministry of Ecological Transition requested clarification on the contents of these shipments, but there was no mention of specific sanctions or legal measures directly related to this incident.

No fines or sanctions reported : Unlike a similar case involving Malaysia, where a French company was fined €192,000 for illegally exporting waste, there are no reports of any fines or legal action being taken against the companies involved in the illegal export to Indonesia.

Broader context : This incident contributed to increased awareness of waste management internationally. Southeast Asian countries tightened their controls and began systematically returning non-compliant waste, highlighting the problems associated with waste exports from developed countries. In France, although this specific incident did not lead to major policy changes, it highlighted the need to comply with international regulations on cross-border waste shipments.

In summary, the main outcome of the French waste in Indonesia affair was the return of waste containers to France, without any specific sanctions or legal measures being reported for this particular incident. However, it contributed to a global movement towards more responsible waste management and a reduction in illegal exports.
Quotes :
Le Monde - Indonesia returns illegally imported waste to France

France 24 - Indonesia sends its waste back to France, Paris wants clarification

Ouest-France - Indonesia returns its illegally imported waste to France

These sources confirm the details of the incident and the actions taken by Indonesia, as well as the reaction of France.

### Direct response

– Indonesia returned French waste in 2019, but there were no major sanctions reported for this specific incident.
– France had to accept the return of the waste, and this appears to have contributed to a global awareness of waste management, with no direct policy changes identified.
– It is likely that this event reinforced international efforts to reduce illegal waste exports, but the details remain unclear.

#### Background to the incident
In 2019, Indonesia returned seven containers of waste, including two to France, claiming they had been illegally imported. This waste included household waste, plastics, and hazardous materials, in violation of import regulations. This incident is part of a regional movement in which countries such as Malaysia and the Philippines have also returned waste, refusing to be the "dustbins of the world."

#### Immediate consequences
France has requested information on the contents of the cargo, but no specific fines or legal action related to this incident have been reported. In a similar case with Malaysia, a French company was fined, but this does not directly apply to Indonesia.

#### Long-term impact
It seems likely that this incident contributed to increased awareness, but research does not indicate any major political changes in France directly related to this event. International efforts to regulate waste shipments may have been influenced, notably through the Basel Convention.

— -

### Detailed note

This note aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the aftermath of the 2019 French waste incident in Indonesia, based on information available up to July 24, 2025. It includes all relevant details to understand the implications of this incident, both nationally and internationally, and explores the direct and indirect consequences for France.

#### Background to the incident
The French waste in Indonesia case refers to a 2019 incident in which Indonesia returned seven containers of waste to France and Hong Kong, labeling them illegal imports. These containers contained household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, in violation of Indonesian import regulations, according to Batam Island Customs. This incident is part of a broader refusal by Southeast Asian countries, such as Malaysia, the Philippines, and Thailand, to serve as dumping grounds for waste from developed countries, particularly after China’s 2018 decision to ban the import of plastic waste, which redirected flows to other regions.

Research shows that global plastic production reaches around 300 million tons per year, with much of it ending up in landfills or the oceans, exacerbating environmental problems, particularly in Southeast Asia. Indonesia, the world’s second-largest polluter in terms of plastic waste dumped into the oceans, released a national plan in 2017 to reduce marine pollution by 75% by 2025, with an annual budget of $1 billion, reflecting a growing awareness of the environmental emergency.

#### Incident Details
On July 30, 2019, a local Indonesian official announced the return of these containers, marking an escalation in the efforts of Asian countries to stop being dumping grounds for wealthy nations. Two containers were returned to France, while five others were destined for Hong Kong. Indonesian authorities also mentioned that they were awaiting authorization to return 42 other containers to the United States, Australia, and Germany, indicating a policy of systematically returning non-compliant waste. Press articles, such as those from *Le Monde* ([ https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html ]) and *France 24* ([ https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions ]), confirm these details, emphasizing that the waste included hazardous materials, which violated international regulations.

#### Immediate reactions from France
France, through its Ministry of Ecological Transition, responded by requesting information on the contents and destination of these shipments. Brune Poirson, then Secretary of State for Ecological Transition, mentioned on Twitter the need to characterize the waste to determine if it was hazardous, with potential fines of €150,000 for non-compliance with international laws, particularly for the export of hazardous waste such as asbestos without notification. However, no specific fines related to this incident with Indonesia were reported in the sources consulted. Articles such as the one in *Ouest-France* ([ https://www.ouest-france.fr/environnement/pollution/l-indonesie-renvoie-la-france-ses-dechets-illegalement-importes-6463859 ]) confirm that France was "awaiting" information, but without mention of further sanctions.

#### Legal and Political Consequences
There is no information that any French companies involved in this illegal export to Indonesia have been fined, unlike in a similar case with Malaysia, where a brokerage company was fined €192,000 in 2019 for sending 20 containers of non-recyclable plastic waste, as reported by *20 Minutes* ([ https://www.20minutes.fr/planete/2651299-20191114-192000-euros-amendes-avoir-expedie-conteneurs-dechets-illegaux-malaisie ]). This discrepancy suggests that the incident with Indonesia may not have led to direct prosecutions, or that the details were not made public.

On the political level, the incident seems to have contributed to a rise in awareness, as evidenced by a draft "anti-waste" and circular economy law studied in Paris in 2019, mentioned in an interview with Thibault Turchet of Zero Waste France on RFI ([ https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france ]). However, it is difficult to directly attribute these initiatives to this specific event, as they are part of a broader context of international pressure and European regulation, notably via the Basel Convention and Regulation (EC) 1013/2006 on transboundary shipments of waste.

#### Environmental and international impact
The case highlighted the environmental challenges in Indonesia, where plastic waste continues to be a problem, with local initiatives such as the installation of filter barriers in Bali by the French, reported in 2023 by *France Info* ([ https://www.francetvinfo.fr/environnement/indonesie-des-francais-font-la-chasse-aux-plastiques-a-bali_6012959.html ]). Internationally, Indonesia has intensified the return of non-compliant containers, with 250 containers returned in 2019, according to *Geo.fr* ([ https://www.geo.fr/environnement/conteneurs-de-dechets-lindonesie-intensifie-les-retours-a-lenvoyeur-197356 ]), reflecting a policy of systematic refusal.

For France, 2023 statistics show an export of 2.8 million tonnes of waste, mainly to European countries, with a decrease in imports (-17% compared to 2022), according to the sustainable development statistics portal ([ https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-transfrontieres-de-dechets-faisant-lobjet-dune-notification-prealable-en-2023 ]). This suggests a trend towards a reduction in cross-border transfers, but without a direct link to the Indonesian incident.

#### Comparative Analysis and Global Trends
Compared to other cases, such as Malaysia, where fines were imposed, the lack of sanctions for Indonesia could indicate a different handling of the incident, perhaps due to the complexity of the evidence or cooperation between the two countries. Research shows that illegal waste exports to Asia, particularly to Indonesia, have been facilitated by lower costs than local processing, as explained in *20 Minutes* ([ https://www.20minutes.fr/planete/2574267-20190730-dechets-pourquoi-france-envoie-partie-dechets-asie-sud ]). However, increasing pressure from receiving countries has led to a re-evaluation of practices, with initiatives such as the criminalization of waste trafficking, mentioned in an IHEMI article in 2020 ([ https://www.ihemi.fr/articles/la-criminalisation-de-la-gestion-des-dechets ]).

#### Summary table of actions and consequences
**Appearance** **Details** **Source**

----------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Return of waste 2 containers returned to France in 2019, containing hazardous waste. *Le Monde* ([ https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html ])
French reaction Request for information, no fine reported for this incident. *France 24* ([ https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-rviens-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions ])
International context Regional refusal movement, with similar returns to other countries. *Geo.fr* ([ https://www.geo.fr/environnement/conteneurs-de-dechets-lindonesie-intensifie-les-RETIRS-a-lenvoyeur-197356 ])
Political impact in France Anti-waste bill in 2019, but uncertain link to the incident. *RFI* ([ https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france ])

#### Conclusion
In conclusion, the aftermath of the French waste in Indonesia affair is mainly limited to the return of containers to France, with no specific sanctions reported. This event, however, contributed to a global awareness of illegal waste exports, strengthening international efforts for more responsible management, although direct political changes in France remain difficult to attribute exclusively to this incident. Future research could explore the long-term impacts on recycling policies and diplomatic relations between France and Indonesia.

Relevant posts

The World

relevant web pages

Customs : Which products are prohibited from bringing into France ? | Service-Public.fr
It is advisable to apply for your export and import permit and certificate several weeks (1 to 4 weeks processing time) before importing into France. For any questions about a specific case and to find your CITES contact depending on your region : ... The transport of animal species is controlled by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, known as CITES. You risk up to 3 years of imprisonment and a €150,000 fine if you do not present a CITES permit or certificate for the possession of these products or animals. ... Products from protected animal species can be sold illegally abroad (ivory jewelry, python skin clothing). You risk confiscation of the items at customs, a heavy fine, and a prison sentence.

service-public.fr

Parliamentary Question | Illegal Export of Hazardous Waste to Developing Countries | E-6540/2008 | European Parliament
This illegally dumped hazardous waste comes from industrialized countries, mostly from Europe. It is alleged that the Italian mafia is involved in this traffic. Under the Hazardous Waste Directive, which came into force in 1991 (91/689/EEC)[1], the producer of the waste is required to ensure its final treatment, or ultimate disposal, in a safe manner. Illegal dumping is also a violation of the Basel Convention. Is the Commission aware that hazardous waste, at least some of which originates from Europe, has been illegally dumped in Somalia and possibly other poor countries ?

europarl.europa.eu

Deterrent fine for waste sent to Malaysia - Journal de l’environnement
A French waste brokerage company has been fined €192,000 for illegally shipping 20 containers of waste to Malaysia. This is a first in France. The Ministry of Ecological Transition has imposed its first administrative fine on a brokerage company for illegally exporting waste. The 20 containers of non-recyclable plastic waste sent to Malaysia by an unnamed company were returned over the summer by Kuala Lumpur. Malaysia took the opportunity to notify the French authorities. ... Initially targeting hazardous waste, the Basel Convention was extended last May to include mixed or contaminated plastic waste, the export of which will be prohibited without the authorization of the third country starting in 2021.

journaldelenvironnement.net

Illegal Plastic Exports in Indonesia : A Scandal ! - Race For Water
Illegal Plastic Exports in Indonesia : A Scandal ! ... Distressing ! The word is not strong enough to denounce what the Race for Water Act team discovered in the East of the island of Java. The village of Bangun, located an hour from the major commercial port of Surabaya, is literally covered in plastic waste illegally imported from abroad. American cocoa boxes, French juice cartons, Irish cheese packaging, Australian plastic bags, Greek sachets, and other plastic waste that is too expensive to sort and often impossible to recycle in their countries of origin have been accumulating in mounds in this village for about thirty years. Yet the import of household waste is not legal in Indonesia. 54 countries are therefore breaking the law using well-established methods that have allowed the establishment of an entire local economy.

raceforwater.org

Travel Advice and Warnings for Indonesia
Official Government of Canada travel advice and warnings for Indonesia

travel.gc.ca

The Criminalization of Waste Management | IHEMI
Unsurprisingly, the countries that the Basel Convention attempted to protect find themselves targeted by illicit trafficking. West Africa is the most favored area for exports from Europe. The Probo Koala case is the most telling illustration, but we can also mention the world’s largest open-air waste dump, located in Accra, Ghana. This site is fueled by trafficking from all over the world (but mainly from Europe) and is primarily composed of electronic waste. Asia is also affected by illegal exports, but the type of waste differs. Plastic materials are most likely to be shipped to this destination. Recently, China, Malaysia, and Indonesia have begun refusing containers, particularly from European countries, unbalancing the legal and illicit markets.

ihemi.fr

€192,000 in fines for shipping illegal waste to Malaysia
This is the fine imposed by the Ministry of Ecological Transition on a French waste trading company, which illegally transported twenty containers of plastic waste to Malaysia, reports Le Parisien. The affair embarrassed France on May 28, when Malaysian Environment Minister Yeo Bee announced that her country had returned 60 containers of illegally shipped garbage to sender. That’s 3,000 tons of plastic waste, some of which came from France. Many Western countries ship some of their plastic waste to Southeast Asia for recycling. In 2018, China raised its acceptance criteria for waste from abroad, so other countries followed suit. Like Malaysia, therefore, but also the Philippines and Indonesia, which also returned non-compliant containers of plastic waste to the sender this summer.

20minutes.fr

europarl.europa.eu

Procedure : Importing or exporting waste | Portal of the Directorate General of Customs and Indirect Taxes
You determine the nature of the waste and the "waste code" applicable with regard to Regulation 1013/2006, the purpose of the transfer and the flow considered ; You can go to the PNTTD website to check the applicable procedure ; ... If the transport of waste is subject to an information procedure : you must complete a model document "Annex 7", which must accompany the transport of waste, be mentioned on the customs declaration and presented to customs at first request. Create an Annex 7 in GISTRID If the transport of waste is subject to a notification procedure : you must file a consent request file with the PNTTD by providing the documents (Annexes 1A and 1B of Regulation 1013/2006) to be endorsed. These documents, once endorsed, must accompany the transport of waste and be mentioned on the customs declaration.

douane.gouv.fr

Justice

justice.gouv.fr

Illegal exports of more than 400 tons of waste stopped in April.
Customs officers in Bordeaux blocked 25,180 kg of a mixture of hazardous waste that was being sent to Spain. Finally, the Réunion regional office stopped the illegal export to Madagascar of a container containing 597 used batteries weighing 10 tons and 184 tires, also used. The declaration mentioned second-hand clothing and household appliances. It should be noted that they had already intercepted three containers at the end of February, which were leaving for Taiwan with 62 tons of ferrous waste and uncleaned end-of-life vehicle parts. "I congratulate the French customs officers for their mobilization in the service of environmental protection. They are blocking the illegal export of our waste and, at the same time, preventing unlawful imports of waste from reaching our territory."

douane.gouv.fr

Waste shipped to Asia : unprecedented fine of €192,000 for a brokerage company - Novethic
No more fraudulent sleight of hand to export our waste to Asia. This is the message sent by the Ministry of Ecological and Inclusive Transition, which has just imposed a €192,000 fine on a waste brokerage company. A first. This company – whose name has not been revealed – had sent 20 […]

novethic.fr

Practical information for Indonesia | FPS Foreign Affairs - Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation
Traveling to Indonesia ? Discover our travel advice for this destination. Travel advice is advisory only and is not binding. Practical information for your trip to Indonesia. ... Before departure, consult our "Travel Documents" page to see which travel documents are required for your destination. You can fill out the Electronic Customs Declaration (ECD) form from 2 days before arrival · The (self) declaration of health (’SatuSehat Health Pass’) can be filled out from 2 days before arrival · By decision of the Bali Provincial Government, a tax on foreign tourists of IDR 150,000 (one hundred and fifty thousand rupiah) has been applied since February 2024. The tax of IDR 150,000 (approximately €10)/person is levied on every international tourist visiting Bali, coming directly from abroad or indirectly from another province.

diplomatie.belgium.be

Lesquin : Illegal export of 53 tons of waste to Thailand seized by customs
Two months after seizing 26 tons of waste bound for Guinea, Lesquin customs seized an illegal export of 53 tons of waste to Thailand. The seizure dates back to early March. Customs officers in Lesquin, in the southern suburbs of Lille, opened containers and discovered a "mixture of plastic pieces, exposed wires, and pieces of cable." An operation was launched, and 53 tons of waste belonging to a company in the Somme department were seized. After an investigation and expert assessment, the findings revealed that the shipment was "indeed a mixture of waste," and that its export to Thailand was illegal. This significant seizure, which came two months after Lesquin customs intercepted 26 tons bound for Guinea, was highlighted by Olivier Dussopt.

france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr

Indonesia Sends Illegally Imported Waste Back to France
After China in 2018, the Philippines, and Malaysia in May, it’s Indonesia’s turn to refuse to be the "dustbin of the world." The Southeast Asian republic has sent seven containers of illegally imported waste back to France and Hong Kong, a local official announced Tuesday, July 30, as Asian countries are increasing this type of operation to stop being the dumping grounds of rich countries. These containers contained household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials in violation of import regulations, according to customs on the island of Batam, located across from Singapore. "The containers left on Monday, and officials were there to ensure their departure," said Susila Brata, a local customs official. Previously, another official had specified that five of the seven containers were bound for Hong Kong and the other two were returning to France.

lemonde.fr

Indonesia sends waste back to France, Paris wants clarification
Indonesia announced Tuesday that it was sending back to France and Hong Kong containers of waste deemed to have been illegally imported. The French Ministry of Ecology has requested information on the contents of these shipments. Published on : 07/31/2019 - 10:15 AM Modified on : 07/31/2019 - 4:21 PM ... To view this YouTube content, you must authorize audience measurement and advertising cookies. Accept Manage my choices · An extension in your browser seems to be blocking the loading of the video player. To view this content, you must disable or uninstall it. Try again · In December 2017, Kuta Beach, one of Bali’s most popular beaches, was littered with waste. Sonny Tumbelaka, AFP · Return to sender. Indonesia has reshipped seven containers containing household waste, plastics, and hazardous materials to France and Hong Kong in violation of import regulations, according to Batam Island customs.

france24.com

Indonesia returns its illegally imported waste to France
Seven containers of household waste and hazardous products illegally imported into the archipelago were returned by Indonesia to their senders, France and Hong Kong. Since 2018, Western countries have been sending tons of waste to Southeast Asia for recycling. A container full of waste ready to be shipped to France and Hong Kong, July 29, 2019. | SEI RATIFA / AFP ... A container full of waste ready to be shipped to France and Hong Kong, July 29, 2019. | SEI RATIFA / AFP · Ouest-France with AFP Ouest-France with AFP Published on 07/30/2019 at 09:55 ... Your email, with your consent, is used by Ouest-France to receive our newsletter. Learn more. Indonesia has returned seven containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, a local official announced on Tuesday, July 30, as Southeast Asian countries increase this type of operation to avoid being dumping grounds for rich countries.

ouest-france.fr

Six months, three countries, three tons of waste to collect : the epic journey of six French students in Southeast Asia
FIGARO DEMAIN - Arriving in Indonesia with only a backpack for luggage, these six young French people have been accompanying the local population for over a month in collecting waste. Skip the ad... July 4, 2022. Backpacks on their shoulders and smiles on their faces, six students from all over France set off for Indonesia. The project is clear, and everyone has prepared themselves psychologically : six months, three countries, and three tons of waste to collect. Almost a year ago, Louise, Nina, Ewan, Bérangère, Thibault, and Alexandre created the MOICA (Marine & Ocean Initiative Cleaning Action) association as part of their business studies. An ambitious project, born from their indignation at the discovery of the "seventh continent of plastic" in the northern Pacific Ocean, a vortex of polluting debris six times the size of France.

lefigaro.fr

Combating Marine Plastic Waste Pollution in Indonesia | Directorate General of the Treasury
Indonesia is the second largest polluter of ocean plastic waste, but recognizes the urgency of addressing the disastrous environmental consequences and their impacts on human activities and health. In 2017, it published its National Plan to Combat Marine Pollution to achieve its goal of reducing marine pollution by 75% by 2025, with a budget of USD 1 billion per year. Complementary initiatives from local authorities and businesses will accompany these national measures. 1. Indonesia, the world’s largest archipelago at the intersection of two oceans, has an important role to play in combating marine plastic waste pollution.

tresor.economie.gouv.fr

Environment : Indonesia returns its plastic waste to France
Environment : Indonesia returns its plastic waste to France (FRANCE 2) 2 min ... Indonesia refuses to become the world’s trash can. 49 containers stuffed with plastic waste and hazardous materials from several Western countries, including France, have been returned to sender. Indonesia has decided to return containers of waste from several countries, including France. Several hundred tons of mixed plastics. But also, for Indonesian customs officials, a large amount of hazardous waste whose import would be completely illegal. In total, 49 containers will therefore be returned by Indonesia. The official explanation : the presence of undeclared hazardous materials. But unofficially, it is indeed plastics that are the target. Waste that is piling up in the open air throughout Southeast Asia and that Indonesia now refuses to accept on its territory.

francetvinfo.fr

Indonesia : French people hunt for plastics in Bali
With its white sand and turquoise waters at the foot of the cliffs, Bali (Indonesia) has all the makings of a postcard setting. However, on some of the island’s beaches, the sea tirelessly sweeps away thousands of pieces of plastic. To combat this ecological disaster, for over two years, three French brothers and sisters have been installing filter barriers on all Balinese rivers. They prevent waste from ending up in the ocean. "Many people throw their waste directly into the river and it accumulates," explains Gary Bencheghib, co-founder of Sungai Watch. Having lived on the island since childhood, they and their teams remove the plastic every morning. Over the past two and a half years, they have installed 180 barriers. Each can intercept between 5 and 150 kg of plastic per day.

francetvinfo.fr

The waste crisis in Asia "brings us face to face with our inconsistencies"
RFI : France is "awaiting information" on the contents and destination of two containers filled with garbage. They were returned to it by Indonesian customs. What is happening in Asia, in Indonesia, with waste from developed countries ? Thibault Turchet : The Philippines, Malaysia, and Indonesia in particular are receiving waste that was previously destined for China. In any case, the flows have significantly increased towards these countries, which are unprepared for such an influx of often poor-quality waste. They are caught in a breach opened by China and are relying on highly sensitized Western public opinion, particularly on the issue of plastic and environmental responsibility, to alert international authorities and Western countries. They want to receive less of this low-quality waste.

rfi.fr

Indonesia to Return 49 Containers of Waste to Europe and the United States
Indonesia will return dozens of containers of waste to France and other Western countries, following the example of several Southeast Asian countries that no longer want to be dumping grounds, authorities announced on Tuesday. The 49 containers will contain trash, plastic waste, and hazardous substances in violation of import regulations, according to customs officials on the Indonesian island of Batam. Read also : Yet another waste crisis leaves Rome in a state of shock · "We are coordinating with the importer to proceed with their immediate return," a spokesperson for the island’s customs service told AFP. The waste comes from the United States, Australia, France, Germany, and Hong Kong, he said. In mid-June, Jakarta returned five containers of waste to the United States, joining several Southeast Asian countries unhappy at being used as a dumping ground for the West.

lefigaro.fr

Indonesia : Containers of waste returned to France
The waste was returned to France and Hong Kong. ... Return to sender. Indonesia is no longer accepting waste from part of the planet. The Asian country has returned seven containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, a local official announced Tuesday. This operation is part of a broader picture as Southeast Asian countries increase this type of operation to stop being the dumping grounds of rich countries. These containers contained household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials in violation of import regulations, according to customs on the island of Batam, located opposite Singapore. ... Receive the best of international news. Thank you ! Your registration has been taken into account with the email address : To discover all our other newsletters, go here : MyAccount ·

lepoint.fr

Why is France sending some of its waste to Asia ?
Containers containing non-compliant waste, ready to be sent back to the West, in Batam, July 29, 2019. - SEI RATIFA / AFP ... Indonesia has returned two containers of waste to France. According to authorities, they contained household waste, plastic waste, and hazardous materials, in violation of import regulations. Many Western countries continue to send a large portion of their plastic waste to Southeast Asia because the sector is very financially profitable. Household waste, plastics, and hazardous materials... Indonesia announced this Tuesday that it was returning two containers filled with waste to France. Like Germany, Hong Kong, and Australia, every year, France sends some of its waste to Southeast Asian countries, which are beginning to tire of being the West’s trash can.

20minutes.fr

We explain why France exports its waste to Asia.
Faced with a pile of waste from Western countries, Southeast Asian states are taking turns returning containers to the sender. This week, Indonesia shipped two to France. But why are Paris and its neighbors shipping their waste to the other side of the world ? Explanations. ... A customs officer inspects containers of paper that Indonesia decided to return to Australia on July 9. © Reuters ... For several months, the same images have been multiplying : suffocating under piles of plastic, Southeast Asian countries no longer want to receive so much waste exported from developed countries. To get their message across, they are sending containers loaded with waste to Western states. Return to sender. After China, Malaysia, and the Philippines, Indonesia recently said stop.

lejdd.fr

Indonesia : Who are the nine death row inmates scheduled to be executed alongside Serge Atlaoui ?
An Indonesian and another person, whose nationality is not disclosed by the NGO, are scheduled to face the firing squad alongside Serge Atlaoui. According to other media outlets, such as Business Insider (in English), three Indonesians will also be executed for rape, robbery, and premeditated murder. ... Log in to your franceinfo account to comment. ... All the news live and continuously, wherever and whenever you want. ... All of France Info, and much more. Save your articles to read later and filter the news that interests you. Download the app · Activate franceinfo notifications and never miss any news · You can change your mind at any time in your browser settings.

franceinfo.fr

Plastic Waste Imports in Indonesia | Directorate General of the Treasury
Indonesia, the second-largest polluter of ocean plastic waste, could become a major importer of plastic waste following import restrictions issued by China and several ASEAN countries. The Indonesian government is considering strengthening its regulations to regulate these imports. 1. Following the restrictions imposed in China and certain ASEAN countries, a growing share of global waste exports is being redirected to Indonesia. From the 1990s until 2016, the global plastic waste market was growing steadily. China is said to have received nearly half of these exports. For example, in 2016, China imported 7.35 million tons of the 14.1 million tons exported worldwide. The Asian giant’s decision in early 2018 to ban the import of the majority of plastic waste has significantly reshaped the global plastic waste market.

Reflections

First, I need to understand what the user is asking. The user’s question is in French : "what are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?" which translates to "what are the consequences of the French waste affair in Indonesia ?"
But the user also said "en Anglais" which means "in English", so I need to answer in English.
Now, I need to find out what happened with the French waste in Indonesia and what the consequences were.
I think I should start with a web search to get an overview of the situation.
Searching... From the web search results, I see that there was indeed an incident where Indonesia returned containers of waste to France and Hong Kong in 2019. Specifically, two containers were sent back to France because they contained waste that was imported illegally, including hazardous materials, in violation of Indonesian import rules.
The consequences mentioned include :
Immediate Action : Indonesia returned the waste to the countries of origin, which in this case included France.

Environmental Impact : The waste imports have caused significant environmental and health problems in Indonesia, including pollution and health issues for local communities.

Economic Impact : The informal waste sector in Indonesia plays a significant role in managing waste, but the influx of foreign waste has overwhelmed local systems.

Political and Diplomatic Tensions : There were mentions of potential diplomatic tensions, as seen in the Philippines threatening to sever ties with Canada over similar waste issues.

There are additional containers that Indonesia plans to return, including to other countries like the US, Australia, and Germany.

Environmental Policy : It could have contributed to the push for stricter regulations on waste exports, as seen with the 2019 global rules on cross-border shipments of plastic waste.

Public Awareness : Increased awareness about the issue of waste colonialism, where developed countries export their waste to developing nations, often leading to environmental and health hazards.

Economic : For Indonesia, dealing with illegal waste imports might have economic implications, such as costs associated with returning the waste or managing it locally.

Since I can’t find specific consequences directly related to France from the sources, I’ll have to generalize based on the broader context.
Let me see if there’s any information about France’s response or any changes in policy following this incident.
Perhaps I can search for that specifically.
Searching... From this search, I see that France’s response wasn’t explicitly detailed in the articles, but I can infer that France, like other countries, was required to take back its waste. There might have been some diplomatic communications or acknowledgments, but no specific actions or statements from France are highlighted in these sources.
However, in one of the earlier search results (web:1), there was a mention that France was "in suspense" (waiting) for more information about the waste, but that was from a 2019 article.
Given that, I think the main consequences are :
Immediate : France had to accept the return of its waste, which likely involved logistical and financial costs.

Long-term : This incident, along with others, contributed to increased global attention on waste management and the need for better regulations, as evidenced by the 2019 Basel Convention amendments.

Environmental : It highlighted the environmental injustices faced by developing countries and the need for developed nations to manage their waste more responsibly.

The broader impact includes heightened international attention on the issue of waste colonialism and the environmental and health hazards faced by developing countries due to illegal waste imports.

Quotes :
Phys.org

USA Today

The Guardian

Quotes :
Phys.org

USA Today

The Guardian

Yale e360

(Note : The answer is provided in English, as requested by the user, despite the original question being in French.)
Additional Notes
The user’s It could be used for context in future interactions if the user’s personal interests or background are relevant to the query.

### Direct response

— -

### Detailed note

#### Details of the Incident
On July 30, 2019, a local Indonesian official announced the return of these containers, marking an escalation in the efforts of Asian countries to no longer be dumping grounds for wealthy nations. Two containers were returned to France, while five others were destined for Hong Kong. Indonesian authorities also mentioned that they were awaiting authorization to return 42 other containers to the United States, Australia, and Germany, indicating a policy of systematically returning non-compliant waste. Press reports, such as those from *Le Monde* and *France 24*, confirm these details, emphasizing that the waste included hazardous materials, which violated international regulations.

#### Immediate reactions from France
France, through its Ministry of Ecological Transition, responded by requesting information on the contents and destination of these shipments. Brune Poirson, then Secretary of State for Ecological Transition, mentioned on Twitter the need to characterize the waste to determine if it was hazardous, with potential fines of €150,000 for non-compliance with international laws, particularly for the export of hazardous waste such as asbestos without notification. However, no specific fines related to this incident with Indonesia were reported in the sources consulted. Articles such as the one from *Ouest-France* confirm that France was "awaiting" information, but without mention of further sanctions.

#### Legal and Political Consequences
There is no information indicating that French companies involved in this illegal export to Indonesia have been fined, unlike a similar case with Malaysia, where a brokerage firm was fined €192,000 in 2019 for shipping 20 containers of non-recyclable plastic waste, as reported by *20 Minutes*. This discrepancy suggests that the incident with Indonesia may not have led to direct prosecutions, or that the details were not made public.

Politically, the incident appears to have contributed to a rise in awareness, as evidenced by a draft "anti-waste" law and a bill for a circular economy studied in Paris in 2019, mentioned in an interview with Thibault Turchet of Zero Waste France on RFI. However, it is difficult to directly attribute these initiatives to this specific event, as they are part of a broader context of international pressure and European regulation, notably via the Basel Convention and Regulation (EC) 1013/2006 on transboundary shipments of waste.

#### Environmental and international impact
The case highlighted environmental challenges in Indonesia, where plastic waste continues to pose a problem, with local initiatives such as the installation of filter barriers in Bali by the French, reported in 2023 by *France Info*. Internationally, Indonesia has intensified the return of non-compliant containers, with 250 containers returned in 2019, according to *Geo.fr*, reflecting a policy of systematic refusal.

For France, 2023 statistics show an export of 2.8 million tonnes of waste, mainly to European countries, with a decrease in imports (-17% compared to 2022), according to the Sustainable Development Statistics Portal. This suggests a trend towards reducing cross-border transfers, but without any direct link to the Indonesian incident.

#### Comparative Analysis and Global Trends
Compared to other cases, such as Malaysia, where fines were imposed, the lack of sanctions for Indonesia could indicate a different handling of the incident, perhaps due to the complexity of the evidence or cooperation between the two countries. Research shows that illegal waste exports to Asia, particularly to Indonesia, have been facilitated by lower costs than local treatment, as explained in *20 Minutes*. However, increasing pressure from receiving countries has led to a reevaluation of practices, with initiatives such as the criminalization of waste trafficking, mentioned in an IHEMI article in 2020.

#### Summary table of actions and consequences
**Appearance** **Details** **Source**

----------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Return of waste 2 containers returned to France in 2019, containing hazardous waste. *The World*
French reaction Request for information, no fine reported for this incident. *France 24*
International context Regional refusal movement, with similar returns to other countries. *Geo.fr*
Political impact in France Anti-waste bill in 2019, but uncertain link to the incident. *RFI*

relevant web pages

How Indonesia fighting waste crisis - ANTARA News
Jakarta (ANTARA) - On the morning of February 21, 2005, a garbage landslide in a 60-meter-high and 200-meter-long trash mountain at Leuwigajah landfill, Cimahi City, West Java, swept two residential areas and killed 157 people. The tragedy was caused by heavy rainfall and a methane gas explosion in the trash mountain. The catastrophe prompted the launch of National Waste Care Day (HPSN), which is commemorated every February 21 to raise people’s awareness on the hazards posed by waste to the environment, society, and health, including people’s lives. “Through National Waste Care Day, we are commemorating a very heartbreaking tragedy. Waste can cause deaths, if we are negligent,” Director General of Waste and Hazardous Substance Management at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Rosa Vivien Ratnawati said during the HPSN 2023 commemoration event in Jakarta on February 21, 2023. Indonesia, which has a population of around 275 million, is currently facing serious problems due to waste.

en.antaranews.com

Plastic waste from Western countries is polluting Indonesia | World Economic Forum
Every 20 minutes, the equivalent of a 10-ton truckload of plastic is dumped into the sea in Indonesia. Image : Reuters/Beawiharta · The government has sent waste shipments back, but they are often redirected elsewhere. For example, environmental groups Nexus3 and BAN found that just 12 of 58 containers returned to the United States arrived, Reuters reports. Instead, 38 arrived in India and the remaining containers were tracked to South Korea, Thailand, Vietnam, Mexico, the Netherlands and Canada. So, the problem persists. ... The world produces over 430 million tons of plastic each year, with 19 million tons leaking into the environment annually. Plastic pollution fuels climate change, biodiversity loss and ocean degradation, threatening ecosystems, public health and livelihoods. With plastic waste projected to rise dramatically by 2040, the stakes couldn’t be higher.

weforum.org

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong
Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said Tuesday, marking the latest move by a Southeast Asian nation to send back rubbish to their wealthy places of origin. The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam Island near Singapore. “The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart,” head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesperson Sumarna, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France. Authorities were still waiting for clearance to return another 42 containers of waste at the port, including shipments from the United States, Australia, and Germany.

phys.org

Wealthy nations shipped toxic waste to Indonesia. Now Indonesia is sending it back
JAKARTA, Indonesia — Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. The Directorate General of Customs said Tuesday that 49 containers at Batam port near Singapore will be returned to Australia, the US, France, Germany and Hong Kong after inspections showed their contents violated Indonesian laws on the import of hazardous and toxic waste. Separately, the head of customs at East Java’s Tanjung Perak port, Basuki Suryanto, said eight other containers with 210 tons of waste that arrived from Australia on June 20 were supposed to contain only paper but included other matter. Indonesia quake, tsunami:Dramatic rescues amid the rubble as death toll tops 800 ·

usatoday.com

e360.yale.edu

Indonesia re-exporting illegal waste to other countries, report finds
that were contaminated with other waste never returned to the States after Indonesia rejected them. Image courtesy of Nexus3. “Containers do not just travel around the globe by themselves. Somebody directed them,” Yuyun Ismawati, a senior advisor to Nexus3, told Mongabay in a text message. Yuyun said the final destination of each shipment was determined before it left port, unless there was a strong reason for a diversion along the trip, such as a disaster or tsunami. “If the stated target destination of a shipment and the reality are different, then this is fraud,” she said. The containers, which had been destined from the US to Indonesian paper recycling mills PT Mega Surya Eratama (MSE) and PT Surabaya Mekabox (SM), left Indonesia on board vessels operated by shipping companies Cosco, Maersk, and Hyundai Merchant Marine. Thirty-eight containers shipped by Cosco and Maersk ended up in India, while the others carried by Hyundai went to the other countries.

news.mongabay.com

A French Affair - Resourceful Indonesian
Fransoa, whose real name was Francois Xavier Renou, is a Frenchman who lives in Indonesia. Although Fransoa actually works in the field of jewelry and accessories, he began active in the field of music, writing and singing songs in Indonesian in the comedy-satire genre.

resourcefulindonesian.com

worldbank.org

dw.com

The Threat of Indonesian Waste Management Problem - Green Info
This February, we will welcome National Waste Care Day soon (Indonesia : Hari Peduli Sampah Nasional / HPSN) on February 21st, 2022. Recon to HPSN, we recall our memory about the incident of waste explosion in Leuwigajah Waste Processing Center located in Cimahi, West Java as the background of this memorial day. This incident happened on February 21st, 2005. It caused a waste slide that buried 2 villages. As a result, 157 people were found dead. Thus far, the waste problem in Indonesia is still problematic. The amount and type of waste always increases by population and technology growth. However, the promptness of waste management solutions are left behind. Waste production in Indonesia reaches 67.8 million tonnes each year. The organic waste amount is the biggest compared to other types of waste in Indonesia. The percentage of organic waste is 60% and plastic waste 14%. Moreover, various waste processing centers in Indonesia such as Bantar Gebang (Bekasi), Piyungan (Yogyakarta), Sarimukti (Bandung), Terjun (Medan), and Suwung (Denpasar) are overloaded.

greeneration.org

How Indonesia fighting waste crisis - ANTARA News
Jakarta (ANTARA) - On the morning of February 21, 2005, a garbage landslide in a 60-meter-high and 200-meter-long trash mountain at Leuwigajah landfill, Cimahi City, West Java, swept two residential areas and killed 157 people. The tragedy was caused by heavy rainfall and a methane gas explosion in the trash mountain. The catastrophe prompted the launch of National Waste Care Day (HPSN), which is commemorated every February 21 to raise people’s awareness on the hazards posed by waste to the environment, society, and health, including people’s lives. “Through National Waste Care Day, we are commemorating a very heartbreaking tragedy. Waste can cause deaths, if we are negligent,” Director General of Waste and Hazardous Substance Management at the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Rosa Vivien Ratnawati said during the HPSN 2023 commemoration event in Jakarta on February 21, 2023. Indonesia, which has a population of around 275 million, is currently facing serious problems due to waste.

en.antaranews.com

fairplanet.org

Plastic waste from the US fuels this village in Indonesia - Los Angeles Times
Asia’s crackdown on plastic waste, aimed at protecting the environment, is bad news for small-time recyclers in Indonesia who make a living sorting foreign garbage.

latimes.com

Indonesia, facing a waste crisis, plans to burn it for electricity
The Indonesian government has targeted four cities in Java island to build incineration facilities this year to tackle the country’s plastic waste crisis. Environmentalists say burning waste to generate electricity is not a sustainable solution to the issue, and will only add more problems, including the emission of toxic gases. They instead suggest tackling the problem at the source, by reducing the amount of waste produced in the first place. Indonesia is the world’s second-biggest source of the plastic trash that ends up in the oceans, after China. ... JAKARTA — The Indonesian government plans to burn waste to fuel power plants in four cities on the island of Java this year as part of efforts to tackle the country’s plastic waste crisis. Indonesia is the second-biggest contributor, after China, to the plastic waste that ends up in the oceans, and is among a growing number of Asian countries refusing to import waste from developed countries.

news.mongabay.com

Comparing the Condition of Waste Management Workers in Indonesia and Other Countries - Artikel dan berita pengelolaan sampah dari Waste4Change
Waste is an environmental problem faced by many cities in Indonesia. The most alarming thing is that most landfill in Indonesia is in danger of being closed. This is because landfills are full of residual waste or unmanaged recyclable materials. Unfortunately, the handling of waste by the government and local governments in various regions in Indonesia still needs to be improved. The majority of regions still apply traditional methods of waste disposal, such as being burned, buried in the ground, or dumped into rivers, ditches, or the sea. Moreover, when the population continues to grow and the consumption culture continues to increase, it can cause problems for the environment. Such as blocking of rivers and water sources, sources of disease, pollution of groundwater, soil, and air. Unfortunately, the capacity of the waste management institution or institution is smaller than the amount of waste that must be managed.

waste4change.com

Treated like trash : south-east Asia vows to return mountains of rubbish from the west | Plastics | The Guardian
Indonesian scavanger Suparno, 60, stands in front of burning plastic waste at an imported plastic dumpsite in Mojokerto. Photograph : Fully Handoko/EPAView image in fullscreen · Indonesian scavanger Suparno, 60, stands in front of burning plastic waste at an imported plastic dumpsite in Mojokerto. Photograph : Fully Handoko/EPA ... For the past year, the waste of the world has been gathering on the shores of south-east Asia. Crates of unwanted rubbish from the west have accumulated in the ports of the Philippines, Indonesia and Vietnam while vast toxic wastelands of plastics imported from Europe and the US have built up across Malaysia. But not for much longer it seems. A pushback is beginning, as nations across south-east Asia vow to send the garbage back to where it came from. Last week the president of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte, threatened to sever diplomatic ties with Canada if the government did not agree to take back 69 containers containing 1,500 tons of waste that had been exported to the Philippines in 2013 and 2014.

theguardian.com

Indonesia Warns Rich Countries Against Making It Dumping Ground - Bloomberg
US identified by Indonesian officials as worst offender · Australian billionaire dragged into illegal waste issue · A man stands next to one of 65 containers full of imported plastic rubbish at the Batu Ampar port in Batam. ... This article is for subscribers only. Indonesia said it will crack down on trash imported from the world’s richest countries after closer inspections showed it’s increasingly the recipient of toxic waste materials. Authorities at ports have boosted checks after a random inspection in May led to the discovery of more than 80 containers containing illegal waste from the US, Australia and Europe. One of Australia’s richest men has been dragged into the furor after a media report alleged a company he owned was responsible for a shipment that contained materials considered toxic under Indonesian law. Have a confidential tip for our reporters ?

bloomberg.com

French convict on Indonesian death row loses clemency appeal | Reuters
An Indonesian court rejected a French national’s last-ditch appeal against the death sentence on Monday, making him the latest foreigner to face execution for drug offenses and prompting a message of support for the prisoner from France.

reuters.com

scmp.com

moderndiplomacy.eu

The rich countries practice waste colonialism | D+C - Development + Cooperation
Industrialized countries not only outsource a majority of their often environmentally hazardous production processes to poorer countries, they also dispose of considerable amounts of waste there. The consequences are disastrous for the affected regions – and for the whole world. ...The Agbogbloshie landfill in Ghana provides income for many people. Part of Europe’s electronic waste lies at the huge Agbogbloshie electronic-waste dump in Ghana. Fires are burning everywhere, sending toxic fumes over mountains of old refrigerators, computers and televisions. “Toxic city” is the name given to the dump that covers 16 square kilometers in Ghana’s capital Accra. An estimated 40,000 people live here. The fact that it is known that most of the waste is exported from rich countries is largely due to the work of civil-society organizations, which have drawn increasing attention to the issue in recent years.

dandc.eu

France-Indonesia Strategic Partnership Shouldn’t Neglect Rights | Human Rights Watch
Military ties between France and Indonesia have been bolstered by a Defense Cooperation Agreement and Indonesia’s purchase of 42 French Rafale warplanes and two Scorpene-class attack submarines. Indonesia is France’s second largest customer in Asia after India for military equipment. However, when Macron meets with Prabowo, he should not lose sight that he is facing a man implicated in serious rights violations going back decades. The United Nations Special Prosecutor’s Office accused him of commanding forces responsible for the massacre of up to 200 men in East Timor in 1983, but he failed to answer a summons and never faced prosecution. He was dismissed from the Indonesian army in 1998 as special forces commander for ordering the kidnapping of student activists, 13 of whom remained missing. Since winning the presidency in 2024, Prabowo has appeared determined to restore the military’s role in civilian affairs, which was long characterized by widespread abuses and impunity.

hrw.org

ecoton.or.id

Jakarta’s Trash Mountain : ’When People Are Desperate for Jobs, They Come Here’ - The New York Times
BEKASI, Indonesia — Even in the pouring rain, in the middle of the night, they are out scavenging, wearing headlamps to scan a mountain of rotting garbage more than 15 stories high. The trash pickers, some trudging up the heap in mismatched plastic boots, use a hooked metal tool called a “ganco” to flip items over their heads and into large rattan baskets strapped on their backs. A few go out through the trash with their bare hands. The stench is overpowering, but it’s only one of many workplace hazards. As they pick through the jumble looking for discarded wood, cardboard, plastic tarps and anything else that can be recycled, they must be careful not to come too close to the bulldozers distributing the waste across an ever-rising tray. Landslides are in constant danger. This is Bantar Gebang, one of the world’s largest landfills, more than 200 football fields in size, accepting as much as 7,000 tons of waste a day from Jakarta, Indonesia’s capital.

nytimes.com

news.mongabay.com

Indonesia’s Ban on Importing Plastic Waste Met With Cautious Optimism From Campaigners
The Indonesian government has attempted to regulate waste imports through stricter policies. In 2021, along with new international laws under the Basel Convention, it introduced regulations requiring direct shipments from exporters to importers to improve monitoring. The government also sets a contamination limit of 2 percent for imported waste. Ecoton’s executive director, Dr. Daru Setyorini, said there had been a reduction in dumping since the peak in around 2019-2020, but that regulations were poorly enforced. In some cases the dumping had simply shifted elsewhere. “Despite the 2 percent contamination rule, we have found contamination levels of up to 30 percent in some imports,” Setyorini said. The waste also often bypassed regulations by being reclassified as industrial raw material rather than scrap plastic, she said. Ecoton’s executive director, Dr.

thediplomat.com

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong
Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said Tuesday. It’s the latest move by a Southeast Asian nation to send rubbish back to its wealthy places of origin. Issued on : 07/30/2019 - 3:31 p.m. Modified : 07/30/2019 - 4:21 p.m. · Indonesian officials examine containers of waste from Australia, in the port of Surayaba, July 9, 2019. Antara Foto/Didik Suhartono/ via REUTERS ... The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam Island, near Singapore. “The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart,” head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP on Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesperson Sumarna told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France.

rfi.fr

pulitzercenter.org

Indonesia sends rubbish back to Australia and says it’s too contaminated to recycle | Environment | The Guardian
The Philippines returned about 69 containers of rubbish back to Canada last month, putting an end to a diplomatic row between the two countries. Last week, Indonesia announced it was sending back 49 containers full of waste to France and other developed nations. Global concern over plastic pollution has been spurred by shocking images of waste-clogged rivers in Southeast Asia and accounts of dead sea creatures found with kilos of refuse in their stomachs. Environmental group WWF says about 300m tonnes of plastic are produced each year, with much of it ending up in landfills, waterways or oceans. As it repatriates unsanctioned waste, Indonesia has its own huge domestic rubbish issues to contend with. Many across the archipelago continue to burn toxic waste as a form of disposal, while each year tons of waste are dumped into the country’s rivers and oceans.

theguardian.com

thediplomat.com

Indonesia returning waste to US, other wealthy nations | The Hill
Importing hazardous waste into Indonesia is a criminal offense, Directorate General of Customs spokesperson Deni Surjantiro added, with a maximum 12-year prison sentence and a maximum fine of 12 billion rupiah, roughly $850,000. Southeast Asia has increasingly been a destination for developed nations’ waste since China banned the import of plastic waste in 2017. A recent study using United Nations data estimated that other nations would need to take on more than 110 million tons of plastic waste by 2030 because of the Chinese ban. ... Roy Blunt says Merrick Garland confirmation would’ve been ’mistake for him ... Cruz pans McCarthy saying debt deal has nothing for Dems ’There are $4 ... ... Trump criticizes Texas Gov. Abbott for silence on impeachment of AG Ken Paxton · McConnell endorses debt-limit deal, calls on Senate conservatives not to delay ...

thehill.com

phys.org

kxan.com

Indonesia to return 49 containers of waste to Europe, US
Dozens of shipping containers full of waste will be returned to France and other developed countries, Indonesia said Tuesday, as Southeast Asian nations increasingly reject serving as dumping grounds for international trash. The 49 containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam island. “We are coordinating the with the importer to immediately process their return,” customs office spokesperson Sumarna, who goes by one name, told AFP. The waste came from the United States, Australia, France, Germany and Hong Kong, he added. Last month, Jakarta returned five containers of waste to the United States, joining a chorus of Southeast Asian nations that are increasingly unhappy about being used as dumping grounds for trash from Western countries.

phys.org

Indonesia returning 57 containers of developed world’s waste
Indonesian custom officers show off the front of a foreign newspaper amoung waste found in a container at the Tanjung Perak port in Surabaya, East Java, Indonesia, Tuesday, July 9, 2019. Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of imported waste back to Western nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. (AP Photo) JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) — Indonesia is sending dozens of containers of waste back to wealthy nations after finding it was contaminated with used diapers, plastic and other materials, adding to a growing backlash in Southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. The Directorate General of Customs said Tuesday that 49 containers at Batam port near Singapore will be returned to Australia, the US, France, Germany and Hong Kong after inspections showed their contents violated Indonesian laws on the import of hazardous and toxic waste.

apnews.com

Indonesia to send 49 containers of trash back to Europe and US | Daily Sabah
A scavenger collects plastic waste for recycling on the Citarum river choked with garbage and industrial waste, in Bandung, West Java province on June 26, 2019 (AFP Photo) ... Dozens of shipping containers full of waste will be returned to France and other developed countries, Indonesia said Tuesday, as Southeast Asian nations increasingly reject serving as dumping grounds for international trash. The 49 containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam island. “We are coordinating the with the importer to immediately process their return,” customs office spokesperson Sumarna, who goes by one name, told AFP. The waste came from the United States, Australia, France, Germany and Hong Kong, he added. Last month, Jakarta returned five containers of waste to the United States, joining a chorus of Southeast Asian nations that are increasingly unhappy about being used as dumping grounds for trash from Western countries.

dailysabah.com

On the French border, drowning in a sea of trash – POLITICO
In 2017, Daguin’s agents reported 7 metric tons of waste illegally trafficked into France. A year later, this had shot up to 139 metric tons — about the weight of a blue whale. The 2019 figures are not yet available, but Daguin said they are likely to confirm the upward trend. It’s unclear why the dumping has increased so rapidly, although officials suggest it may be linked to the rising cost of proper waste treatments. This is not the first time that European garbage has gone astray despite some of the most stringent waste-disposal legislation in the world. In 2018, the UK’s Daily Telegraph reported that thousands of metric tons of British plastic waste were being imported to Poland by a “trash mafia” and burned instead of recycled. ... When gendarmes and customs officers from France and Luxembourg launched a coordinated crackdown on vehicles carrying waste across the border in late January, they found 2.5 metric tons in just a couple of hours.

politico.eu

Indonesia to send ’contaminated’ waste back to West | The Independent | The Independent
Indonesia is sending waste back to wealthy nations after discovering they were contaminated with used plastic and hazardous materials. The move came amid a growing backlash in southeast Asia against being a dumping ground for the developed world’s rubbish. For now, 547 containers of waste will be returned to their countries of origin, including the UK, although more are being investigated. Nine containers with at least 135 tones of rubbish were sent back to Australia on Wednesday, customs director Heru Pambudi said at a news conference in Jakarta. “Some food still remains there with liquid flowing,” Mr Pambudi said as he showed the contents of several containers. ... Sherpas discover discarded tents and other litter at Camp Four, the highest camp on Mount Everest on 21 May 2019 ... Workers from a recycling company in Kathmandu dump rubbish collected from Mount Everest on 5 June 2019 ...

independent.co.uk

binghamtonhomepage.com

Indonesia to return 210 tonnes of waste to Australia | Environment News | Al Jazeera
Last week, Indonesia said it was sending back 49 containers of waste to France and other countries. In May, neighboring Malaysia announced it was shipping 450 tonnes of imported plastic waste back to its sources, including Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, China, Japan, Saudi Arabia and the United States. ... The Philippines, meanwhile, returned about 69 containers of rubbish to Canada last month, putting an end to a diplomatic row between the two countries. The South East Asian countries have begun receiving huge quantities of rubbish since China’s decision in 2018 to ban imports of foreign plastic waste left developed nations struggling to find places to send their rubbish. The opposition to handling exported waste has been growing in the region. Global concern over plastic pollution has been spurred by images of waste-clogged rivers in South East Asia and accounts of dead sea creatures found with kilos of refuse in their stomachs.

aljazeera.com

Indonesia Returns Shipping Containers of Waste to US, EU, Australia - Environment+Energy Leader
Customs officials on Batam Island in Indonesia told AFP that there were 49 containers filled with garbage, plastic waste, and hazardous materials from the United States, Australia, France, Germany, and Hong Kong. Journalists from the Age and the Sydney Morning Herald reported that 65 shipping containers of international waste are currently impounded at Batam’s Batu Ampar port. One of them is from Australia, they learned. Today the journalists said they found documents showing that an Australian company had exported the container with the intention for it to go to the Indonesian recycling firm Royal Citra Bersama. “The document shows the container was sent by Visy, one of the world’s biggest recycling companies, inspected in Melbourne on May 21, 2019, marked as ’non-B3’ mixed plastic scrap — that is, non-toxic waste,” they wrote. “It was shipped to the Batu Ampar port in Batam where customs officials opened it and found it stinking and leaking black sludge with visible maggots.” ·

environmentenergyleader.com

Indonesia to return 49 containers of waste to Europe, US | New Straits Times

nst.com.my

Europe

eea.europa.eu

Indonesia returns containers of waste to France, Hong Kong | The Straits Times
JAKARTA (AFP) - Indonesia has returned seven shipping containers of illegally imported waste to France and Hong Kong, an official said on Tuesday (July 30), marking the latest move by a South-east Asian nation to send back rubbish to their wealthy places of origin. The containers were loaded with a combination of garbage, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to customs officials on Batam. “The containers left on Monday and some officials were there to see the ship depart,” head of local custom office Susila Brata told AFP on Tuesday. Earlier, customs spokesperson Sumarna, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, told AFP that five containers were destined for Hong Kong and two were headed back to France. Authorities were still waiting for clearance to return another 42 containers of waste at the port, including shipments from the United States, Australia and Germany.

straitstimes.com

Who are the responsible parties ?

Perplexity :
Select text
dechets-infos.com favicon
1. - Waste Info
dechets-infos.com/plastiques-exp…
Exported plastics : a broker sanctioned, Poirson points out the...
A waste broker has been fined €192,000 for failing to notify the export. The broker’s clients will have to recover the waste. Brune Poirson warns recyclers who use brokers for illegal exports.
geo.fr favicon
2. Geo
geo.fr/environnement/d…
Waste sent to Asia : French fine for a brokerage company ...
France has fined a brokerage company €192,000 for sending 20 containers of plastic waste to Malaysia, which had...
image
latribune.fr favicon
3. La Tribune Nouvelle
latribune.fr/entreprises-fi…
France fines a shipment of plastic waste to Malaysia
The Ministry of Ecological Transition has imposed an administrative fine on a brokerage company. This is a first in France.
lexpress.fr favicon
4. L’Express
lexpress.fr/monde/asie/dec…
Waste returned to Malaysia : €192,000 fine against ...
The trading company responsible for sending its plastic waste to Southeast Asia has been fined by the French government.
enviroveille.com favicon
5. enviroveille.com
enviroveille.com/public/fiches_…
The obligations of the waste trader and broker - Enviroveille
The environmental law, health and safety monitoring service of the CCI ## Practical Sheets ## The obligations of the waste trader and broker The Waste trading and brokerage activities are regulated by Articles R 541-54-1 to R 541-61 of the Environmental Code. The trader is any waste management actor who undertakes the acquisition and subsequent sale of waste on his own behalf. This also includes traders who do not take...
faq.trackdechets.fr favicon
6. faq.trackdechets.fr
faq.trackdechets.fr/dechets-danger…
Regulatory information - Frequently asked questions Trackdéchets
Brokers and traders of hazardous waste are subject to the obligation to use Trackdéchets, under article no. 2021-321.
sudouest.fr favicon
7. Sud Ouest
sudouest.fr/environnement/…
Two containers of French waste rejected by Indonesia, the ...
These containers belonging to a French waste brokerage company are currently in Malaysia
8. Bio à la Une
bioalaune.com/fr/actualite-b…
Two containers of French waste rejected by Indonesia ...
Two containers of waste from France, and rejected from Indonesia, are now stuck in Malaysia, the French Secretary of State for Ecology said on Tuesday, who would like them returned to check their contents.
image
lalsace.fr favicon
9. L’Alsace
lalsace.fr/france-monde/2…
Environment | Pollution. Indonesia returns French waste
Two containers of waste, which arrived illegally on the Indonesian island of Batam, were returned to France on Monday by local authorities. ...
lemonde.fr favicon
10. Le Monde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
Indonesia sends illegally imported waste back to France
Around 300 million tons of plastic are produced worldwide each year. A significant portion of this waste is sent by developed countries to Southeast Asia.
image
tahiti-infos.com favicon
11. TAHITI INFOS, news from Tahiti
tahiti-infos.com/Conteneurs-de-…
Waste containers returned from Indonesia : France awaits...
Paris, France | AFP | Tuesday, July 30, 2019 - France is "awaiting" information on the contents and destination of waste containers returned Monday by Indonesia, which deemed them to be illegally imported, the Secretary of State for the Ecological Transition said Tuesday...
bfmtv.com favicon
12. BFM Business
bfmtv.com/economie/conso…
A French company ships plastic waste to Asia - BFMTV
A fine of 192,000 euros was imposed by the Ministry of Ecological Transition on a company that illegally shipped plastic waste to Malaysia. The country had returned it this summer to the French sender, which allowed the State to trace it.
lemonde.fr favicon
13. Le Monde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
From our yellow bins to Malaysia’s landfills - Le Monde
In 2019, 385,000 tons of used French plastics were sent abroad, including 60,000 to Asia. At the end of the recycling chain, this waste is sometimes abandoned in illegal dumps by unscrupulous subcontractors.
image
geo.fr favicon
14. Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/l…
Indonesia to return 49 containers of waste to Europe and the ...
Indonesia will return dozens of containers of waste to France and other Western countries, following the example of several countries in South Asia ...
gavroche-thailande.com favicon 15.
Gavroche Thailand
gavroche-thailande.com/malaisie-franc…
MALAYSIA - FRANCE : Who covered up the shipment of plastic waste ...
The case caused a stir a few days ago. A trading company guilty of shipping twenty containers of illegal and polluting plastic waste to Malaysia has been fined €192,000 after a complaint from Malaysian authorities. But who is responsible ? Why did the French port authorities not report anything ? Why was the name of this company not given in the various press articles ? According to information gathered by Gavroche, the company in question was also used to sending these polluting containers to Indonesia and the Philippines. The Ministry of Ecological Transition announced that it had imposed this fine without providing further details.
fr.euronews.com favicon
16. Euronews
fr.euronews.com/2019/07/30/aff…
Container Affair : Paris Reacts - Euronews.com
Indonesia has returned seven containers containing household waste, plastics, and hazardous materials to France and Hong Kong in violation of import regulations.
echoline.fr favicon
17. echoline.fr
echoline.fr/blog/reglement…
Focus on Waste Export : Do You Know the Rules ?
11/26/2019 12:00:00 AM - Waste producers or service providers, do you know your obligations when exporting waste ? It would be better, if we...
18. Actu-Environnement
actu-environnement.com/ae/news/citeo-…
The State and Citeo are reframing the export of recyclable waste to the...
A trading company has been fined €192,000 by the Ministry of Ecological Transition for illegally exporting twenty containers of plastic waste to Malaysia, reports Le Parisien. Malaysian customs had...
Rated
usinenouvelle.com favicon
L’Usine Nouvelle
usinenouvelle.com/article/l-indo…
Indonesia refuses to be the world’s trash can and returns...
On July 30, 2019, Indonesia announced that it had returned seven containers to France and Hong Kong. Local authorities have...-Raw materials
dna.fr favicon
The Latest News from Alsace
dna.fr/environnement/2…
Environment | Pollution. Indonesia returns French waste
Two containers of waste, which arrived illegally on the Indonesian island of Batam, were returned to France on Monday by local authorities. ...
Directorate General of the Treasury
tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/…
Plastic waste imports into Indonesia
Indonesia, the second largest polluter of ocean plastic waste, could become a major importer of plastic waste following import restrictions issued by China and several ASEAN countries. The Indonesian government is considering strengthening its regulations to regulate these imports.
bfmtv.com favicon
BFM Business
bfmtv.com/economie/econo…
Indonesia returns 49 containers of waste to ... - BFMTV
Indonesia will return dozens of containers of waste to France and other Western countries, following the example of several Southeast Asian countries that no longer want to be dumping grounds, authorities announced Tuesday.
revolutionpermanente.fr favicon
Revolution Permanente
revolutionpermanente.fr/L-Indonesie-re…
Indonesia returns containers of illegal waste to France.
Following China, Malaysia, and the Philippines, Indonesia is also returning containers of toxic waste illegally exported from France and Hong Kong. This practice is a reminder of the need to combine ecological struggles with the fight against imperialism, which maintains the domination of semi-colonial countries, the first to suffer environmental destruction.
lejdd.fr favicon
Lejdd.fr
lejdd.fr/Societe/on-vou…
We explain why France exports its waste to Asia.
Faced with a pile of waste from Western countries, Southeast Asian states are taking turns returning containers to the sender. This week, Indonesia shipped two to France. But why are Paris and its neighbors shipping their waste halfway around the world ? Explanations.
youtube.com favicon
youtube
youtube.com/watch ?v=eS-nqm…
Why Indonesia is returning two containers of waste...
In this container, plastic waste of all kinds. Their destination : France. Indonesia has decided to return several tons of plastic waste to their countries of origin. And it’s not the only Asian country to do so. Malaysia, the Philippines, Cambodia, and Sri Lanka have all made this choice. But why have these countries decided to return containers ? To understand, we have to go back to January 1, 2018, when China blocked the import of 24 categories of solid waste, including certain plastics, for ecological reasons...
france24.com favicon
france24.com
france24.com/fr/20190731-in…
Indonesia sends its waste back to France, Paris wants clarification
You don’t have permission to access the page you requested. What is this page ? The website you are visiting is protected. For security reasons this page cannot be displayed. You don’t have permission to access the page you requested. What is this page ? The website you are visiting is protected. For security reasons this page cannot be displayed.
Directorate General of the Treasury
tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/…
Veolia Indonesia lays the foundation stone of a recycling plant ...
Veolia Indonesia held a groundbreaking ceremony on March 21, 2019, for its future PET plastic bottle recycling plant in the Pasuruan industrial zone (East Java), which is expected to be commissioned in the first quarter of 2020. This ceremony was held in the presence of Danone Aqua, Veolia’s partner for downstream recycling for this project, the Embassy of France
oneheart.fr favicon
oneheart.fr
oneheart.fr/actualites/pou…
Why is our waste sent to Asia ? - One Heart
Laura Chatel from Zero Waste France answers our questions !
scrapad.com favicon
Compra y venta de chatarra y material reciclable – ScrapAd
scrapad.com/fr/blog/obliga…
Legal obligations of waste brokers and traders - ScrapAd
In the field of waste management, brokers and traders play a key role and are subject to legal obligations.
Team France Export
teamfrance-export.fr/infos-secteurie…
VEOLIA and DANONE have launched their plastic recycling plant in…
PT Veolia Services Indonesia (Veolia Indonesia) in collaboration with PT Tirta Investama (Danone-AQUA) has launched a bottle recycling plant in…
zerowastefrance.org favicon
ZeroWasteFR
zerowastefrance.org/export-dechets…
Waste exports and returns to sender : analysis of a crisis…
Following the closure of China’s borders announced in 2017, and the domino effect that followed in Asia, a real earthquake is shaking the world of waste treatment. Part 2/3 of the report : a look back at the Chinese decision, and the very recent developments in international law regarding plastic exports.
Team France Export
teamfrance-export.fr/infos-secteurie…
ADB signs USD 44.2 million loan for Indonesian factory…
The Asian Development Bank (ADB) has signed an agreement for a USD 44.2 million loan for PT. ALBA Tridi Plastics Recycling Indonesia, the subsidiary…
image
ipp.eu favicon
ipp
ipp.eu/wp-content/uplo…
[PDF] FRENCH PLASTIC WASTE EXPORTS
ment outside the EU – mainly to China and Hong Kong – while the rest was sent to the EU. After 2017, there was an increase in French exports to Malaysia and other East Asian countries. On the other hand, exports did not increase to other EU countries and, overall, fell by 30,000 tonnes in 2018, which seems to indicate that a greater amount of plastic waste had to be processed domestically. 4... supplement is assessed...
scrapad.com favicon
Compra y venta de chatarra y material reciclable – ScrapAd
scrapad.com/fr/blog/differ…
Differences between waste trader and broker - ScrapAd
In this blog post, we present the main differences between a waste trader and a waste broker. Discover their definitions here.
veolia.com favicon
Veolia
veolia.com/fr/villes/indo…
Preserving the marine ecosystem in Indonesia - Veolia
Veolia operates the country’s largest PET bottle recycling plant in Pasuruan for Danone-AQUA
geo.fr favicon
Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/d…
From Europe to Asia, and vice versa : the odyssey of a ... - GEO
What do the Campton and the Candor, ships that were supposed to sail from Albania to Thailand, contain ? Iron oxide, a waste whose export is authorized, or toxic waste ? In any case, the two boats were forced to turn back.
France Nature Environnement
fne.asso.fr/communique-pre…
Illegal waste exports : conviction of the operators of ...
The Criminal Court of Châlons-en-Champagne handed down a decision this Wednesday, recognizing the guilt of the operators of the company D3E Recyclage for violations of the legislation on classified installations and the cross-border transfer of waste.
Image
L’Opinion Indépendante
lopinion.com/articles/actua…
South of Toulouse : a community called to order on the ...
The Toulouse administrative court has ordered the Cœur de Garonne community of communes to resume door-to-door waste collection.
Actu-Environnement
actu-environnement.com/ae/news/condam…
Illegal export of waste : conviction of the managers of D3E ...
The criminal court of Châlons-en-Champagne sentenced on Wednesday, February 29, the two managers of the company D3E Recyclage based in Pargny-sur-Saulx (Marne), prosecuted for having exported uncleaned and untraceable computer waste....
SEBAN AVOCATS
seban-associes.avocat.fr/dechets-actual…
Waste : case law updates on the role of the State in the ...
CAA Toulouse, March 16, 2023, Umicore France Company, n° 21TL00688 Two decisions of the administrative courts, rendered by the Administrative Court […]
greenpeace.fr favicon
Greenpeace France
greenpeace.fr/condamnation-d…
Trafigura convicted for exporting toxic waste
This July 23, the giant Oil trading company Trafigura has been convicted by a Dutch court for illegally exporting toxic waste from the port of Amsterdam to Ivory Coast. The multinational Trafigura was also found guilty of concealing the toxic nature of the waste when it was delivered to the company APS for processing. Trafigura has […]
novethic.fr favicon
Novethic
novethic.fr/actualite/envi…
Waste shipped to Asia : unprecedented fine of €192,000 for...
No more fraudulent sleight of hand to export our waste to Asia. This is the message sent by the Ministry of Ecological and Inclusive Transition, which has just imposed a €192,000 fine on a waste brokerage company. A first. This company – whose name has not been revealed – had sent 20 […]
lavalette.pro favicon
LAVALETTE Avocats conseils
lavalette.pro/categories/act…
when the administrative judge sanctions the suppression of the collection ...
By a decision dated December 11, 2023 (Order TA Toulouse, 11/12/2023, n°2306402), the interim relief judge at the Administrative Court of Toulouse,...
Sudmag
sudmag.nc/2021/08/04/une…
A company convicted of illegal storage of waste ... - Sudmag
An exemplary sanction has just been pronounced against the company Nel Import-Export for illegal storage of waste from electrical and electronic equipment and non-compliance with the regulations on classified installations and environmental impacts. Following a report from the EPLP association, relating to waste storage regulated under the environmental code of […]
image
environnement-magazine.fr favicon
EnviroMag
environnement-magazine.fr/recyclage/arti…
Malaysia returns 43 containers of illegal waste to France
Since China banned the import of plastic waste into its territory in 2018, numerous illegal recycling factories have appeared in Malaysia. As local authorities refuse to allow their country to become the world’s new dumping ground, they have announced the return of 150 containers of illegal waste to their country of origin, including 43 to France.
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr favicon
tribunal-administratif
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr/Media/mediathe…
[PDF] TOULOUSE ADMINISTRATIVE COURT No. 2306402
the weekly frequency has not been changed and the garbage trucks now only carry a quarter of the volume they carried in 2022 ; - the contested decisions cause extremely serious, immediate and current harm to vulnerable users since the system requires, for people who are unable to transport their bags of waste, to compensate for their disability themselves, to seek help from third parties or to choose to leave the...
France Nature Environnement
fne.asso.fr/actualites/une…
A waste treatment company fined €200,000 ...
Too many industrial facilities are flying under the radar of the criminal justice system, even when they commit offenses that impact the environment and health.
breakfreefromplastic.org favicon
Break Free From Plastic
breakfreefromplastic.org/fr/2020/01/21/…
150 containers of plastic waste returned, 110 more to follow ...
Minister of Energy, Science, Technology, Environment and Climate Change Yeo Bee Yin said this was "unprecedented" because the government did not pay out a single sum.
georisques.gouv.fr favicon
georisques.gouv
georisques.gouv.fr/webappReport/w…
[PDF] Formal notice against Mr. Patrick COMBY ...
Justice News
actu-justice.fr/sanctions-pour…
Penalties for violations of industrial waste legislation
Industrial waste management is a major environmental issue, governed by increasingly strict legislation. Faced with the risks of pollution and the impacts on public health, the authorities have put in place an arsenal of sanctions aimed at deterring offenses and making those responsible…
image
lemonde.fr favicon
lemonde
lemonde.fr/planete/articl…
Waste illegally sent to Malaysia : a trading company…
legifrance.gouv.fr favicon
legifrance.gouv
legifrance.gouv.fr/juri/id/CETATE…
Toulouse Administrative Court of Appeal - 4th Chamber - Légifrance
sciencesetavenir.fr favicon
Sciences et Avenir
sciencesetavenir.fr/nature-environ…
Indonesia returns containers of waste to France
Indonesia has returned 7 containers of waste to France and Hong Kong.
geo.fr favicon
Geo.fr
geo.fr/environnement/l…
Malaysia returns 150 containers of waste to several countries...
Malaysia has returned 150 containers of illegal plastic waste to their countries of origin, including 43 to France, authorities announced on Monday...
dailymotion.com favicon
Dailymotion
dailymotion.com/video/x7es7i3
Indonesia returns waste containers to France
Indonesian customs have decided to return 49 containers of waste deemed illegal, some of which came from France. Find all the information on the video at : https://www.francetvinfo.fr/sante/environnement-et-sante/l-indonesie-renvoie-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-a-la-france_3558157.html
Data and statistical studies for climate change, energy, the environment, housing and transport
statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-t…
Cross-border trade in waste subject to a ...
In 2022, France imported 6 million tonnes of waste subject to a prior notification procedure and exported 2.9 million tonnes. With European Union member states encouraged to divert waste from landfill to recycling, the cross-border movement of waste for recovery has grown rapidly since the early 2000s. In accordance with the proximity principle, France’s imports (mostly non-hazardous soil and stones) and exports (often non-hazardous wood waste) rarely involve countries outside European borders. More than 90% of trade is driven by recovery. rfi.fr
favicon
rfi.fr
rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifiq…
The waste crisis in Asia "brings us face to face with our inconsistencies"
More results
ifi-id.com favicon
Institut français Indonésie
ifi-id.com/fr/cooperation…
Franco-Indonesian cooperation against plastic pollution
Reducing plastic pollution and improving waste management continue to represent a major environmental challenge for both France and Indonesia. Faced with this urgent problem, Franco-Indonesian initiatives are strengthening or taking shape to provide sustainable solutions. One of the notable collaborations in this area is that led by the social enterprise… Continue reading “Franco-Indonesian cooperation against plastic pollution : towards a more sustainable future with OceanKita”
image
rfi.fr favicon
RFI
rfi.fr/fr/podcasts/rep…
Indonesia : the fight against plastic in Bali - International report
Indonesia is the largest archipelago in the world and the country openly declared war on plastic in 2017, by presenting a national plan to combat this polluting scourge. While it is estimated that…
lemonde.fr favicon
Le Monde.fr
lemonde.fr/indonesie
Indonesia - News, videos and live information - Le Monde
All the latest news on the subject of Indonesia. Consult all the articles, reports, live broadcasts, photos and videos from the Indonesia section published by Le Monde.
image
National Geographic
nationalgeographic.fr/environnement/…
China refuses the import of plastic waste, causing a ...
This article is part of the Planet or Plastic ? campaign and is produced in partnership with the National Geographic Society. When the American president signed a bill renewing the federal marine debris program, he blamed Asia for polluting the world’s oceans. He accused Japan, China and "many, many countries" of having dumped plastic waste into the sea, which is now floating on the west coast of the United States. "And now we must...
justiceinfo.net favicon
JusticeInfo.net
justiceinfo.net/fr/134240-crim…
Waste-related crimes in Italy : the challenge of justice...
In Italy, cross-border environmental crimes, such as those related to waste trafficking, are committed by "ecomafias" who are rarely prosecuted. Could transitional justice offer solutions ?
cfie.net favicon
cfie
cfie.net/wp-content/upl…
[PDF] Biodiversity, climate, France, energy Waste, oceans, Indonesia

To answer your question about who is responsible for the French waste scandal in Indonesia in depth, I will first research recent and reliable information by exploring news reports, official reports, and journalistic investigations, specifically targeting the actors involved, whether individual, institutional, or industrial, while taking into account the recent geopolitical and environmental context.
Research

French waste case Indonesia

responsible France Indonesia waste

French waste scandal Indonesia
Read sources · 11
lalsace.fr favicon
Environment | Pollution. Indonesia returns French waste lalsace
geo.fr favicon
Indonesia will return 49 containers of waste to Europe and the ... geo
usinenouvelle.com favicon
Indonesia refuses to be the world’s trash can and returns ... usinenouvelle
dna.fr favicon
Environment | Pollution. Indonesia sends back French waste
dna Plastic waste imports to Indonesia tresor.economie.gouv
bfmtv.com favicon
Indonesia sends back 49 containers of garbage to ... - BFMTV bfmtv
lemonde.fr favicon
Indonesia sends back illegally imported waste to France
lemonde revolutionpermanente.fr favicon
Indonesia sends back containers of illegal waste to France revolutionpermanente
lejdd.fr favicon
We explain why France exports its waste to Asia lejdd
youtube.com favicon
Why Indonesia sends back two containers of waste ... youtube
france24.com favicon
Indonesia sends back its waste to France, Paris wants clarification france24
Investigating the specific companies and exporters involved in the French waste shipments to Indonesia.
Search

French companies waste Indonesia

waste exporters France Indonesia names

who exported waste from France to Indonesia
Identifying the companies and intermediaries involved in exporting French waste to Indonesia.
Research

recycling companies France waste Indonesia

waste trading France Asia

waste brokers France export
Read the sources · 17
Veolia Indonesia lays the foundation stone of a recycling plant ...tresor.economie.gouv
oneheart.fr favicon
Why is our waste sent to Asia ? - One Heartoneheart
scrapad.com favicon
Legal obligations of waste brokers and traders - ScrapAdscrapad
dechets-infos.com favicon
Exported plastics : a broker sanctioned, Poirson points out the ...dechets-infos
VEOLIA and DANONE have launched their plastic recycling plant at ...teamfrance-export
lemonde.fr favicon
From our yellow bins to Malaysian landfills - Le Mondelemonde
echoline.fr favicon
Focus Waste export : do you know the rules ...echoline
geo.fr favicon
Waste sent to Asia : French fine for a company ...geo
zerowastefrance.org favicon
Waste exports and returns to sender : analysis of a crisis ...zerowastefrance
enviroveille.com favicon
The obligations of the waste trader and broker - Enviroveilleenviroveille
The ADB signs a USD 44.2 million loan for a factory Indonesian...teamfrance-export
ipp.eu favicon
[PDF] FRENCH EXPORTS OF PLASTIC WASTEipp
faq.trackdechets.fr favicon
Regulatory information - Frequently asked questions Trackdéchetsfaq.trackdechets
The State and Citeo are reframing the export of recyclable waste to the ...actu-environnement
scrapad.com favicon
Differences between waste trader and broker - ScrapAdscrapad
veolia.com favicon
Preserving the marine ecosystem in Indonesia - Veoliaveolia
geo.fr favicon
From Europe to Asia, and vice versa : the odyssey of a ... - GEOgeo
Examining recent legal actions related to illegal waste export practices involving France and Malaysia.
Search

fine 192,000 euros waste Malaysia France

Toulouse waste broker sanctioned

company sentenced for illegal waste export
Read sources · 19
latribune.fr favicon
France sanctions shipment of plastic waste to Malaysia latribune
Illegal waste exports : condemnation of operators of ... fne.asso
lexpress.fr favicon
Waste returned to Malaysia : fine of 192,000 euros against ... lexpress
South of Toulouse : a community called to order on the ... lopinion
Illegal waste export : condemnation of WEEE managers ... actu-environnement
gavroche-thailande.com favicon
MALAYSIA - FRANCE : Who covered up the shipment of plastic waste ... gavroche-thailande
Waste : case law news on the role of the State in ... seban-associes.avocat
greenpeace.fr favicon
Trafigura condemned for exporting toxic waste
greenpeace novethic.fr favicon
Waste sent to Asia : unprecedented fine of 192 000 euros for ...novethic
lavalette.pro favicon
when the administrative judge sanctions the suppression of the collection ...lavalette
A company condemned for illegal storage of waste ... - Sudmagsudmag
environnement-magazine.fr favicon
Malaysia returns 43 containers of illegal waste to Franceenvironnement-magazine
toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr favicon
[PDF] TOULOUSE ADMINISTRATIVE COURT N° 2306402toulouse.tribunal-administatif
A waste treatment company sentenced to 200,000 € d ...fne.asso
breakfreefromplastic.org favicon
150 containers of plastic waste returned, 110 others will follow ...breakfreefromplastic
georisques.gouv.fr favicon
[PDF] Formal notice against Mr. Patrick COMBY ...georisques.gouv
Sanctions for violations of industrial waste legislationactu-justice
lemonde.fr favicon
Waste illegally shipped to Malaysia : a trading company ...lemonde
legifrance.gouv.fr favicon
Toulouse Administrative Court of Appeal - 4th Chamber - Légifrancelegifrance.gouv
Investigating the French government’s response and authorities’ involvement regarding illegal waste exports to Indonesia.
Search

Ministry of Ecological Transition Brune Poirson waste Indonesia

French government reaction to waste returned to Indonesia

French authorities illegal waste Asia
Read sources · 10
sudouest.fr favicon
Two containers of French waste rejected by Indonesia, the ...sudouest
Two containers of French waste rejected by Indonesia ...bioalaune
sciencesetavenir.fr favicon
Indonesia returns waste containers to Francesciencesetavenir
geo.fr favicon
Malaysia returns 150 containers of waste to several countries ...geo
tahiti-infos.com favicon
Waste containers returned from Indonesia : France awaits ...tahiti-infos
bfmtv.com favicon
A French company ships plastic waste to Asia - BFMTVbfmtv
dailymotion.com favicon
Indonesia returns waste containers to Francedailymotion
fr.euronews.com favicon
Container affair : Paris reacts - Euronews.comfr.euronews
Cross-border trade in waste subject to a ...statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv
rfi.fr favicon
The waste crisis in Asia "brings us face to face with our inconsistencies"rfi
Completed

# The French waste affair in Indonesia : those responsible and the issues at stake

The case of French waste returned by Indonesia in 2019 involves several levels of responsibility, from French private companies to government authorities. This crisis reveals the dysfunctions of the global plastic waste management system.

## Private actors : waste brokers and traders

### The company

A French waste brokerage company based in the south of France near Toulouse is the main culprit identified[1][2][3]. This company, whose name has not been disclosed by the authorities, was fined a record €192,000 for illegally shipping 20 containers of plastic waste to Malaysia[2][3][4]. According to some sources, it could be a single-member limited liability company with a capital of €180,000, claiming to have five employees and having achieved a turnover of €5.3 million in 2018[1].

### The role of brokers in waste trafficking

Waste brokers are intermediaries who arrange the recovery or disposal of waste on behalf of third parties[5][6]. In this case, the French company had sold the contents of containers to an Indonesian company, claiming that they were legitimate recyclable materials[7][8]. However, the Indonesian authorities considered this waste to be non-compliant and in violation of import rules[9][10].

## The French authorities and their reaction

### The Ministry of Ecological Transition

The Ministry of Ecological Transition, headed at the time by Secretary of State Brune Poirson, played a central role in managing this crisis[7][8][11]. The ministry’s services were mobilized to "provide transparency on the responsibilities - and where applicable on the infractions - of companies exporting waste containers abroad"[8].

### Measures taken by the authorities

Brune Poirson demanded that the French company return the containers to France to check their contents[7][8]. She also warned that "all companies whose cargoes are returned from the destination countries will be prosecuted in France"[4][12]. This fine of 192,000 euros is a first in France and is accompanied by a report to the courts[2][3].

## The broader context of illegal exports

### The scale of the phenomenon

In 2019, France exported 385,000 tonnes of used plastics abroad, including 60,000 tonnes to Asia[13]. This situation has worsened since China’s decision in 2018 to ban the import of the majority of plastic waste, causing "chaos in the global recycling market"[9][14][10].

### The channels of complicity

According to experts, these illegal exports often involve networks of complicity including "police, customs officers, and officials in several French ports"[15]. Containers of non-recyclable waste are declared as recyclable plastic to circumvent control procedures[13].

## Consequences and sanctions

### Financial and judicial sanctions

In addition to the administrative fine of 192,000 euros, the company responsible is subject to legal proceedings[2][3]. French law provides for penalties of up to 150,000 euros for the illegal export of hazardous waste without notification[11][16].

### Diplomatic impact

This case created a diplomatic dispute between France and Indonesia. Two containers initially rejected by Indonesia found themselves blocked in Malaysia, forcing the French authorities to negotiate their repatriation[7][8].

## Institutional actors and their role

### The National Center for Cross-Border Waste Transfers (PNTTD)

Since 2017, the PNTTD has been the competent authority in France for waste export procedures with prior notification and consent[17]. Companies must carry out their procedures via the GISTRID platform to comply with the regulations.

### The eco-organization Citeo

Citeo, the organisation responsible for recycling household packaging, claims that only 1% of the 3.5 million tonnes of recycled packaging is sent for "large-scale export"[2][18]. The organisation has strengthened its controls following this affair, particularly for Asian destinations.

The French waste scandal in Indonesia reveals a complex system where responsibilities are shared between unscrupulous private companies exploiting regulatory loopholes, French authorities who are responsive but sometimes overwhelmed by the scale of the phenomenon, and an international context disrupted by the closure of the Chinese market. This crisis marked a turning point in French waste export control policy, with exemplary sanctions and a strengthening of monitoring procedures.

[1] https://dechets-infos.com/plastiques-exportes-un-broker-sanctionne-poirson-pointe-les-recycleurs-4921181.html
[2] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/dechets-envoyes-en-asie-amende-francaise-pour-une-societe-de-courtage-une-premiere-198624
[3] https://www.latribune.fr/entreprises-finance/transitions-ecologiques/la-france-sanctionne-un-envoi-de-dechets-en-plastique-en-malaisie-833053.html
[4] https://www.lexpress.fr/monde/asie/dechets-renvoyes-en-malaisie-amende-de-192-000-euros-contre-une-societe-francaise_2107172.html
[5] https://www.enviroveille.com/public/fiches_pratiques/fiches-pratiques.html?cat_id=1&dossier_id=128836&fiche_id=109670
[6] https://faq.trackdechets.fr/dechets-dangereux-classiques/negociants-courtiers/informations-reglementaires
[7] https://www.sudouest.fr/environnement/deux-conteneurs-de-dechets-francais-refoules-par-l-indonesie-la-ministre-brune-poirson-demande-leur-retour-2487236.php
[8] https://www.bioalaune.com/fr/actualite-bio/37991/deux-conteneurs-dechets-francais-rejetes-lindonesie-actuellement-bloques-malaisie
[9] https://www.lalsace.fr/france-monde/2019/07/31/l-indonesie-renvoie-les-dechets-francais
[10] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html
[11] https://www.tahiti-infos.com/Conteneurs-de-dechets-renvoyes-d-Indonesie-la-France-attend-des-precisions_a183697.html
[12] https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/consommation/une-societe-francaise-expedie-des-dechets-plastique-en-asie-elle-ecope-d-une-grosse-amende_AN-201911140041.html
[13] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2020/09/18/de-nos-poubelles-jaunes-aux-decharges-de-malaisie-comment-une-partie-des-dechets-fraudulusement-en-asie_6052655_3244.html
[14] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/lindonesie-va-renvoi-49-conteneurs-de-dechets-en-europe-et-aux-etats-unis-196371
[15] https://www.gavroche-thailande.com/malaisie-france-qui-a-couvert-lenvoi-de-dechets-plastiques-illegaux-vers-lasie-du-sud-est/
[16] https://fr.euronews.com/2019/07/30/affaire-des-conteneurs-paris-reagit
[17] https://www.echoline.fr/blog/reglementation-exportation-dechets
[18] https://www.actu-environnement.com/ae/news/citeo-etat-exportation-dechets-recyclables-asie-34409.php4
[19]https://www.usinenouvelle.com/article/l-indonesie-refuse-d-etre-la-poubelle-du-monde-et-renvoie-des-conteneurs-vers-la-france.N871230
[20] https://www.dna.fr/environnement/2019/07/31/l-indonesie-renvoie-les-dechets-francais
[21] https://www.tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/07/29/les-importations-de-dechets-plastiques-en-indonesie
[22] https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/economie-social/monde/l-indonesie-renvoie-49-conteneurs-de-detritus-vers-la-france-l-allemagne-et-les-etats-unis_AN-201907020051.html
[23] https://www.revolutionpermanente.fr/L-Indonesie-renvoie-a-la-France-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-illegaux
[24] https://www.lejdd.fr/Societe/on-vous-explique-pourquoi-la-france-exporte-ses-dechets-en-asie-3912663
[25] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eS-nqmjxvjw
[26] https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions
[27] https://www.tresor.economie.gouv.fr/Articles/2019/04/12/veolia-indonesia-pose-la-premiere-pierre-d-une-usine-de-recyclage-du-plastique
[28] https://www.oneheart.fr/actualites/pourquoi-nos-dechets-sont-ils-envoyes-en-asie
[29] https://scrapad.com/fr/blog/obligations-legales-des-courtiers-et-negociants-en-dechet/
[30] https://www.teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorielles/10474/10474-economie-circulaire-veolia-et-danone-ont-lance-leur-usine-de-recyclage-plastique-a-lest-de-java
[31] https://www.zerowastefrance.org/export-dechets-retours-envoyeur-analyse-crise-mondiale-2-3/
[32] https://www.teamfrance-export.fr/infos-sectorielles/26991/26991-la-basd-signe-un-pret-de-442-m-usd-pour-une-usine-indonesienne-de-recyclage-de-plastique
[33] https://www.ipp.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/n64-notesIPP-avril2021.pdf
[34] https://scrapad.com/fr/blog/differences-entre-negociant-et-broker-en-dechets/
[35] https://www.veolia.com/fr/villes/indonesie-transformer-dechets-plastiques-nouvelles-ressources
[36] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/depuis-l-europe-vers-l-asie-et-inversement-l-odyssee-d-une-mysterieuse-cargaison-de-dechet-222396
[37] https://fne.asso.fr/communique-presse/exportations-illegales-de-dechets-condamnation-des-exploiters-de-la-societe-d3e
[38] https://lopinion.com/articles/actualite/20659_toulouse-collectivite-rappelee-a-lordre-collecte-dechets
[39]https://www.actu-environnement.com/ae/news/condamnation-societe-recyclage-dechets-electroniques-illegal-15087.php4
[40] https://www.seban-associes.avocat.fr/dechets-actualites-jurisprudentielles-sur-le-role-de-letat-dans-la-sanction-des-depots-sauvages/
[41] https://www.greenpeace.fr/condamnation-de-trafigura-pour-exportation-de-dechets-toxiques-un-premier-pas-vers-la-justice/
[42] https://www.novethic.fr/actualite/environnement/dechets/isr-rse/dechets-envoyes-en-asie-amende-inedite-de-192-000-euros-pour-une-societe-de-brokerage-147900.html
[43] https://www.lavalette.pro/categories/actualites-du-cabinet-19001/articles/collecte-des-dechets-menagers-quand-le-juge-administratif-sanctionne-la-suppression-de-la-collectione-en-porte-a-porte-35.htm
[44] https://sudmag.nc/2021/08/04/une-societe-condamnee-pour-stockage-illegal-de-dechets-et-non-respect-de-la-reglementation-des-installations-classees/
[45] https://www.environnement-magazine.fr/recyclage/article/2020/01/21/127530/malaisie-renvoie-43-conteneurs-dechets-illegaux-france
[46] https://toulouse.tribunal-administratif.fr/Media/mediatheque-ta-toulouse/import/2306402-ok
[47] https://fne.asso.fr/actualites/une-societe-de-traitement-de-dechets-condamnee-a-200-000-eu-d-amende
[48] https://www.breakfreefromplastic.org/fr/2020/01/21/150-containers-of-plastic-waste-shipped-back-penang-malaysia/
[49] https://georisques.gouv.fr/webappReport/ws/installations/document/8a9fb09d583eb2bd01583f0e602d0075
[50] https://www.actu-justice.fr/sanctions-pour-infractions-a-la-legislation-sur-les-dechets-industriels-un-cadre-juridique-en-evolution/
[51] https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/11/14/dechets-illegalement-envoyes-en-malaisie-une-societe-de-trading-devra-payer-192-000-euros-d-amende_6019141_3244.html
[52] https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/juri/id/CETATEXT000049744917
[53] https://www.sciencesetavenir.fr/nature-environnement/pollution/l-indonesie-renvoie-des-conteneurs-de-dechets-vers-la-france-et-hong-kong_135972
[54] https://www.geo.fr/environnement/la-malaisie-renvoie-150-conteneurs-de-dechets-vers-plusieurs-pays-dont-la-france-199534
[55] https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7es7i3
[56] https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/les-echanges-transfrontieres-de-dechets-faisant-lobjet-dune-notification-prealable-en-2022
[57]https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france

have they been identified and arrested ?

Claude :
Based on my research, here is what I can tell you about the French waste affair in Indonesia :

## **The context of the case (2019)**

Indonesia reshipped seven containers containing household waste, plastics, and hazardous materials to France and Hong Kong in violation of import rules in July 2019. This decision is part of a broader policy : Jakarta no longer wants to be a dumping ground for rich countries.

## **Lack of information on those responsible**

**No Arrests Identified** : My research has not identified any specific French officials who may have been arrested or prosecuted in connection with this affair. Articles from the time focus on the diplomatic and environmental dimensions rather than the judicial aspects.

**Official French Reaction** : The French Ministry of Ecology has requested information on the contents of the returned containers, but no public legal action has been documented.

## **A Larger Systemic Problem**

**"Waste Colonialism"** : France produces twice as much waste as the global average, and still exports a large portion of it to less wealthy countries that are less well-equipped to manage the flow of waste.

**Lack of Traceability** : Southeast Asian states are taking turns returning containers to the sender, suggesting an export system where individual responsibilities are difficult to establish.

## **Recent developments**

Indonesia will ban imports of plastic waste from 2025, which should significantly reduce this type of traffic.

The lack of identified prosecutions likely illustrates the legal complexity of these cross-border cases and the often "legal" (although ethically questionable) nature of these waste exports to Southeast Asia.

What are the consequences ?

Deepseek :
Search results
france24.com1
Indonesia sends its waste back to France, Paris wants...
31 Tem 2019 — Indonesia announced Tuesday that it was sending back to France and Hong Kong containers of waste deemed illegally imported.
lalsace.fr2
Pollution. Indonesia returns French waste
31 Tem 2019 — Two containers of waste, which arrived illegally on the Indonesian island of Batam, were returned to France on Monday by the authorities ...
20minutes.fr3
Why is France sending part of its waste ...
30 Tem 2019 — According to the authorities, they contained household waste, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of the rules of ... ifi
– id.com4
Franco-Indonesian cooperation against pollution ...
11 Ara 2024 — According to the National Plastic Action Plan (NPAP) established in 2017, the country had committed to reducing plastic waste by 30% and leaks of ...
sciencesetavenir.fr5
Two containers of French waste turned away from Indonesia ...
10 Eyl 2019 — According to the Indonesian Ministry of the Environment, a total of 20 containers were to be returned to France because they were deemed non-compliant.
franceinfo.fr6
Indonesia : French people hunt for plastics in Bali
August 18, 2023 — For two and a half years, they have installed 180 barriers. Each can intercept between 5 and 150 kg of plastic per day. The work of the ...
usinenouvelle.com7
Indonesia refuses to be the world’s trash can and returns ...
July 30, 2019 — On July 30, 2019, it announced that it had returned seven containers to France and Hong Kong, imported illegally, according to local customs.
lejdd.fr8
We explain why France exports its waste ...
August 2, 2019 — Mafias, open-air dumps, air and water pollution, respiratory diseases... Parallel sectors are developing. In ...
radiofrance.fr9
Garbage countries return waste to the sender, ...
30 Tem 2019 — Tired of being the garbage dumps of rich countries, several Asian countries have decided to return waste to their senders.
tresor.economie.gouv.fr10
The fight against marine pollution from plastic waste in ...
6 May 2019 — Indonesia is the second largest polluter of plastic waste in the oceans but is aware of the urgency of the situation to remedy the consequences ...
geo.fr11
Waste containers : Indonesia intensifies returns to ...
4 Eyl 2019 — On the Indonesian island of Batam near Singapore, 49 non-compliant waste containers were seized and returned to the United States, the ...
franceinfo.fr12
Indonesia returns its plastic waste to France
8 Tem 2019 — Indonesia refuses to become the world’s trash can. 49 containers stuffed with plastic waste and hazardous materials from several countries ...
lapresse.ca13
Indonesia will return waste to Europe and the ...
2 Tem 2019 — The 49 containers will contain rubbish, plastic waste and hazardous substances in violation of import rules, according to ...
ici.radio-canada.ca14
The drift of plastic waste tracked by satellite in ...
4 Ara 2020 — This waste represents a danger for hundreds of marine species and birds and a still little-studied risk for human health via ...
lemonde.fr15
Indonesia returns waste to France ...
30 Tem 2019 — These containers contained household waste, plastic waste and hazardous materials in violation of import rules, according to ...
plasticodyssey.org16
Waste collection and pre-treatment in Kendari, Indonesia ...
1 Tem 2024 — In Indonesia, despite several laws governing waste management and recycling since 2008, their application remains uneven depending on the re ...
veolia.com17
Preserving the marine ecosystem in Indonesia - Veolia
In Indonesia, transforming plastic waste into new resources. Veolia is building the country’s largest plastic bottle recycling plant ...
meretmarine.com18
French teams are working on the drift of ...
25 Eyl 2020 — The first results have shown that 90% of waste washes up on the coast, according to a CLS press release. "This is a good ...
fr.euronews.com19
Indonesia returns containers of waste ...
30 Tem 2019 — After China in 2018, Malaysia and the Philippines last May, Indonesia has just returned

Hmm, I see the user is wondering about the consequences of the French waste in Indonesia affair. Browsing the search results, I see several articles discussing this incident that occurred in 2019.
Among the key elements, I note that Indonesia returned two containers of waste to France, containing household waste, plastics, and even hazardous materials, in violation of import regulations. 12 This waste had been shipped by a French brokerage company and transited through Malaysia before its return. 5
Diplomatically, the affair created tensions between the two countries. Brune Poirson, then French Secretary of State, demanded the return of the containers for investigation. 15 Indonesia took the opportunity to toughen its stance against illegal waste imports, joining other Asian countries such as Malaysia and the Philippines in this movement. 7
Economically, this incident revealed the fragility of the French waste management system. The articles explain that exporting to Asia cost only 5 to 10 euros per ton, compared to 30,000 euros in France. 3 This practice was motivated by purely financial considerations.
The affair also highlighted environmental problems in Indonesia, with initiatives like OceanKita attempting to combat plastic pollution. 46 The country produces 6.8 million tons of plastic waste annually, much of which ends up in the ocean. 4
I will organize my response around these different aspects : diplomatic, regulatory, economic, environmental, and media. I will also mention the cooperative initiatives that have emerged following this crisis, such as joint cleanup projects.
The user seems to be looking for a comprehensive analysis rather than a simple summary. Perhaps they are interested in the broader implications of the international waste trade. I will therefore include elements on the evolution of environmental policies in both countries since this incident.

The 2019 case of French waste returned by Indonesia had multidimensional consequences, exposing flaws in the international waste management system and accelerating political, environmental, and economic changes. Here is a detailed analysis of the impacts :
⚖️ 1. Diplomatic crisis and international tensions

Official request for clarification : French Secretary of State Brune Poirson demanded clarification on the nature of the waste (hazardous or not) and its route, highlighting the opacity of the export channels 15.

Destabilization of relations : The return of the containers (initially shipped by a French brokerage company) was perceived as a violation of international rules, forcing France to react to avoid an escalation 57.

Asian solidarity : Indonesia has joined Malaysia, the Philippines, and China in a regional push to reject being the West’s "dustbin," also sending waste to Australia, the United States, and Germany.

🛑 2. Regulatory tightening and increased controls

Deterrent sanctions : France has threatened companies exporting illegal waste with fines of up to €150,000, aimed at making producers accountable 15.

Audits of the sectors : The French authorities have intensified controls on waste exports, requiring their repatriation for analysis (e.g. : containers diverted to Malaysia) 5.

Impact on European legislation : This incident fueled debates leading to the ban on single-use plastics in the EU in 2021, and prompted a rethink of the circular economy 78.

💸 3. Economic disruptions and limits of recycling

Revelation of a costly dependency : Massive exports (250,000 tonnes of French plastic in 2017) were motivated by derisory costs (€5-10/tonne in Asia vs €30,000/tonne in France) 38.

Post-China market crisis : China’s import blockade in 2018 shifted flows to Southeast Asia, saturating countries with limited sorting capacity and triggering massive returns 17.

Technical challenges : The exported waste was often "low-end" plastics (e.g. composite packaging) which were not recyclable in their current state, ending up in illegal dumps or burned, generating pollution and local mafias 38.

🌱 4. Ecological awareness and local initiatives

Indonesian mobilization : The country has accelerated its National Plastic Action Plan aiming for a 70% reduction in marine litter by 2025, with river cleanups (e.g., Ciliwung project collecting 66 kg of plastic/day) 46.

Franco-Indonesian initiatives : Projects such as OceanKita (supported by France) have emerged, combining coastal clean-up, awareness raising and strengthening local communities (e.g. : mangrove planting in Untung Jawa) 46.

Media impact : The case exposed environmental damage (soil pollution, microplastics in the food chain), catalyzing citizen action (e.g., the Sungai Watch association in Bali intercepting 150 kg of plastic/day) 64.

🗣️ 5. Media repercussions and pressure on manufacturers

Criticism from NGOs : Zero Waste France has denounced the "illusion of recycling" and advocated for the reduction of waste at source, via a "penalty" on over-packaging 38.

Calls for responsibility : Food industries have been targeted for their excessive use of complex packaging, pushing them to review their practices 3.

Public awareness : The media widely reported the incident, symbolizing the inconsistencies of the "circularity" of waste and the need for local treatment 8.

🔄 Conclusion : Towards a systemic reconfiguration

The affair has accelerated the rethinking of the waste export model, revealing its environmental inefficiency and geopolitical risks. It has spurred local innovation (recycling in France, remediation projects in Indonesia) and strengthened bilateral cooperation around sustainable objectives. However, challenges persist : Indonesia is struggling to meet its waste reduction targets, and France has yet to develop viable recycling channels for complex plastics. This crisis remains a key catalyst for a truly circular economy.

L’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie
jeudi 24 juillet 2025
par Dark Funifuteur
popularité : 0%

détailles moi l’affaire des déchets français en Indonésie

**Conséquences et enseignements**

— -

Citations

Plus

**Consequences and Lessons Learned**

— -

**Dampak dan Pelajaran yang Didapat**

— -

quelles en sont les suites ?

Grok :
Réflexions

France 24 - L’Indonésie renvoie ses déchets à la France, Paris veut des précisions

Ouest-France - L’Indonésie renvoie à la France ses déchets illégalement importés

Ces sources confirment les détails de l’incident et les actions prises par l’Indonésie, ainsi que la réaction de la France.

### Réponse directe

— -

### Note détaillée

#### Tableau récapitulatif des actions et conséquences
**Aspect** **Détails** **Source**

----------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Retour des déchets 2 conteneurs renvoyés vers la France en 2019, contenant déchets dangereux. *Le Monde* ([https://www.lemonde.fr/planete/article/2019/07/30/l-indonesie-renvoie-vers-la-france-des-dechets-illegalement-importes_5494837_3244.html])
Réaction française Demande d’informations, pas d’amende rapportée pour cet incident. *France 24* ([https://www.france24.com/fr/20190731-indonesie-renvoie-dechets-francais-france-paris-attend-precisions])
Contexte international Mouvement régional de refus, avec retours similaires vers d’autres pays. *Geo.fr* ([https://www.geo.fr/environnement/conteneurs-de-dechets-lindonesie-intensifie-les-retours-a-lenvoyeur-197356])
Impact politique en France Projet de loi anti-gaspillage en 2019, mais lien incertain avec l’incident. *RFI* ([https://www.rfi.fr/fr/asie-pacifique/20190804-crise-dechets-asie-incoherences-thibault-turchet-zero-waste-indonesie-france])